4 ms·
> Many of her tweets were pretty inflammatory What, were people forced to print the tweets out on sandpaper and wipe their asses with them? It's pretty fucked
by mindslight 11y ago
> Many of her tweets were pretty inflammatory
What, were people forced to print the tweets out on sandpaper and wipe their asses with them?
It's pretty fucked up that thought policing has gotten so entrenched into our psyche that it's "obvious" an experiment should be discontinued, apologized for, and be pondered as a priori irresponsible, all because it generated vulgar phrases!
Corporations have always been vulnerable to media-driven mob shenanigans, but we're qualitatively entering a new regime where any communication, no matter what the context, will be rapidly highlighted, isolated, and hung out as something offensive to some emergently-forming group of freelance complainers looking for their fifteen minutes.
Even HN has succumbed to this kindler, gentler phenomenon of speech restriction - I'm guessing my lead-in sentence will not be well received do to its overt vulgarity. Civility certainly has its place (especially as a default), but not when it confuses direct objectivity and permits out-of-touch groupthink to flourish. As hackers we should be cutting through to the core of things rather than sugar coating in verbal fashion to get past the filters of the voluntarily-lesser apes.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoAlthough it's on sociology and only tangentially related, I suspect you might enjoy Kieran Healey's upcoming paper "Fuck Nuance". Preprint: http://kieranhealy.org/files/papers/fuck-nuance.pdf http://kieranhealy.org/files/papers/fuck-nuance.pdf
- warmblood 11y agoStanding behind the open and casual use of racial slurs isn't advocacy of freedom of speech. It's advocacy of a specific kind of hate speech that is only used when someone intends to vilify and direct hostility towards a marginalized minority.
- mindslight 11y agoDo you think this bot was trying to recruit an army of loyal soldiers to carry out her desired race war, or was she basing her threats on the possibility of convincing Microsoft to create a mechanical body with which she could directly perform attacks?
- EC1 11y agoYou are already part of the collective and there is no going back. I feel bad for you.
- Torgo 11y agoYour definition of free speech is alien to the legal history of this country.
- kelukelugames 11y agoJust going post post this xkcd comic. https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/ I didn't think Tay's tweets were a big deal. I didn't think Microsoft's apology was either. But some people have a strong persecution complex and are offended that you can't make racist comments on Twitter.
- warmblood 11y agoI think your own life experiences probably matter a lot with regards to whether some of the white supremacy stuff the bot was repeating is offensive or not a "big deal".
- kelukelugames 11y agoI agree completely. That's why many people on HN are upset because they think it's just a joke and can't comprehend why anyone is upset. I tried to phrase my comment as "I hear ya, but have you considered x?" I gave up half way through and decided to call them crybabies. Both the Verge and Engadget shut down their comment forums because they got tired of racist and sexist comments. I wonder if HN will root out the bigotry here.
- GunboatDiplomat 11y agoFree speech isn't free if it doesn't include speech you find offensive.
- panic 11y agoNobody is advocating that Microsoft should be thrown in jail or taken to court. This isn't about the legal protection of free speech.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 11y agoI don't think anybody was talking about the legal protection of free speech, apart from that xkcd comic which uses it as a straw man to justify intolerant groupthink and corporate censorship. In these days of digital sharecropping and social media saturation, the proscriptions on de jure government activity are much less involved with routine everyday freedom of speech.
- Nutmog 11y agoTwitter stands behind it and seems to be doing fine. They didn't suspend Tay's account. Why are people not blaming Twitter for supporting hate speech? Hate speech, in the broader form of being speech that vilifies marginalized people is rampant throughout society and it's completely hypocritical to pretend most of us don't do it. Look at any workplace lunchroom, or any group of friends hanging out in their house, or any school, any gossiping housewives, 99%er protesters, etc. Just about everybody vilifies vulnerable people. Not always categorizing them by race, but sometimes by personality type, job, country, city, status as a customer, company they work for or individual identity.
- magicalist 11y ago> It's pretty fucked up that thought policing has gotten so entrenched into our psyche that it's "obvious" an experiment should be discontinued, apologized for, and be pondered as a priori irresponsible, all because it generated vulgar phrases! This is fucking stupid. It was a bot that didn't do what they wanted it to do in a publicly embarrassing way. They could also be legitimately sorry that something they created said some racist shit, and it's not clear why your precious snowflake feelings have any bearing on what should or shouldn't be in a blog post on the subject. I do find it amusingly ironic that your post is the most I've seen someone offended over this whole situation.
- MawNicker 11y agoIt's sad that it's ironic. It's always ironic. Tolerance is the intolerance of intolerance. It's true. Intolerance is shitty and I fucking hate it. I want it to die. I complain about it's enduring existence whenever I get the opportunity. I know I'm being ironic. Do you know there's no other option? I actually appreciated knowing that someone else saw the same condemnation. Microsoft is a world authority. That it just apologized for these things in the same motion makes them offensive. The reality was rather mundane. They didn't do anything wrong. They got pranked. This should be something we laugh about. It's only upsetting for the 5 seconds it takes you to realize: no one intended this. That should have been Microsoft's response imho.
- magicalist 11y agoI'm not making some cute comment about the intolerance of tolerance. I'm pointing out that someone apparently personally offended about a culture of outrage is the only one outraged over the whole thing. There have been no widespread condemnations of Microsoft, just a lot of mildly amused people. > That it just apologized for these things in the same motion makes them offensive. You're assuming motivations that you have no insight into. If I had made Tay I would apologize too. Any assumption you make is on you. So what is ironic is that there are people waiting with bated breath for the merest hint of something so they can express their righteous outrage on the internet, making demands for thought policing and handwringing over word choice, which wouldn't have existed at all if they had just said, "well, that's a corporate blog post" and moved the fuck on.
- bracewel 11y agoIt allowed users to bypass Twitter blocks by tweeting at the bot while tagging users that block them, which seems pretty bad and was abused very quickly. Also it's a violation of the Twitter TOS.
- popmystack 11y agoNone of this is remotely related to thought policing.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]