4 ms·
Safari is also the only desktop browser that can handle my "power user" web browsing style. Chrome completely falls over after a few dozen tabs are opened. Fire
by jacobolus 11y ago
Safari is also the only desktop browser that can handle my "power user" web browsing style. Chrome completely falls over after a few dozen tabs are opened. Firefox holds up better, but still starts starts stuttering when it gets to 80–100 tabs. Safari keeps going fine with several hundred tabs.
Edit: For the folks who are apparently offended by my browser use, I’ll elaborate:
Why would anyone want a large number of tabs, you ask? Well, when researching a topic, it’s often useful to open in tabs, breadth-first style, every potentially relevant link in a network of {academic papers, historical web pages, wikipedia articles, ..}.
For me, it’s much more efficient to partition my browsing tasks into {open a bunch of tabs without looking closely at the content | go through the list of tabs in order, lightly skimming the content and closing any that aren’t relevant | dive deep into each relevant tab, reading carefully, taking notes, etc.}. I find that, as alternative strategies, both (a) trying to entirely finish with one tab before opening another, storing its hyperlinks in a text file for later examination, or (b) only opening links in the same tab, using the browser history as a linear linked list of my current place in the browsing tree, are much less effective.
Theoretically, my strategy could be done with a set of bookmarks, a list of links in a text file somewhere, one of those "read later" apps, etc. In practice, I find that it works better for me to just keep the tabs open in my browser. YMMV.
Anyway, now imagine you have 4–5 different long-term ongoing research interests/projects (possibly related). Sometimes, when diving into one topic, you end up stumbling across a useful tangent into one of the other topics you care about. Occasionally, the thing you stumble on is important enough to temporarily set aside the first topic (tabling the in-progress search by leaving all of the, say, 50 currently open tabs in their own window) and open up a new window to dive in on the second topic. Alternately, imagine you receive an important email, and need to suspend the entire research session for later. Again, it’s easier to just keep the window open with all the tabs in it, rather than closing everything and reconstructing it later.
This might not be the browsing style for everyone. But it works for me, and Safari is the only browser I’ve tried which holds up.
- zajd 11y agoSeveral hundred tabs? Dear god
- awakeasleep 11y agoAka The User is Wrong
- Klathmon 11y agoAKA the software was not written with that use case in mind. Just because the way he/she uses software doesn't work well with chrome doesn't make chrome bad software, and it doesn't mean the user is wrong. It just means that it's not a good fit for that person.
- jacobolus 11y agoI definitely am not claiming that Chrome is “bad software”. All I said was that it can’t handle my browsing style, while Safari can.
- Klathmon 11y agoAnd I didn't mean to imply that you did, just that the person I replied to did. Your explanation there is a great example of what I personally want to see more of. A clear concise reason why you prefer one browser to another. So often its just "X is faster" or "Y uses less memory" without any other details. And those kinds of complaints help nobody.
- zajd 11y agoHonestly I was just shocked someone actually uses hundreds of tabs, I struggle to understand why but I guess that's just me. Downvotes ahoy
- Illniyar 11y agoI can't imagine opening 10 tabs, let alone hundreds of tabs without tree-style-tabs. And only firefox has the infastructure to support such changes to its UI. I would say that the only broweser that supports your use case is firefox, not safari.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- irascible 11y agoWhen he says research, he means porn. 100 tabs of porn.
- hs86 11y agoCheck out Tab Outliner[1] for Chrome. Its integration into the Chrome UI is not as good as Tree Style Tab's in Firefox but is has better keyboard shortcuts, rearranging tabs with Drag and Drop is more intuitive and its built in session manager allows you to unload entrie trees from RAM without losing the tab hierarchy. This enables a workflow with several hundreds of tabs without the drawback of the additional RAM and CPU usage. Previously I shared the impression that Tree Style Tab for Firefox has ruined all other browsers for me and I could never switch away from Firefox but Tab Outliner showed me that I was wrong. [1]http://tabsoutliner.com/ http://tabsoutliner.com/
- jsolson 11y agoI see this critique now and then, and it always makes me wonder what is wrong with your Chrome installation. I typically have somewhere between 200 and 400 tabs open, and I work on a wimpy little 11" MacBook Air. The vast majority of those tabs are heavy things like Google Docs. Chrome seems to barely notice.
- Crito 11y agoHow do you manage hundreds of tabs in Chrome? I used to use hundreds of tabs in firefox, but firefox had an effective tree-style tabs extension...
- jsolson 11y agoI tend to partition them into windows once the favicons go away. Otherwise mostly based on the ordering (which I adjust regularly). Much of the time they are effectively a queue of things to review/skim/familiarize myself with while I'm authoring some code or a design doc. The ones with different favicons tend to be things like bugs where I owe an update, so I scan through them regularly (I'm extremely forgetful when it comes to lists of things to do). Honestly I know how tree-style management would go for me: I'd group a bunch of things together in a tree and forget about them, largely defeating the purpose of having kept the tab open for me.
- detaro 11y agoFor me it is multiple windows, you can shift-select multiple tabs for easier sorting. As in, if the tab bar starts to get illegible I shift-click a sub-topic or other logical range and pop it in a new window.
- j_s 11y agoExtensions can impact performance dramatically.
- flanbiscuit 11y agoJust curious to know why you, or anyone else, need 100+ tabs open. Especially when you say you can have up to 400. Can you remember what's in each? I'm not judging, just trying to understand because it's so different from how I use browsers. When my tabs start to become so small that I can no longer see the titles on them I start to clean up by either bookmarking them or close them. I rarely need to bookmark so I don't have a million bookmarks.
- Gmo 11y agoMy firefox is doing fine with several hundred tabs (on Windows though).
- detaro 11y agoNot on OSX, but both Firefox and Chrome do large tab counts for me. Firefox gets a bit wonky around 250, chrome/chromium never gave me trouble (used up to 380 or so). Eat quite a bit of memory in the process though, but that's probably to be expected. EDIT: uBlock or similar is absolutely must though, unless you browse only slim, "old-school" websites.