3 ms·
You're asking how it can be confidential? It's confidential because you signed a contract agreeing that it's confidential. Sure, if you got everyone who bought
by eli 17y ago
You're asking how it can be confidential? It's confidential because you signed a contract agreeing that it's confidential.
Sure, if you got everyone who bought your book to sign a contract agreeing not to write bad reviews, then you could potentially sue them if they violate that contract. Indeed I'm aware of several hardware and software products that at least claim that by using them you agree not to post bad reviews or benchmarks.
- baddox 17y agoYou can't change reality by signing a contract. If you signed a contract saying it was directions to build a time machine, would that make it so?
- houseabsolute 17y agoNone of the contracts mentioned in the post you're replying to purport to change reality. They just restrict what the signer is allowed to do.
- pyre 17y agoI think that the point that was attempting to come across in that post was that just because something is in a contract doesn't mean that it's enforceable. I can't sign a contract that says that if I don't crack a joke that makes you smile, you get to kill me. I could sign that contract, and you could kill me, but you'll still go to jail for it.
- sparky 17y agoI think seldo's comment above captures it. What you said is true, but you also can't force Apple to give you a development environment for their device and let you sell apps in their private store. They have offered to do so anyway, so long as you keep it to yourself. I would bet that many SDKs for closed devices (e.g. game consoles) are under similar restrictions. Can anyone comment on that?
- pyre 17y agoTo be the devil's advocate, most game console SDKs are sold at a much higher price therefore setting the barrier to entry much higher. Apple iPhone SDK = $99 Sony PS3 SDK = $10,250 [1] One could argue that $99 is affordable by most anyone. $10K? No so much. [1] http://www.betanews.com/article/Sony-slashes-price-of-PS3-SDK-to-fix-game-problem/1195491681 http://www.betanews.com/article/Sony-slashes-price-of-PS3-SD...
- anamax 17y ago> I think that the point that was attempting to come across in that post was that just because something is in a contract doesn't mean that it's enforceable. That may be the point, but it isn't relevant to this situation because NDAs on SDKs are legally enforceable. You don't have a legal right to an SDK.
- houseabsolute 17y agoThere is the idea of an unconscionable contract but I think Apple's legal team has at least a good faith belief that their NDA does not fall under that umbrella.
- gojomo 17y agoYou can promise to keep a secret. People do it all the time, sometimes informally, sometimes in writing. That's all 'confidential' means.
- seldo 17y agoWell, unlike the book, the Developer Program is an ongoing service. They're not saying it's illegal, they're saying if you break the NDA you will be barred from using their services in the future. Which, if you're a developer, is quite a threat.
- tlrobinson 17y agoAn example of one such vendor was posted here a few days ago: http://www.bannedbygaussian.org/ http://www.bannedbygaussian.org/ More at: http://www.eff.org/wp/dangerous-terms-users-guide-eulas http://www.eff.org/wp/dangerous-terms-users-guide-eulas