5 ms·
Bitcoin's problem is not a lack of a leader, it's problem is that the leader is Gregory Maxwell at Blockstream and he's a terrible decision maker. Blockstream i
by mike_hearn 11y ago
Bitcoin's problem is not a lack of a leader, it's problem is that the leader is Gregory Maxwell at Blockstream and he's a terrible decision maker. Blockstream is the source of the refusal to bump the block size.
Indeed, the block size debate did not stalemate. It resulted in the small blockists winning, due to the much more aggressive tactics they used (e.g. hiring a bunch of developers then asserting they'd all quit forever if the block size were changed).
- tortionisgood 11y agoWhy don't you quit your whining and go back to work at R3, or did you just get a job to whine about bitcoin? Blockstream employs a small minority of Core devs. You lost, most holders of bitcoin did not want to follow the direction you laid out, be a grown man and deal with it.
- cyberdexter 11y agoFact is that Blockstream is walling the code changes for numerous (selfish) reasons. However, Mike's opinions are irrelevant since he's been corrupted as well.
- readysetmain 11y agoInstead of childish name calling why not try to encourage a system of several independent working groups building their own clients and negotiating between these groups what the spec should be, like any other protocol does? I hope the answer doesn't relate to your current investments.
- BitcoinErrorLog 11y agoWho's Mike Hearn? Why does his opinion matter?
- cyberdexter 11y agoit doesn't. Not any more.
- cyberdexter 11y agoMike, the entire drama is ridiculous. However, you've turned your back on BTC because XT was rejected to go and work for R3 to put our tech back into the hands of the people we wanted to get away from. If BTC and everything that "could" come with it was so important to you then you should have stayed and fought the fight. Instead you decided to join R3,so let go and move on.
- trevelyan 11y agoBlockstream is developing bitcoin into a bank settlement network (that the banks won't use). Maybe you should focus your ire there, instead of on the guy who has actually pushed open source and consumer-grade P2P payment systems miles forward.
- arsenische 11y agoDo you think Bitcoin Classic has chances to succeed? It looks like their hashing power is growing: http://nodecounter.com/#block_explorer http://nodecounter.com/#block_explorer
- bachback 11y agoBitcoin's technical problems are that it fundamentally does not scale. If each node has to verify all transactions that is not sustainable in the long term. Hal Finney knew this way back: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2500.msg34211#msg34211 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2500.msg34211#msg342... "Bitcoin itself cannot scale to have every single financial transaction in the world be broadcast to everyone and included in the block chain. There needs to be a secondary level of payment systems which is lighter weight and more efficient."
- arsenische 11y agoTrue, but we are not there yet. Bitcoin can probably scale 20x times without a problem. That would be 20 times lower transaction fees and 20 times more people using it.
- SkyMarshal 11y agoIt can't scale 20x without running into decentralization problems. http://fc16.ifca.ai/bitcoin/papers/CDE+16.pdf http://fc16.ifca.ai/bitcoin/papers/CDE+16.pdf Most large blockers are running businesses that depend on no/low fees, plus the reddit mob that goes with whatever argument sounds most conspiratorial (aka Blockstream sabotaging Bitcoin for sidechains).
- arsenische 11y agoThanks for the article. But I don't see where it says that Bitcoin can't scale 20x without decentralization problems. I see that "the block size should not exceed 4MB for X=90%; and 38MB for X=50%", but I don't think that 50% reduction of number of nodes would be a serious decentralization problem (we've seen a similar reduction already due to the implementation of SPV clients). Mining centralization could be a bigger problem, but with headers-first mining the block size wouldn't contribute to it. Also the authors of the article assume the use of Bitcoin’s current peer-to-peer overlay network, that can be drastically optimized. I've chosen 20x because Gavin had conducted 20Mb tests more than a year ago, before many optimizations took place. There is nothing bad in the low fees. Low fees is the marketing strategy to boost the usage of Bitcoin and create the large enough ecosystem. Miners are being subsidised by bitcoin holders for a reason. Larger the blocks while preserving a reasonable degree of decentralization -> lower the fees per transaction -> more people use Bitcoin -> more valuable the bitcoin ecosystem is -> higher the price of bitcoin -> mining is more profitable -> stable and secure infrastructure for the new global economy.
- terranix 11y agoI thought you were out of Bitcoin?
- jron 11y agoMike Hearn works for a bank. Gregory Maxwell works for a group of cypherpunks. I'll take my chances with Bitcoin. Thanks for bitcoinj though.
- explorer666 11y agoLook at the list of investors. Banks invested in Blockstream.
- jron 11y agoI never said banks don't know how to hedge.
- explorer666 11y agoThat's not hedging. They are paying to kill Bitcoin.
- explorer666 11y agoSo many new users just to attack you Mike. And all the buttcoin trolls suddenly became small blockers. Evidence of Blockstream hiring shills continues to grow.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- smartfbrankings 11y agoDidn't you whiny ragequit already?
- 29a 11y agostfu, hearn, you got dang'd troll you
- httpagent 11y agoI've noticed a "know-nothing" strategy recently adopted by blockchain core - basically, the ideas is that community members claim that everyone who isn't part of core development is naive and has no valid position in debating the future of bitcoin. These users speak with pride about leaving social communities because of their ignorance. It reminds me a lot of the Fox news listeners who deride world media as liars. Here's an example of the proud know-nothingness. The interesting part begins at 17:30. The speaker, Julia Tourianski, makes a fair attack against Mike Hearn for his departure, but then she goes on to point out that developers are faced with low morale because the community doesn't support their work. The conversation then moves to leaving Reddit and other media because "the trolls" (presumably persons who are in favor of a blocksize increase) have taken over. https://soundcloud.com/heryptohow/julia-tourianski-john-dilley-of-blockstream-and-lyn-kirk-ulbricht https://soundcloud.com/heryptohow/julia-tourianski-john-dill...
- LAMike 11y agoDo you find it strange that Bitcoin is the same price it was ever since you said it was dead?
- muyuu 11y agoIt went great.