6 ms·
Instead of complaing about what others have and I don't, I like to remember that my dogs eat better food than the majority of the world and I poop into cleaner
by exabrial 11y ago
Instead of complaing about what others have and I don't, I like to remember that my dogs eat better food than the majority of the world and I poop into cleaner water than the rest of the world drinks.
I give my money away to the Ronald McDonald house and my time free to the Lords Dinner, a local organization the provides free meals to anyone.
Im not better than anyone else, theres a lot more I could do. But I realized a long time ago its not the .1% thats the problem, its the 99.9% of us that do nothing. That starbucks you have in the morning would go a long way overseas towards education.
- Klinky 11y agoMany of the benefits we have today in the "first world" come from people demanding a fairer share of the resources being allocated. Charities don't fill in the huge gaps that leave people drinking toilet water or eating food you wouldn't feed a dog. Saying it could be worse is not a good excuse to ignore inequality.
- merpnderp 11y agoI'd say that is wrong and the benefits of the industrialized world come from people being freer to exchange goods and services without direct interference of the government and with fair protections from the law. S. Korea didn't outperform N. Korea, Taiwan didn't outperform China, and W. Germany didn't outperform E. Germany because their people demanded a fairer distribution of resources.
- Klinky 11y agoA marketplace is a tool, and it alone does not automatically bring freedom to people or ensure fair resource allocation. There are complicated factors for the differences in the countries you mentioned.
- TheLogothete 11y agoSo much this! The top 1% outperform significantly everyone else in every scenario. The app store? Twitch streamers? Youtube videos? Facebook pages? Athletes? It's a natural phenomenon. If you fight it, you are practically fighting nature. You don't fight earthquakes by trying to stop them. You prepare and help the affected instead.
- sangnoir 11y ago> The top 1% outperform significantly everyone else in every scenario. The app store? Twitch streamers? Youtube videos? Facebook pages? Athletes? No-one likes cheats - even elite athletes are not allowed to gain an unfair advantage via doping. 20th century Robber-barons might have been an equally 'natural phenomenon', until legislation caught up with their unfair advantages.
- TheLogothete 11y agoThe top 1% does not have to cheat to outperform the rest. Did you read the last paragraphs of the article?
- sangnoir 11y ago> The top 1% does not have to cheat to outperform the rest. Did you read the last paragraphs of the article? I read it. The penultimate paragraph suggests that they do cheat. Did you read it? Heck, even the title is "Make elites compete", you could not have missed that.
- TheLogothete 11y agoYou are clearly biased against rich people. The sibling's comment are my thoughts exactly. Not every cheat is rich and everyone who is rich cheats. If somebody cheats - punish him, whether he is rich or not is irrelevant. Don't make different rules for different groups. What would happen if we swap wealth for race? I did not point out the last paragraph to be cheeky. Less Marx, more Adam Smith.
- sangnoir 11y ago> You are clearly biased against rich people This is not true...well, I'm no more biased than the article under discussion. I'm simply quoting the article and what I got from it.
- sportanova 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- magicGLASSman 11y agoI wish I could up vote this more! It starts with us helping each other locally and creating tighter communities of people around us. We are being divided by this very .1% by envy and our own greed.
- crdb 11y ago> my dogs eat better food than the majority of the world This immediately reminded me of Viktor Belenko [1] who flew his MiG-25 to Japan and defected. He wrote (I think, in his autobiography, it could have been an interview) of the amazement that dawned upon him when he entered a Western supermarket for the first time. edit: found it. "Once I bought a can which said "dinner." I cooked it with potatoes, onions, and garlic-it was delicious. Next morning my friends ask me, "Viktor, did you buy a cat?" It was a can of chicken-based cat food. But it was delicious! It was better than canned food for people in Russia today. And I did test it. Last year I brought four people from Russia for commercial project, and I set them up. I bought nibble sized human food. I installed a pâté, and it was cat food. I put it on crackers. And they did consume it, and they liked it. So the taste has not changed." [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Belenko https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Belenko [2] http://www.videofact.com/english/defectors2_4en.html http://www.videofact.com/english/defectors2_4en.html
- mlvljr 11y agoI honestly always liked the smell of Whiskas (not that I ever tested it) :)
- jessaustin 11y agoI grew up in and have lived mostly in USA, but I've never understood canned pet food. Pets will eat anything you feed them, eventually. Why choose to feed them something expensive and wasteful?
- liveoneggs 11y agowhy not just eat your pet, then everyone wins
- chefkoch 11y agoYes, don't complain and look the other way. With the money from higher taxes for the rich you could feed a lot of poor people.
- exabrial 11y agoAnd that's my point, people complain about the rich while they do nothing.
- magicGLASSman 11y agoIt is about actually doing something and not just complaining. What percentage of those tax dollars you think actually make it to the poor?
- chefkoch 11y agoSo because you think not much of the money makes it to the poor it's better to just let the rich keep it?
- sportanova 11y agoAbsolutely! How vindictive to think otherwise. It's bullshit, but I can understand the "we're going to take your money because we can improve society with it" argument. But I can't understand the "you have too much, so let's take it and burn it" mentality
- ap22213 11y agoI'm pretty sure that good portion of the '99%' are doing a lot more than 'nothing'. But, getting back to the core, I think all of these capitalism vs communism juxtapositions distract us from looking at our collective goals. That is, we often put ideology in front of the desired effect. Capitalism has succeeded in being a much, much better allocator of resources than large-scale central planning. I think most of us get that. Allowing capital to flow dynamically has allowed resources to flow to where there is most demand, and it has incentivized people to play the resource allocation game. As a society, we have generally accepted some inequality in the process, as long as the system has generally benefited most people. Traditionally, in the west, this has been 'progress' - the optimism that one's quality of life and the quality of life of their descendants will get significantly better over time. In countries that have adopted capitalism, it's been great, as long as per-capita grown rates have been high (say > 4% annually). But, when standards of living start to decrease over time, like they have started to over the last 30-40 years, people lose faith in the system. That, coupled with most economists predicting long-term global growth stagnation, it's time to think about novel new models that achieve social goals. As hackers, I'm surprised that there has been so much focus in HN comments on dueling ideology. Where are the innovative minds that come up with new systems to replace the old ones?
- kuschku 11y agoThere is no need for a new system, or new concepts. The old European systems of Social Democracy already solved the issues. Give everyone a minimum standard of life, ensuring that everyone has an opportunity at improving themselves. Give everyone a second chance. If everyone has similar chances at getting quality education, at getting into good jobs, then people's status only depends on their own merit. For the American dream to work, we need a social market economy. Not just in the US, not just in Germany, but in every country we gave a free trade zone with.
- jqm 11y agoThe problems with the European Social Democracy model are becoming apparent even as we speak. It works really well with a small, homogenous, educated, basically peaceable population and assumes plentiful resources and that the population reproduces at a reasonable level. But much of the world does not live under those kind of conditions and national barriers are apparently very much an artificial construct. Would social democracy work in Iraq? In Somalia? But we share the same world as Iraq and Somalia. So what do we do? (real question... I don't know).
- bcook 11y agoThe author is complaining on the behalf of those who could use more help (the 99%). Do you honestly think that 99.9% of people "do nothing"? This world-view is flawed and self-righteous. Anecdotally, I am from a small, southern USA town (per capita income of ~$22K) where most of the people I know donate their time and money to others on a weekly basis (much more than 0.01% of my town's total work-hour output). The fact that you needed to include "Im not better than anyone else" seems to be a bit of a Freudian slip...
- exabrial 11y agoNo of course not. In fact, I do very little in the grand scheme of things to make the world a better place. If you're doing charity work though, you are a minority. I'm not trying to toot my horn I'm just pointing out how much help is needed and how few people actually show up :/
- dikdik 11y agoSo how many generations do you think we will continue to tout this race-to-the-bottom mentality? "There are poorer people in India, sit down and be grateful!" The reality is millennials will have a worse standard of living than their parents. OK, maybe not the worst thing in the world. But what about my kids? Will they be worse off than me? What about my grandkids? There is a reason trends are important (just like global warming). Waiting until Antarctica melts before we do anything about it, is extremely stupid and short-sighted. Additionally, the same argument you made can be made against the 1% (or 0.1%). Tax the shit out of them, it shouldn't matter since their living standard will still be much higher than every other American. Why should the 99.9% be subjugated to a protestant work ethic, while the 0.1% are encouraged and celebrated for acting as ruthless capitalists?