4 ms·
Cool project, although I would not advise using dashcams if you are involved in an accident the police can subpoena the footage which could potentially be used
by dogma1138 11y ago
Cool project, although I would not advise using dashcams if you are involved in an accident the police can subpoena the footage which could potentially be used against you (in both criminal and civil suits).
If you do run a dashcam I would suggest having one that does not record audio and only keeps the last 5-10min of footage on record because GL explaining to the cops why you have been driving like a jackass just before the accident even if it had nothing to do with it.
- swsieber 11y agoConversely, if you're a responsible driver then it prove that you are in the right.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fapjacks 11y agoRight. It's no accident (badum-psh!) that Russia and China are full of expensive cars with dashcams. Or even just regular cars with dashcams. The benefits far outweigh the penalties for the vast majority of dashcam users.
- dogma1138 11y agoDashcams in Russia are used because there is a huge problem with insurance fraud people would just either get hit intentionally or even jump on the hood of standing cars and claim they were hit. The police and the legal system in Russia wouldn't care about your dashcam if you want to get out a of a jam a bribe would work just fine (I've been pulled over in plenty of places where I had to pay dues, mostly Asia - Thailand, Philippines, Burma but it's not that uncommon in Russia and some Balkan states either), insurance companies on the other hand do like them very much.
- fapjacks 11y agoI am really wondering why you are pushing so hard against dashcams. Dashcams (along with bodycams) are making corruption in the justice system much harder to pull off. You can find a ton of videos on YouTube exposing corruption in law enforcement around the world, including the United States. This is not mass surveillance! This is a personal record of travel that isn't vacuumed up into the warrantless surveillance machine and twisted to serve an evil purpose (like Verizon's call record database, among many others). Your argument -- that your video could be subpoenaed and you might have to explain why you were driving like a jackass -- is weak to the point that I am beginning to suspect an ulterior motive. Why are you pushing so hard against dashcams?
- dogma1138 11y agoNothing wrong with having a camera to record when you are being pulled over, having a device that constantly records everything and is pretty much turned on by default is disadvantageous to both your privacy and your interests. I've also said that I personally would recommend a dash cam which records the last 5 min and no audio, this should be enough as a deterrent and will allow you to provide any evidence if required while not keeping anything on the record that could damage you. And please do not compare dashcams to bodycams, because ?I'm pretty sure you would not want to live in a world where everyone is wearing a bodycam that is recording 24/7, or even suggest people to walk on the street while recording everything with their phones. When you make a record of anything you should be aware that what ever you document can be used against you, or against another party at any time and that your agency to maintain the privacy of that record is limited both from a legal and practical point of view.
- fapjacks 11y agoUhm. Bodycams -- specifically that term, "bodycams" -- have exactly one context right now, and that's the context in which law enforcement wears them while on duty. And I do think that bodycams are a great thing that should be required as part of being a law enforcement officer on duty. You still haven't explained yourself beyond the same old "what you record can be used against you" argument, which as I've said before, is weak. I think this will be my last reply, since there is absolutely nothing being gained here in this discussion.
- dogma1138 11y agoI haven't met a single person who doesn't go above the speed limit (to a reasonable amount) or misses a give way or stop sign once in a while.
- swsieber 11y agoWell, if you're at fault, then fess up. If your are more responsible than most, then statistically, a dash cam will be on your side. And judging from this thread, that shouldn't be too hard.
- nerdy 11y agoSpeed, okay... and sometimes it's safer going faster than the posted limit (IE with the flow of traffic). However, if you're missing stop signs, you're definitely doing something wrong - either driving too fast or not paying attention.
- gherkin0 11y ago> However, if you're missing stop signs, you're definitely doing something wrong - either driving too fast or not paying attention. Lots of people will slow down significantly (say to <10mph), but not stop completely, if no one seems to be there.
- nerdy 11y agoSounds different from "missing" stop signs. Sadly, I see people come to rolling stops at most stop signs... so much so that it makes me feel like I'm the only one wasting my time doing it right. It's one of the many things that make me wild about the idea of letting computers do the driving. Zipper-merging, slowing to time lights instead of stopping, and no rubbernecking are wonders of the future I can't wait to enjoy.
- pravda 11y agoYou might not be doing it 'right'. Most stop signs just mean slow down. If there is no traffic, you should not come to a full stop.
- Zombieball 11y agoHow long does it take for them to subpoena you? That is if I were in an accident, and they don't physically confiscate the memory drive, could you extract any video that supports your case and delete the rest before they request it? I figure this happens with police dashcams and bodycams all the time.
- dogma1138 11y agoIf the police is on the scene they don't even need a subpoena they can search the car and confiscate the memory card. If you destroy the contents of the card it doesn't look good, that fact can be brought up against you (tampering with a car that was involved in an accident especially one with casualties could potentially be a crime on it's own). If you present only the snippets that support your case the other party will petition the court to for you to present the unedited video if you cannot the entire thing will most likely be thrown out (the other side might be able to present the fact that you have attempted to present an edited video and have discarded the raw footage which will likely not fair well with a jury). Not to mention that having the video it self could put you at risk of perjury or being found in contempt if you try to do anything after the fact.
- lr4444lr 11y agoThey need probable cause to do that in most places. Also, there's nothing stopping you from quickly dismounting it before you pull over and shoving it under the seat, saying you don't have it if asked what the dangling wire is, and refuse to consent to a search if the officer doesn't believe you. If your car is forcibly searched anyway, it will almost surely be inadmissible, and might even help your whole charge get thrown out.
- dogma1138 11y agoI was pretty clear that I am referencing only cases when a vehicular accident has occurred in that case they have all the probable cause they need. BTW if the officer doesn't believe you it could lead to a probable cause, please do not base your strategy on having to give a false statement to a law enforcement agent.
- m0nty 11y ago> why you have been driving like a jackass Or just don't drive like a jackass. It's a serious business, take it seriously.
- CamperBob2 11y ago"What dashcam, Officer? Oh, that? It hasn't worked for weeks."
- dogma1138 11y agoLying to a police officer is a crime in most jurisdictions, it's called making a false statement.
- colejohnson66 11y agoBut the officer can't search the vehicle because of that. And if he does, you can most likely get your whole case tossed out for a search without probable cause.
- dogma1138 11y agoProbable cause is a tricky issue, if the police officer thinks you are hiding something they can claim probable cause and if they actually find what they were looking for their cause has just been validated. But this is irrelevant because i was specifically talking about accident when they do not need cause to search your car.
- AckSyn 11y agoOnly if you're making an actual report, going under oath. An instance of lying about a dash-cam won't get you in trouble.
- mentat 11y agoThis is absolutely and completely not true. Please do not do this. All statements to an officer at any time are evidence.
- danielweber 11y agoSome people keep records because they honestly believe they are doing things properly and want to be able to prove it.
- placeybordeaux 11y agoIs there well documented cases of this?