4 ms·
> The actual page still exists and can still be accessed so nobodies freedom of speech is being curtailed... Google's freedom of speech is being curtailed. I t
by andrewflnr 11y ago
> The actual page still exists and can still be accessed so nobodies freedom of speech is being curtailed...
Google's freedom of speech is being curtailed. I thought I addressed this, but maybe not. Whether you think they're being jerks in exercising that right is entirely beside the point.
> If anything this is giving citizens the freedom of speech to say "I want this to be forgotten..."
A thousand times no. Freedom of speech is the right to literally say/write/etc "please let this be forgotten." You can say that until you're blue in the face and your fingers fall off. What is being discussed here, the government stepping in and forcing that request to be honored, is nothing more or less than censorship at the whim of the individual, or maybe a judge. This is not free speech, it is the exact opposite.
And don't try to tell me, "but I said only legitimate reasons!" That's a fantasy. A legal mechanism like this is 100% guaranteed to be abused. The DMCA is supposed to only be used for legitimate reasons too.
If we get used to Google being muzzled in this manner, eventually it will be common knowledge that you can't get the full truth on Google, so they will go elsewhere. Are you going to start filing "right to be forgotten" requests on everyone who mentions your malpractice suit except the original source? Every search engine, every aggregator built to get around precisely this law? Good luck if someone comes up with a peer-to-peer solution. How long do you really think it will be before someone gets upset that the source document is still available and demands that it be taken down too? Not long, if people start taking the right to be forgotten seriously.
We're already getting used to the idea that our actions have chance of becoming widely known, and that most people have some kind of stupid gaffe in their history. If you let things progress naturally, we'll get more used to it and reach some relatively sane equilibrium. Censorship throws away the chance to reach that point.