5 ms·
>Otherwise, frankly, academics arguing over what has no consequence will have no consequence outside the circles of those who argue over it. Sociology is mostl
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
>Otherwise, frankly, academics arguing over what has no consequence will have no consequence outside the circles of those who argue over it.
Sociology is mostly a series of status games played by academics. It's part of the humanities, which means the methods of play are peer group signalling and persuasive story-telling, not reality testing.
It's not engineering, where models actually have to predict reality with at least a minimal baseline of accuracy and reliability.
Engineers don't have a problem with nuance, and are suspicious of toy models that don't include details - because they're just not useful.
If you model flight characteristics for an airliner but don't deal with edge cases, the plane can fall out of the sky.
If you offer a grand social theory of X but get the details wrong, no one really cares, because sociologists have very little influence on practical policy, and the influence they do have is carefully chosen for political applicability by non-sociologists.
Occasionally useful insights fall out of social psychology and sociology. But they have limited applicability because our understanding of social psychology is pre-Newtonian - some things seem to work, but no one is really sure why - and our understanding of politics and economics is barbaric and barely better than medieval, on a good day.
- danharaj 11y agoYour entire post is a series of sociological assertions about academics and engineers without scientific evidence. I'm sure the irony was intentional.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoThat entire post can be reduced to two core assertions: 1) Details matter in engineering because products will actually be manufactured according to those details and if the details are wrong then planes would fall out of the sky. (Which we know they rarely do.) 2) Details don't matter in social theory because practitioners don't use academic theories to make policy. The theories can't be tested because they aren't used. Most social science "theories" are therefore a hypothesis without an experiment. The only statement about people or social behavior is that engineers put their theories into practice with more frequency and rigor than sociologists, which is empirically true.