5 ms·
I think there's a lot of assumptions about the Prez being dumb here that aren't warranted. From the perspective of the FBI, free encryption tools like PGP have
by mike_hearn 11y ago
I think there's a lot of assumptions about the Prez being dumb here that aren't warranted.
From the perspective of the FBI, free encryption tools like PGP have been around a long time, but they only started having investigations blocked by encryption very recently, as Valley tech firms started integrating it and enabling it by default. Even if the Prez knows that encryption tools have been available for decades, and I suspect he does, that isn't the cause of the current problems they're having.
With respect to getting warranted access to encrypted data, key escrow is an old concept, so of course there is. Just because we in the tech community don't like it doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
- studentrob 11y ago> With respect to getting warranted access to encrypted data, key escrow is an old concept, so of course there is. Just because we in the tech community don't like it doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Okay, let's say key escrow is used. There will be a lot of debate and new laws passed by Congress. After this, who in the public do you think will sign up to use the products Apple admits has been weakened by government? I think the public will just become more informed about encryption and more people will end up using various encryption apps that circumvent whatever measures the government puts in place with Apple. In other words, it'll be a big waste of time, and the main target, terrorists, will be the first ones to figure out the right ways to hide their communications.
- aptwebapps 11y ago> After this, who in the public do you think will sign up to use the products Apple admits has been weakened by government? Nearly all of the people who would have otherwise bought those products.
- studentrob 11y agoPerhaps. Either way my larger concern is the message being sent to law enforcement by the higher ups. I mentioned this in another comment. Plus the fact that terrorists will be the first to use other encryption tech. So, yeah, it is a waste of time and the reason can only be that our higher ups are misinformed. I don't see any good reason they would know all this and lie about it. So they can catch a few common criminals? So they can fail at catching the smart terrorists? It doesn't add up.
- yaur 11y agoWhile that's undoubtedly true domestically, I have to belive that openly requiring a backdoor is going to hurt Apple and the rest of the US tech sector in the rest of the world.
- 794CD01 11y agoWhy is that? Other countries want their own law enforcement to be able to break the encryption used in their countries just as badly as the US does. That's close to 95% of the reason Blackberry still exists.
- samsolomon 11y agoI assure you that most who buy an iPhone (or any product) don't consider security in their purchase decision. Security isn't a visible feature. Brand, design, usability, camera quality and a dozen other things will come before that.
- jerf 11y ago"I think there's a lot of assumptions about the Prez being dumb here that aren't warranted." The $PRESIDENT is dumb about encryption, though. I don't mean Obama specifically; I mean, we have probably never elected anyone who could really understand this problem, we probably never will, and even if we ever do elect someone who could theoretically do it there's no way they will ever be able to break out enough time to come to a deep, independent understanding of their own in the face of all the other fires they are dealing with on a daily basis.
- ethbro 11y agoThis is what terrifies me. We're potentially about to elect (assuming the primaries stay the course) one of (a) a gentleman who thinks that technology can magically just do anything asked of it or (b) a lady whose desire to use a personal Blackberry led to (at best) ignoring basic information security risks. Despite my political leanings, and as much as I hate to admit it, I'm tempted to choose the pragmatic candidate with a business degree over the ignorant candidate with a law degree. Btw, what is it with lawyers mistaking laws for truths? They seem to look at the world through some bizarre Borges lens where physics needs follow law instead of the other way around.
- studentrob 11y ago> Btw, what is it with lawyers mistaking laws for truths? They seem to look at the world through some bizarre Borges lens where physics needs follow law instead of the other way around. Haha. I don't think anyone is trying to legislate that gravity lighten up so we can use less fuel to move around. ;-) I'd venture it's because technology and science moved so quickly that many people still don't understand things that you consider basic. For example, I have a lot of respect for people who are artistic and spiritual. I recently tried out meditation and realized there's a whole world I've been missing. I think the same can be said of science. Some people just don't want to learn it. That should be alright within our current system. But, in cases like this where the technology (encryption + internet) goes from near zero usage 20 years ago to more than 50% usage today, it's tough to make sure our government gets it. The average age of our representatives is around 58, so none grew up with the internet or computers. And, it's been made so easy that you didn't need to understand it to use it. So we have many people using something that most don't understand. And we have not yet been in many situations where our civil rights depend upon having representatives who understand it. I'm probably oversimplifying but that's how I make sense of it. The way forward is to educate the public and our representatives. Hopefully over time we have more people in office who either understand such critical security issues themselves, or have a connection to someone who does.