5 ms·
"Creating wealth" is such a loaded term. Do people like the Walton family and the Koch brothers personally create billions in wealth every year? No. They depend
by chongli 11y ago
"Creating wealth" is such a loaded term. Do people like the Walton family and the Koch brothers personally create billions in wealth every year? No. They depend on millions of people who work for them. They merely reap a ridiculously outsized share of the benefits for being the owners of all the capital.
- lisivka 11y agoYou can hire these millions of people and they will work for you. Just provide better terms than Koch, so you will be wealthy and we will have better salary.
- kuschku 11y agoBut you can't, because you require a starting capital and you'll have to compete with them in an unfairly titled market. If the market was actually fair, it would be a lot easier to do a startup or a small company and start competing.
- WalterBright 11y agoThe capital markets exist to provide capital in large quantities to new companies that have a compelling business plan for making money. Consider all the investors looking under every rock for "the next big thing".
- JetSpiegel 11y agoThe Koch won't fund a direct competitor, so there goes your access to capital markets.
- WalterBright 11y agoI had no idea that Koch controlled all investors worldwide :-)
- ownagefool 11y agoYour typical investor isn't going to invest in "What Koch provides but less profit margin". Rather, they'd just invest in what Koch provides.
- WalterBright 11y agoI didn't know that every business on or off the stock exchange was managed by Koch. I'm a bit surprised that Koch owns my business, too.
- kuschku 11y agoEh, using the capital markets to start your company will make sure that yours will be just as investor-oriented and bad as every competitor. I was thinking more along the lines of ALDI, which never took a loan or credit, and was started by the two brothers taking over a tiny store from their father, and later expanding into a global chain.
- Houshalter 11y agoNot necessarily. Soon they will replace all those workers with machines, and they won't depend on workers anymore. In the past they did create wealth, by actually founding those successful businesses. Of course that might have been luck and markets aren't perfectly fair, so maybe they don't deserve 100% of the profits. But still they did create something of value, at one point in time. A thing which continues to produce value today. It's not like Walmart just materialized out of the aether and Sam Walton just happened to find it first. Of course deontological arguments are silly and it's impossible to know who "deserves" what. I think a consequentialist argument is much stronger, that taxing rich people and redistributing the money to everyone, creates more benefit to society than it harms.
- WalterBright 11y agoConsider the case where worker Fred creates $100/hr in value yet earns only $10/hr. Me, as a greedy capitalist, wants a piece of that action. I offer Fred $20 to create $100/hr for me. Bob, that capitalist swine, outbids me and offers Fred $30. Ted, the running dog capitalist pig, offers him $40. You see where this is going. If Fred really was underpaid relative to the value he produces, why isn't he getting a better offer elsewhere? You could postulate there are lots of Freds bidding for his job, keeping wages low. But then were are the new companies being created for the simple purpose of hiring boatloads of Freds and making 10x their pay? Being underpaid seems like an unstable state in a free market.
- justincormack 11y agoIn reality markets are not as competitive or as simple as the model. If you want to set up another Walmart say, it is not that easy to get it funded or make it a success, not as simple as just hiring a bunch of people and putting them to work to make money, as any entrepreneur knows.
- WalterBright 11y agoThen is it really the workers creating that value, or the people, capital, and infrastructure creating that value? For example, suppose I have a machine that, when a lever is pulled, it manufactures a gold nugget. A worker is needed to pull that lever - but is the bulk of the value being created by the worker or the machine? It gets down to how one does the accounting for productivity. Get it too far wrong and one is likely to go out of business.
- huherto 11y agoThe workers and capital are just part of the equation. The more fundamental part is the consumers. The current trends will eventually kill that too. It is a loose loose situation.