5 ms·
Wow, great publicity for Ethereum. Except, they can't ever bring themselves to explain what it does, or what it means. We're missing the 'why'.
by zaroth 11y ago
Wow, great publicity for Ethereum. Except, they can't ever bring themselves to explain what it does, or what it means. We're missing the 'why'.
- natrius 11y agoBlockchains are peer-to-peer cloud computers that collectively enforce a set of rules on a historical record that they create together. If the rules meet your needs, you can use a blockchain’s history as the source of truth for any information you want because no one can break those rules. Bitcoin’s rules define a currency: how are new tokens produced, how many are allowed, how they can be transferred from one person to another, etc. Ethereum’s rules define a process for defining new rules. This makes it a universal blockchain where rules for any interaction can be defined, and anyone can choose whether to treat its historical record as their source of truth. We're in the process of defining economic interactions—both existing and novel interactions—as entries in a digital historical record to eliminate the need for middlemen in much of our economy and give everyone access to financial tools that were once limited to the wealthy and their corporations. Social interactions that don't involve money can be built as well. Join us. Let's build software that users control.
- Anonobread 11y agoUsers don't control cloud software.
- natrius 11y agoRules in blockchain-based software cannot change ex post facto. The only decision involved is the user's choice to use the application in the first place. These are user-controlled applications. (I've tried explaining these as applications that no one controls, but that has a wild west connotation that isn't applicable.)
- Anonobread 11y agoMy point is running all the nodes in the cloud means that the users of those nodes don't own them. > the user's choice to use the application in the first place. Right, but if none of the users can even run the so called "peer-to-peer" component, what's the difference between that and run-of-the-mill centralized DB software? Either way nobody but the chosen few can directly access the DB.
- natrius 11y agoWith blockchains, only the user has write access to the database with their cryptographic identity. Users are in full control. Users can run a node of the peer-to-peer component if they want. Anyone can. They just don't have to.
- Anonobread 11y ago> With blockchains, only the user has write access to the database with their cryptographic identity. Users are in full control. That trait is far from being unique to blockchains. But no, users aren't in full control of cloud software. > Users can run a node of the peer-to-peer component if they want. Anyone can. They just don't have to. After 18 months of block size debate, this is deja vu. No, anyone can't run a node if you make it cost $5k/mo
- nix_said 11y agoYou are clearly talking to an Ethereum investor and not a programmer. A large part of the Ethereum hype is using blockchains where they are woefully the wrong tool for the job.
- natrius 11y agoHaha, you didn't even take the effort to look at my profile. I write code. Like many Ethereum developers, I own ether. My comments apply to any EVM-based blockchain, and there will be many.
- brenfrow 11y agoThe why is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j23HnORQXvs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j23HnORQXvs Its meant to be a world computer. However currently every node runs every contract, so it can only be as fast as one node. They will fix this in the future. Remember we are only in the very beginning.
- readysetmain 11y agoThey hope to fix this in the future. However their answer is sharding which also may make the system less decentralized and trustless.
- adrianmacneil 11y agoVitalik explained it pretty well at a recent talk he did at Coinbase: Ethereum is a world computer. As in, it acts like a single public computer that can perform computations for anyone who is willing to pay for them, but instead of this computer being run by a third party, it's run by the network as a whole. This is useful for any situation where you would usually need a trusted third party to perform some computations or enforce one side of a bargain - for example ecommerce/escrow, trading, voting, bets, issuing stock/currency, plus other things that probably have not even been thought of yet. I agree, it can be a pretty wishy-washy mission statement at times. But then again, so was the idea of a global communications network where anyone could communicate with everyone and publish their own content in the 1980s.
- Anonobread 11y ago> Ethereum is a world computer. As in, it acts like a single public computer that can perform computations for anyone who is willing to pay for them, but instead of this computer being run by a third party, it's run by the network as a whole. Compared to actual Python code, or Ruby code, or any code that you can imagine, Ethereum VM code is a hobbled down child's toy. Think: Gameboy from 1995. The memory is scant. The performance, abysmal. > This is useful for any situation where you would usually need a trusted third party to perform some computations or enforce one side of a bargain - for example ecommerce/escrow, trading, voting, bets, issuing stock/currency, plus other things that probably have not even been thought of yet. You can do all of those things with Bitcoin. We don't promote it much because no one has cared to use any of it for years. It's always hooked in investors, though. Lots and lots of investors.
- lololomg 11y agoThe bit that I don't get is how Ethereum will communicate with the outside world. Example: I bet a friend that Hillary will be the next president. We create an Ethereum app/contract/whatever and fund it with $50 (worth of 'ether') each. When the election rolls around, we want to pay the winner automatically, but how can you do that? You could have a rule to check some 'official' source on the internet but that data could easily be faked or unavailable. Then what? If this kind of app is not suited to Etherium, then what are some good examples of Etherium's capabilities?
- throwaway859360 11y agoIn computer security I've often heard the saying there is no security without physical security. This means if somebody can access the hardware running your program you can't trust the outcome. That's why you have to lock your servers away and trust the people who have the key. Ethereum solves this problem by creating truly virtual machine that does not have physical location. If somebody wants to tamper with the execution there is no address to drive to or datacenter to cut power from. Even service providers themselves can prove that they have locked themselves out. Without ethereum you just have to take their word for it. This all comes with caveats. Radical transparency, everyone can see your code and when it is running. Cost, you need to pay for every instruction to keep the system running and to prevent spamming. It's a shared resource, you need to wait for your turn and the computer is very slow. Is there usecase for such contraption remains to be seen.