4 ms·
Don't put any effort into it...I'm not that interested since I don't care what outside beliefs someone has at a technical conference as long as they leave them
by tzs 11y ago
Don't put any effort into it...I'm not that interested since I don't care what outside beliefs someone has at a technical conference as long as they leave them outside (and the conference rules of conduct either prohibit others from bringing them up or allow one to defend their outside beliefs if others bring them up).
I've read one or two of his walls of text, but kind of fogged out a bit due to the length so was more skimming than reading closely in many parts.
Generally, when I ask someone for a citation it is because I want to know if they have done their homework, or are just repeating what they read on some blog or forum.
If you say he is racist, I have no doubt you have checked for yourself, and if I did ask you for cites you'd give ones that strongly backed your points.
The person I was responding too...not so much. I was not impressed with his response.
From what you said here and elsewhere, it sounds like there are three levels to understanding Yarvin. At the first level, you see some statements about things like slavery that seem in isolation to be pretty bad.
At the second level, when you check for context of those specific statements, they seem reasonable. E.g., slavery as a natural human relationship. Given how long widespread slavery lasted in human history, it is hard to say that it is not natural. The key at level two is to realize that recognizing something as natural does not imply one thinks it is good. I'd say much of human advancement comes from deciding that we will NOT do things that are natural, because often natural behavior maximizes short term or local gain over long term or widespread gain. Hence, we have banned for good reason various natural behaviors such as slavery, rape, revenge killings, genocide against conquered people, and so on.
Then there is the third level, apparently, where you go deeper and decide that he really is racist underneath.
I've went to level two. You are at level three. The person I was responding to appears to be either at level one, or perhaps at level two but applying faulty logic (e.g., it was democratic governments that outlawed slavery, and Yarvin is against democracy, therefore Yarvin is in favor of slavery).
- KirinDave 11y ago> Generally, when I ask someone for a citation it is because I want to know if they have done their homework, or are just repeating what they read on some blog or forum. Quick.... quick question. Wouldn't that have been the kind of foundation research you were asking for and hoping for in the first place? And didn't I provide specific blog posts by the man in question w.r.t. his views on race relations? Unless of course, your entire request was a disingenuous attempt to derail the conversation. But now I'm being silly! Of course, that's exactly what you're saying it is. I appreciate how you freely admit that you aren't actually interested in evidence, you were just hoping to derail me. Your honesty is refreshing. > The person I was responding too...not so much. I was not impressed with his response. Have a nice day. Better luck next time on your astroturfing.
- tzs 11y ago> And didn't I provide specific blog posts by the man in question w.r.t. his views on race relations? I asked for a citation on the claim that he has called for the enslavement of black people. I specifically mentioned that I had seem him talk about how some groups were better slaves than others, and linked to a thread within his recent AMA. You responded with a link to his blog where he said that slavery is a natural human relationship. I followed that link, searched for the places where he said slavery was a natural human relationship--and found nothing in those parts of the blog post where he called for enslavement or even said that it was a good thing. Your second point was that he has said he is "amenable to white nationalist writings", and you cited a blog entry where he talked about this. There is no mention of slavery in that blog entry, and a bit of Googling has failed to turn up a connection between white nationalists and any advocacy for slavery. You also brought up, without providing a cite, that he has discussed the suitability of different races for slavery. I had already noted that, since it was in the discussion from the AMA that I cited. In that discussion it was clear that he meant "suitability" in the sense that they work out better from the slaver's point of view. If one group of people tend to die when enslaved, and another tends to live, then the later are more suitable. Believing that doesn't imply that one believes that the second group should be slaves or that one supports slavery.
- KirinDave 11y ago> I asked for a citation on the claim that he has called for the enslavement of black people. I specifically mentioned that I had seem him talk about how some groups were better slaves than others, and linked to a thread within his recent AMA. Which we've established is his MO, which you've accepted from other sources without any claim at all. > You responded with a link to his blog where he said that slavery is a natural human relationship. I followed that link, searched for the places where he said slavery was a natural human relationship--and found nothing in those parts of the blog post where he called for enslavement or even said that it was a good thing. The entire discussion was about how good Carlyle's work on slavery was. The entire subject matter is a defense of the use of slavery and in particular black people as slaves. Which he was defending and promoting, as he then directly said slavery was a natural human relationship. > There is no mention of slavery in that blog entry, and a bit of Googling has failed to turn up a connection between white nationalists and any advocacy for slavery. I do not believe you did this. If you did you would see that it would at its core remove citizenship rights and protections from everyone not identified as 'white.' The primary goal is the deportation or detainment of the resident black population of America. > You also brought up, without providing a cite, that he has discussed the suitability of different races for slavery. You had accepted this as a prior condition and mentioned the AMA. Am I obligated to cite your sources now? > Believing that doesn't imply that one believes that the second group should be slaves or that one supports slavery. You know, a few people told me you were a good person to talk to. That you were one of the better commenters on HN. But this level of deliberate, defensive obtuseness is a great example of someone frantically putting their head in the sand. Maybe you should ask the other person in this thread who you trust implicitly if I'm wrong about this. Either way, your judgement of my methodology and the degree to which you require me to spoonfeed you the vile substance of this conversation is immaterial to me. We've defunded Lambdaconf and picked up the sponsors to Moonconf. Mission complete.