4 ms·
Whenever privacy as a topic comes up in discussions on the forums I follow, a lot of people chime in with a fairly dismissive "no harm, no foul" kind of attitud
by Silhouette 17y ago
Whenever privacy as a topic comes up in discussions on the forums I follow, a lot of people chime in with a fairly dismissive "no harm, no foul" kind of attitude. They don't mind the Eric Schmidts and Jonathan Schwartzes and Mark Zuckerbergs of the world proclaiming the death of privacy, because apparently no-one in the Facebook generation cares.
It's odd how when something like this becomes public, when everyday, non-geek people actually appreciate the implications of what is going on, there never seems to be a shortage of people who care, and whatever Schmidt says there obviously are examples of real harm being done.
I have been saying for a while that I think privacy and data protection will have to get worse before they get better. Right now, our societies are drifting into a situation where governments and megacorps can build databases for whatever purpose they want, because as long as that is all they are doing, the average guy in the street doesn't know or care.
But as we are seeing increasingly frequently now, those databases are subject to both deliberate abuse and accidental compromise. There can be consequences for very large numbers of people and/or very serious consequences for some of those people.
We need serious laws, with company-destroying penalties attached, to protect the privacy of individuals and regulate the collection of any kind of potentially sensitive, personally identifiable data in any database, and we need them before the frog is dead.
- forgotAgain 17y agoI agree with everything that you say except that if we let things get worse I believe it will be to late to make them better.
- pingswept 17y agoIf we fix the problems now, wouldn't it get better in 75 years or so, when all the currently surveilled people are dead? (Admittedly, that's still a terrible situation.)
- Silhouette 17y agoThere is a Pandora's box effect here, to be sure. I think the best we can hope for is for one or two really spectacular failures, by organisations on the scale of Google or Facebook, where the potential damage becomes obvious to everyone but because of the scale of the problem the plug gets pulled quickly before too much damage can be done. IMHO, this would be preferable to slowing building up lots of databases and having an endless stream of small-scale leaks, each of which is also damaging to those involved, but none of them big enough to make this a serious political issue.
- andreyf 17y agoCan you step me through this worst-case situation you're thinking of? People's most-emailed contacts being auto-added to their buzz stream doesn't count.
- Silhouette 17y ago> People's most-emailed contacts being auto-added to their buzz stream doesn't count. Does that depend on how many people's previosly private information is now available to abusive ex-partners? Is it OK in this case, because so far only one person has come forward and exposed that threat? What if it happened to 10 people? 100? 1,000,000?
- andreyf 17y agoDoes that depend on how many people's previosly private information is now available to abusive ex-partners? Some people will use Buzz to announce their previously private information to the world, knowing they have abusive ex-partners. Others will stab themselves in the face with a nice pen. Neither Google nor Montblanc is to blame.
- Silhouette 17y agoI think the question is, did the person make the previously private information available more widely, or did Google (or Facebook, or whoever else controls the big database and previously implied that access to that data would be restricted)?
- andreyf 17y agoAgreed.
- andreyf 17y agoWhy do we need the kind of privacy you speak of? Because while people nod in approval to your rhetoric, their behavior shows that they feel free to give it up the "privacy" of what they're eating for breakfast en masse.
- emarcotte 17y agoI believe the reason is freedom of choice. Clearly not everyone wants to be part of this system. Do you not know of people who lock their profiles on facebook, or people who strictly avoid social networking sites in the first place? If that is the case, I would be very surprised. Do we remove their ability to choose?
- jerf 17y agoI get the point you are trying to make, but I think it would only be valid if people fully understood the transaction they are making and chose to make it anyhow. I do not think we are there. Nor do I think this is because people are "stupid"; these issues are complicated. Over time, many of these people have discovered the issues that can arise and regret their decisions in hindsight; many more will come to the same realization in the future. It should also be pointed out that privacy advocates in general are not saying these transactions should be impossible; what they are saying is that it should be possible to not conduct these transactions. There's basically no option to participate on Facebook and, say, pay them money to leave you the hell alone.
- dantheman 17y agoDo people ever fully understand what they're getting into, I'd say not. As for your second point; you can take facebook as they present it or you don't have to use it, it's not for you to decide what they can and cannot do
- jerf 17y agoIf you can say both of those things at once, you missed my point. You can't deliberately "take it or leave it" (your second paragraph) if you don't know what "it" is (your first paragraph). The point is not that I demand that Facebook be legally constrained to provide me a high-privacy option. I would fight such a law. The point is that nearly nobody would even understand what such a choice is, and in an environment where nobody fully understands the implications of their actions, it is not a legitimate argument to then cite people's actions as supporting the current system. You could argue that people would still make the same choices even if they did fully understand the transactions they are making (and I'd counterargue after that), but you can't base an argument on current people making conscious choices when they aren't in fact making conscious choices.
- coffeemug 17y agoWe need serious laws, with company-destroying penalties attached, to protect the privacy of individuals We already have them, and I don't think we don't need more. There is a fundamental difference between the government spying on citizens or abusing the information they collect, and companies doing so. People voluntarily sign onto Facebook every day, and the company does not violate its privacy policy (if it did, you'd have grounds for a law suit). If Facebook users find its privacy policy acceptable, I don't think establishing contrarian laws is a proper response. It's not the government's place to institute laws to protect consumers from themselves. I don't believe Facebook abuses the customer's trust (and there are already contract laws against such things). The proper action here is educating people about privacy, not adding more legislation.
- CaptainZapp 17y agoUhh, I voluntarily signed up for GMail and GMail ONLY. This however does not imply that I agreed that Google can package their "Facebook-Killer" without as much as asking. In my opinion that's actually worse then Apples completely slimy attempt to smuggle their software onto my box without asking. Just because I had the bad sense to install Itunes. Don't be evil; Ha!
- coffeemug 17y agoHas your privacy been compromised in a way that conflicts with their privacy policy? If that's the case, you can file a lawsuit. Otherwise, the legal system cannot help you (and should not be able to help you). If this is a huge concern for you and it wasn't covered in their privacy policy, you shouldn't have used their product. If you implicitly trusted them, you can stop doing so now. I agree that they are wrong. I just don't think we need more legislation to patch it up. It's between consumers and the companies - the government has nothing to do with it.
- emarcotte 17y agoAnd when privacy policies change, do I have to re-evaluate each time/product that may or may not be involved (since google products are sort of all merged into one)? If I do re-evaluate, and decide I no longer agree with the policy, and I delete my account is my data really gone or will the data still be there, just hidden, and part of the new policy which may give them more rights to for example sell that information? I believe facebook makes notifications of these changes, does GMail? There are lots of issues that a simple 'privacy policy' document does not solve and may that it adds.
- dantheman 17y agoI completely disagree -- the law moves slow, we don't want to jump the gun and get bad laws. If in the meantime some people are inconvenienced or worse someone dies (stalker finds them etc). Those are risks we have to take for progress. If you have a stalker stay away from new things, don't hurt everyone by forcing them to slow down. Premature laws are worse than no laws.
- Silhouette 17y agoI agree that bad laws are worse than no laws, but how long exactly does it take? It's really not that hard to think through the consequences of modern technology providing massive data storage, fast data mining, and a worldwide communications network with near instant data transmission and plenty of bandwidth. It's also not as if these are new developments or things we could not see coming. I can completely accept not rushing out a law in five minutes, but this has been coming for at least a decade, and it's been a huge and blindingly obvious issue for several years, ever since the social networking sites and data hoarders like Google got big. There have been plenty of serious data loss cases, including those with very serious consequences. There have been plenty of cases where databases have come incorrect, deliberately or carelessly, and those have serious consequences too. Failing to update privacy and data protection laws by now isn't caution, it's negligence.