3 ms·
This is an analysis of top 1% wage earners, not top 1% capital owners; and besides, it's not really the top 1% where it gets egregious; more like the top 0.1%.
by barrkel 11y ago
This is an analysis of top 1% wage earners, not top 1% capital owners; and besides, it's not really the top 1% where it gets egregious; more like the top 0.1%. The analysis of returns to capital doesn't seem to include capital appreciation itself, and how it is taxed much more favourably than labour.
- hkmurakami 11y agoAgreed. I think it's a great coup that the truly powerful have managed to shake the narrative to the 1% rather than the 0.1% or 0.01%, thereby adding significant noise to the problem framework.
- themgt 11y agoAbsolutely, but also as barrkel points out, talking about income rather than wealth, which is much more important - referencing Piketty while purposely failing to address his actual thesis, which was almost wholly about wealth rather than income: r > g
- HappyTypist 11y agoThat's because it isn't. It is taxed better in nominal terms because it ignores inflation. If you bought a stock for $100 and sold it for $110 in a year, in nominal terms you made 10%. But $110 in a year isn't worth as much as last year, and in real terms you probably made 8%. There is a reason that short term capital gains are taxed exactly the same as income. In the 2015 top tax bracket of 39.6%, capital gains is taxed at 23.8%. That's a 40% discount, which (unsurprisingly) is long term equity capital appreciation minus long term CPI trends. This discount should be extended to all forms of savings and investment income too (e.g. interest and bonds), but that's another topic.
- RyanZAG 11y ago> capital appreciation itself, and how it is taxed much more favourably than labour. This is very much on purpose. Capital is extremely mobile and not part of a market transaction, while most labor is immobile and constrained as a market transaction. It is easy to take tax from a labor market transaction, and this tax is borne just as much by the capital employing the labor as by the labor itself. Taking tax from capital appreciation is far more difficult - if you put your capital tax too high, the capital just moves to a different market with better dynamics. Of course if you go overboard with your labor regulation and tax, then other labor markets are able to out compete your own labor market, and that is even worse. Basically: you don't have free reign to decide on these labor and capital taxes and regulations. Any policy change you make is going to have consequences. You can't just say "OK, we will just double capital tax! Money for all!" and not face extreme changes in your entire base. I'm in South Africa and watching this unfold as the socialist government continues to raise capital taxes each year, and now faces enormous foreign capital flight and lack of investment in the economy, destroying GDP growth and pushing the more vulnerable parts of the population out of jobs and into extreme debt and poverty. Believe me, you don't want that in USA just to get rid of some mythical '1% problem' that hurts your sensitivities.
- HappyTypist 11y agoNo, this is not on purpose. It's simply a fact of tax being measured in nominal dollars, when capital appreciation is really denominated in real terms (i.e. after inflation).
- wycx 11y ago<i>Capital is extremely mobile and not part of a market transaction, while most labor is immobile and constrained as a market transaction.</i> It does not have to be. The neo-feudalists have relentlessly advanced an agenda of removing capital controls since the early 1970s. If you look at modern, rich, mixed industrial economies that have emerged since WW2, they did it with very strict capital controls in place during the period they nurtured their infant industries. At one time in South Korea the highest penalty for violating capital controls was the death penalty!