5 ms·
So.... Change your first name. It's called your legal name for a reason. Can you get away with your nickname in a number of systems? Sure, but when you run into
by joshstrange 11y ago
So.... Change your first name. It's called your legal name for a reason. Can you get away with your nickname in a number of systems? Sure, but when you run into issues you really don't have anyone to blame but yourself. Your complaint boils down to "I want to abuse the legal name system and everything should just work for me"
> And yet, so many institutions are incapable of handling the situation and insist on calling me by my first name, which is not who I am.
False, you may not consider that your first name but it IS your legal name and at the end of the day that's really the only thing that matters. We all have to conform to some system and it can't be "kstrauser's system" or "joshstrange's system". I feel for people with drop/user/select/null/etc in their name as they've done nothing wrong, but people not using their real first name and complaining when they have is just annoying.
- kstrauser 11y ago> False, you may not consider that your first name but it IS your legal name and at the end of the day that's really the only thing that matters. See, this is one of the misunderstandings from the article. Don't feel bad: many people make this mistake. But it is a mistake. Your legal name is the one you conduct business with. In my case, I conduct all business using my middle name. The fact that I was born with it doesn't make it any more valid than if it were a childhood nickname I'd kept around all my life. What matters is that it's the primary key I've been using to legitimately represent myself. I'm not a lawyer, but my lawyer is and I'm more inclined to side with his advice than yours here.
- joshstrange 11y agoLegal Name = Name on your birth certificate, pure and simple. Something isn't so just because you say it is. I can say my SSN is 123-45-6789 but that doesn't make it so.
- zyxley 11y ago> Legal Name = Name on your birth certificate Wrong, at least in the US. Common law precedent allows you to use whatever name you like, regardless of what's on official documents, as long as you're not doing it for fraudulent purposes. If you decide one day that you want to be "John Pfeffenheimer Gramblekins", you can go ahead and use that name in legal agreements and on your bills, as long as you're not trying to trick anyone into thinking that "John Pfeffenheimer Gramblekins" is a different person than your previous name. The same principle stands behind common-law name changes after marriage.
- kstrauser 11y ago> Legal Name = Name on your birth certificate, pure and simple. As a counterexample, my wife's current name is not on her birth certificate. > Something isn't so just because you say it is. Indeed. So we find ourselves in a teachable moment: you are wrong, but in a way that many other well-meaning people have been. I presume you find this subject interesting, so consider checking out http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-b... which is a list of things commonly thought to be true about human names but that actually aren't. I personally love these sorts of things. For instance, I was pretty sure I knew all about how calendars work until I attended a talk buy a guy who maintains a date library. He started throwing out edge case after edge case until I gave up any pretense that I had an inkling about the subject.
- philovivero 11y agoThanks for being so calm and informative on this subject. It is funny to see people trying to tell you you're wrong, when it's evident this is a subject you'd naturally become quite expert at.
- kstrauser 11y agoThanks, although I'm not so much an expert in the subject as someone who's had to deal with this time and again. It is a little frustrating to be corrected so many times by people not directly involved. When my paid lawyer says "sign your home purchase documents the same way you normally write your name", then I heed his recommendations. When I explain the situation to my (huge multinational) bank and they issue me checks and debit cards in my desired name, I'm sure they're not humoring me just for the fun of it and throwing banking regulations to the wind. Basically, several entrypoints into the legal and financial systems have vetted and agreed with my lawyer's interpretation. And yet, here we find ourselves having this discussion. :-D
- greenleafjacob 11y agoIt's not nearly that simple. Most scholars for example agree that the common law permits a right to change your name "with legal affect" without relying on state procedures or approval. [1] http://www.uclalawreview.org/pdf/57-1-7.pdf http://www.uclalawreview.org/pdf/57-1-7.pdf
- protomyth 11y ago> Legal Name = Name on your birth certificate, pure and simple. I know a few tribal members who would disagree and be correct in doing so. There are other names you sometimes get later in life depending on culture.
- twic 11y agoMy dad also goes by his middle name - he has a first name that is incredibly common in his nation of origin, so it's almost useless as a way of referring to him. You're the first person i've ever heard suggest that he's wrong to do that, and you are mistaken to do so.
- joshstrange 11y agoI'm not saying he is wrong to do so but that he has to deal with the consequences of doing so. Your legal name is what is on your birth certificate/green card/etc not what you say it is. You can make it whatever you want it to be by legally changing your name but until you do so your legal name is your legal name no matter what you want to say it is.
- mikeash 11y agoOne of the ways to legally change your name is to simply start using your new name. So it sounds like they've already done as you suggest.
- twic 11y agoHis legal name is not in question. The point is that the names people go by - that is, their names, that being what names are - are not always the same as their legal names.
- dalke 11y agoNo. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_name#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_name#United_States > Most state courts have held that a legally assumed name (i.e., for a non-fraudulent purpose) is a legal name and usable as their true name, though assumed names are often not considered the person's technically true name. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Name_change#Informal_methods_of_legal_name_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Name_change#Informal_methods_o... > A common law name (i.e. one assumed for a non-fraudulent purpose) is a legal name.[7] In most states a statutory method, while quick and definitive, only supplements the common law method,[8] unless the statute makes itself exclusive.
- aroberge 11y agoYou keep writing words to the effect that "your first name is your legal name" with full cultural blinders on. I was born in Quebec (Canada) and, for many generations, almost all boys from French speaking families were named Joseph second_name third_name Surname, and all girls were named Marie second_name third_name Surname. Most people use their third_name where you would use your first_name. Every legal document that I have (including my passport) is based on my "legal" third_name Surname.