5 ms·
Sanitation is the proverbial uphill battle in India. West and affluent Indians often do not understand the full extent of issues here. Some 15 years ago we buil
by tn13 11y ago
Sanitation is the proverbial uphill battle in India. West and affluent Indians often do not understand the full extent of issues here. Some 15 years ago we built 5 toilets (along with flush) for a community of sheep shepherds deep into the jungles of Maharashtra-India. 6 years later when we visited them again it was embarrassing to see that they were using the toilets as shelter for their sheep and still defecating in open.
Their logic was flawless. Why should we change our priorities because you think what we are doing is wrong. We thought it was a lesson not to interfere in their affairs any more.
Some changed land regulation laws made their land extremely valuable. 5 years back these people sold their land for multi-million dollars. Now these people are into Trucking and Fishing business with homes better than mine own.
This is a anecdotal evidence and must not be used for any kind of conclusion. I visited Dharavi-Mumbai(largest slum in world) where there is literally no space for toilets. Every morning there will be like 1000 people trying to use like 20 toilets. There are people who then have no choice but to defecate in side their home in a reusable utensil and throw it out in gutter. Men can defecate in open but women sometimes even soil themselves standing in line. It is pretty horrible given that this is the same place responsible for making snacks for millions of Mumbai residents. [1]
[1] http://sanitation.indiawaterportal.org/english/node/2918 http://sanitation.indiawaterportal.org/english/node/2918
- lostlogin 11y agoIs that link your work? Do you have more about what you do?
- tn13 11y agoNo that is not the link to my work. The work I referred to was the work by a local Temple and I was a 15 year old volunteer who laid bricks for toilets. Never had the big picture that time.
- srean 11y agoThere is some irony in here. I know of cases where people broke up the toilets built with govt money just to sell the bricks. I am glad however, that the discussion has been less myopic than I would have otherwise expected: oh look at these poor Indians why don't we get some money and build them toilets.
- tn13 11y agoYes. The discussion around education in India however remains myopic. Lets build "free schools" for poor Indians remains the objective which has achieved very little.
- sanrights 11y agoI definitely agree that the community is integral in implementing long-term solutions. We believe that access to toilets is a right, and so our mission is to fight alongside these communities to realize access to this sanitation infrastructure. Community input starts with identifying the right location to put the facility (we focus on rural areas where the space is not an issue). Community members petition to get Indian government land handed over for us to build on, and local community members are the folks hired to run the facilities.