3 ms·
Grave dirt is chthonic. Agricultural topsoil is not. I didn't mean to imply that justice was the only function of the underworld gods, but the reward and puni
by logfromblammo 11y ago
Grave dirt is chthonic. Agricultural topsoil is not.
I didn't mean to imply that justice was the only function of the underworld gods, but the reward and punishment of deceased souls is a common theme across many religions.
When an Egyptian soul entered Duat, those with guilty souls--as determined by Anubis and a set of scales--were devoured by Ammit. A Hindu soul's karma--Buddhists inherited the tradition--is judged by Yama, and may be consigned to an unfortunate reincarnation, or even Naraka (or Diyu), the Hindu Hell. Abrahamics are judged after death, and the good enter paradise while the wicked are tortured by fire in Gehenna or by ice in Zamhareer. Maya traversed Xibalba, and its painful, terrifying, and humiliating tests.
Since no one can escape death, a mythical afterlife where punishment is meted out for misdeeds done in life, or rewards granted to the virtuous, is a great way to keep the living in line, especially if their moral development still revolves around not getting caught. If someone believes that death is their final end, and there is no afterlife, it is much more difficult to convince them to adopt unselfish strategies (or those vulnerable to exploitation) while they still live.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> Grave dirt is chthonic. Agricultural topsoil is not. I hate to keep bringing up Demeter, but I'm going to have to. The god of agriculture is chthonic. The earth itself, encompassing everything, is chthonic. I'm not aware of a Greek principle of being judged in the afterlife; there are myths of specific people who received particular punishments, but I thought they were conceived of as exceptional. Do you know of any source stating that, according to the classical Greeks, the general run of bad people receive a worse fate in the afterlife than good people do? Achilles' ghost appears in the Odyssey to say how terrible it is to be dead - he was a hero.
- logfromblammo 11y agoMost people were not bad enough to go to Tartarus. If you were not virtuous enough to go to Elysium, or if your good and bad deeds sort of balanced out, you were released into the fields of asphodel to be boring and unremarkable, forever. It isn't quite fire and brimstone, but lack of any meaningful stimulation could be considered a form of punishment. If you read the Iliad, you ought to know that Achilles wasn't exactly a paragon of virtue, even by the standards of ancient Greece. But the general run of bad people were simply ignored and forgotten. You had to be a real shitheel to get a special punishment in Tartarus.