2 ms·
I get the point you are trying to make, but I think it would only be valid if people fully understood the transaction they are making and chose to make it anyho
by jerf 17y ago
I get the point you are trying to make, but I think it would only be valid if people fully understood the transaction they are making and chose to make it anyhow. I do not think we are there. Nor do I think this is because people are "stupid"; these issues are complicated. Over time, many of these people have discovered the issues that can arise and regret their decisions in hindsight; many more will come to the same realization in the future.
It should also be pointed out that privacy advocates in general are not saying these transactions should be impossible; what they are saying is that it should be possible to not conduct these transactions. There's basically no option to participate on Facebook and, say, pay them money to leave you the hell alone.
- dantheman 17y agoDo people ever fully understand what they're getting into, I'd say not. As for your second point; you can take facebook as they present it or you don't have to use it, it's not for you to decide what they can and cannot do
- jerf 17y agoIf you can say both of those things at once, you missed my point. You can't deliberately "take it or leave it" (your second paragraph) if you don't know what "it" is (your first paragraph). The point is not that I demand that Facebook be legally constrained to provide me a high-privacy option. I would fight such a law. The point is that nearly nobody would even understand what such a choice is, and in an environment where nobody fully understands the implications of their actions, it is not a legitimate argument to then cite people's actions as supporting the current system. You could argue that people would still make the same choices even if they did fully understand the transactions they are making (and I'd counterargue after that), but you can't base an argument on current people making conscious choices when they aren't in fact making conscious choices.
- dantheman 17y agoPeople should just assume everything that is on the internet and not encrypted is public. It's safe that way. Heck, people think email is private. I think people need to realize this is something new and that their might be negative consequences that they cannot foresee. They should think, if this is data is public what is the worst that can happen, if this data is correlated with other data i have online what can happen.
- andreyf 17y agoit would only be valid if people fully understood the transaction they are making and chose to make it anyhow It's really not that hard: if you're trying to keep something from your ex-husband, don't tweet or Buzz it publicly. it should be possible to not conduct these transactions But that's the case now - I have the option to exert complete control over who gets to see my facebook profile, my tweets, and my buzz-es.
- jerf 17y ago"I have the option to exert complete control over who gets to see my facebook profile, my tweets, and my buzz-es." To my understanding, those buttons aren't anywhere near as powerful as you may think; I'm pretty sure Facebook affiliates see right through them if you do much more than glance at an app. How many randomly-selected people will be able to correctly answer that question? Pointing out that there are parts of privacy that people do get ("Gosh, maybe I shouldn't make a post about how much fun my mistress and I had last night") doesn't negate the point that there's a huge chunk that they don't understand at all, and therefore we can't look at their actions as endorsement of the current way private information is being handled. (Both of you who have replied do not seem to be getting my point here. I'm not making the general purpose argument that "we should have privacy". I'm making the argument that we can't read people's apparent acceptance of the current privacy regime as real acceptance when they don't actually know what the current regime is. Which is why my post here focuses on the issue of what an average person understands is going on, rather than whether what is going on is intrinsically good or bad.)