2 ms·
What use is the DNA match to third parties if there is no name/identity information paired with it? I guess it reveals a few bits of information if you know yo
by maxerickson 11y ago
What use is the DNA match to third parties if there is no name/identity information paired with it?
I guess it reveals a few bits of information if you know your killer submitted a sample to the project (but an easy way to avoid this threat is to not be a killer).
Most of the threats I can think of start with the third party already having the DNA, so it's existence in the project database doesn't seem important.
- jacquesm 11y agoSomeone else that is a (distant) family member of yours could supply enough information that by combining a few of those records you'd be as identifiable as if you had added your name and SSN to the sample. It's not a problem in isolation, it is by combining data from several sources that you can re-establish identity from an otherwise anonymous submission. For instance, let's say my brother submits his DNA non-anonymously to some database. By looking at the match between his profile and mine it could be established that I'm a close relative. A few more like that and some constraint trickery and you'd have me as the only solution to your equation. For an interesting perspective on this: consider what could happen if Facebook bought 23andme... (not much chance, fortunately given who founded 23andme but still).
- maxerickson 11y agoThe relative match can happen whether you have submitted your DNA or not. The third party that is searching using DNA gets "Bill's close relative" or "Bill's close relative that also anonymously submitted their DNA to the database". The specter of the service working internally to de-anonymize submissions is real enough though. I guess I don't really care about protecting myself from future dystopias, not really in a sense that I have nothing to hide (I find attention quite uncomfortable), more in a sense that I hope I'd stand up and shout loudly, rendering irrelevant all the past hiding-planning.
- jacquesm 11y agoThere's approximately 100,000 Amsterdam Jews that would stand with you and should just as loudly, only they can't. Lessons from the past can only be applied to the future if you're actually willing to learn them. Unfortunately, it seems as though those lessons weren't serious enough yet. I shudder to think of the kind of lesson that it would take to get people to understand these things in a way that we will actually live by those lessons in the future. Standing and shouting loudly is not much of a defense against an organized entity that is 'out to get you', even if that seems like a distant and remote possibility, the damage it could do is sufficient to warrant the - small - premium we'd pay in being careful with our data today. It's a bit like the rest of the security industry: probability of incidence * potential damage is a good way to figure out whether or not something is worth protecting against. I wrote a bit more about this here: http://jacquesmattheij.com/if-you-have-nothing-to-hide http://jacquesmattheij.com/if-you-have-nothing-to-hide Because I got very tired of the 'if you have nothing to hide' mantra, and even if you freely admit to finding attention quite uncomfortable you might be persuaded by the argument that seemingly innocent entries in databases have cost many lives already.
- maxerickson 11y agoIs it okay if I think the better lesson (vs hiding) is to not allow tyranny? Maybe it's overly optimistic or foolish or something, but it's still a shit world if only the people that (properly!) planned ahead survive. Edit: Imagine a modern populist horror that subjected everyone to mandatory genetic testing and slaughtered people with certain genes; You can't escape your genes, the problem would be the populist horror, not whether you were on some preexisting list of people that needed slaughterin'.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's definitely preferable. But given that Hitler actually made it in on the democratic process you don't always get that choice. And yes, those that properly planned ahead survived. I have a very nice piece about that from a guy called Simon Carmiggelt, unfortunately it is available in Dutch only, and only in video (even though he was a writer): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ofu3ZkGw2w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ofu3ZkGw2w The essence is that the writer meets with an elderly lady from the city on the street and she relates how just above everybody died from a particular family, except for one guy who saw it coming, warned everybody else and then left. If the Nazi's had been able to take possession of a Europe wide DNA database they might have just been able to eradicate the Jewish people forever and that's a very sobering thought to me. Now, I'm not Jewish but I know a few people here that are 'singletons', they have no living relatives going back two generations and that's a pretty strange thing to have it described to you. I don't have much to worry about from the angle of religious persecution or anything to that effect (I believe, but then again, who knows, maybe one day some religious nutcase will decide to open a war on atheism and maybe then I will have a problem but that's not genetic so the link with DNA isn't really there). Even so, less data in searchable files about you is better imnsho, the upsides are quite limited and the downsides significant, especially if you have no idea who is rooting around in them (one case of being stalked is enough for a lifetime).