3 ms·
Other than graphics, is there anything available over PCIe that isn't available over USB?
by aidenn0 11y ago
Other than graphics, is there anything available over PCIe that isn't available over USB?
- woodman 11y agoAny sensor activity that is sensitive to inconsistent latency, like a GPS time source. I don't think you'll find any trusted stratum 1 ntp servers using USB for clock sources.
- mahyarm 11y agoSo use GPIO?
- woodman 11y agoFor this specific device? Sure, but that wasn't the question that I was answering.
- aidenn0 11y agoRight, any low-latency low-bandwith application can use GPIO (or in the case of audio, isochronous USB); high-bandwidth non-latency-sensitive applications use USB. This leaves just latency-sensitive high-bandwith applications, of which the most common is video.
- wtallis 11y agoJust because you can do it over USB doesn't mean you should. PCIe gets you more bandwidth and vastly better latency, and the peripherals that use PCIe tend to be higher quality and have better drivers than their USB competition. Just compare any USB NIC against Intel Ethernet or Atheros WiFi, or NVMe and AHCI devices against the mess that is UASP. You can't build a decent router or NAS around USB devices. (And DisplayLink offers graphics over USB, but it's so bad that in almost any other context it should be regarded as not counting.)
- greglindahl 11y agoDisplayLink has a large number of customers, so obviously it works well enough for a lot of use-cases. I've used it for status displays, and the additional monitors that most engineers like to have. I can't even remember which one of the two monitors in my home office is DisplayLink. I'd imagine that I'd notice if I tried to play a game...
- hinkley 11y agoOn quite a few of these devices, some of the 'on board' connectors are running over USB as well, so they'll never perform even though they're soldered.
- hinkley 11y agoTCP/IP over PCIe is a hell of a lot faster than USB, for one. Peripheral management is better as well.