4 ms·
I've used three smartwatches so far: Moto 360, Apple Watch and Samsung Gear S2. The Samsung is my clear favorite because it has the most watchlike physical des
by pavlov 11y ago
I've used three smartwatches so far: Moto 360, Apple Watch and Samsung Gear S2.
The Samsung is my clear favorite because it has the most watchlike physical design and the best designed software of the three. Considering the reputation Samsung has in software, that was rather shocking (and perhaps speaks more about Google's and Apple's failures).
Android Wear is distressingly non-spatial. Most of the time I felt lost in the UI. I never could figure out if swiping left or right or up would bring me to the same place as it did last time, or (more often) whether I'd be faced with a surprising new screen out of nowhere.
Apple Watch has too many buttons and UI actions. It's rarely obvious what each of them will do, so often I'd just cycle through them all: turn the crown, try long press and force touch, swipe in all directions... The meaning of actions varies arbitrarily (e.g. to set an alarm you must turn the crown and the screen does nothing; in most other apps you specify values by touch actions and the crown does nothing).
The Samsung Gear S2 has a rotating bezel that's much nicer to use than the fidgety crown on the Apple Watch. It also has a clear meaning in the interface: you turn the bezel to scroll through content. That covers a lot of the things you actually do on a smartwatch, and there's no guessing whether you need to swipe in this or that direction instead.
The Samsung is also the fastest of the bunch. Native apps start instantly, whereas Apple Watch will often keep you waiting for 5-10 seconds for an app to start.
My two cents on smartwatches... Supposedly Samsung's Gear software is coming to iOS too (pending Apple approval it seems), so it's shaping up to be a real cross-platform contender.
- ohthehugemanate 11y agoI just got a gear s2, and I agree with your sentiment. But i had an original Pebble since the Kickstart, and it's way better on everything but looks. Pebble has one of the best looking watches on the market fwiw, in the Pebble round... Unfortunately it's only IPX7 rated, just "splash resistant", and it has a battery life like all the competitors. So I bought the s2, and it's good enough. But the moment Pebble releases a good looking, round watch that can survive a swimming pool and last like its other models, I'm in.
- rev_bird 11y ago>in most other apps you specify values by touch actions and the crown does nothing This was only a minor point in a much bigger comment, but I can't help thinking this is going to change. The alarm app works differently than new third-party apps because Apple made it, and Apple is way better at making Watch apps than third-party devs -- even aside from limitations on the Watch API, it's not surprising that the UI from developers is inconsistent and (right now) favors basically making a little tiny version of an iPhone app, touchscreen and all. I bet this changes in relatively short order, or at least improves to the point that you can get as consistent an experience on the Watch as you'd get between apps on the phone.
- nl 11y agoI have a Huawei Watch[1]. It's great, and actually looks like a normal - nice looking watch. It's fast, great battery life (~2 days). I don't find the interface bad (I've never got lost in it like your experience). Not sure if it is the same software as on the G2 - I thought it was standard Android. I use it for notifications - single glance to see if I should read an email/message. I haven't worn a watch in years, but I'm really enjoying it. [1] http://consumer.huawei.com/minisite/worldwide/huawei-watch/ http://consumer.huawei.com/minisite/worldwide/huawei-watch/