5 ms·
A mental disorder means a stable cluster of symptoms in a population such that it is (1) statistically abnormal, (2) distressful to a degree (clinical significa
by threatofrain 11y ago
A mental disorder means a stable cluster of symptoms in a population such that it is (1) statistically abnormal, (2) distressful to a degree (clinical significance), and (3) not ameliorated by a reasonable change in environment.
Statistical abnormality is one point that is debated among professionals today because some might say that if obesity becomes pandemic, it's still a disorder. Deafness is also an interesting discussion because there are deaf communities now, so a reasonable change in environment is possible.
One does not use science to determine if a cluster of symptoms warrants classification as a disorder. There is no inherency in the universe which demands that. Science can set arbitrary statistical brightlines, study the etiology of a stable cluster of symptoms, if it can be found, and then study a range of possible interventions to the distress.
Perhaps in the future, mental decline at age 90 will be considered a disorder, because everyone is mentally sharp even at age 100, the mental decline causes a lot of financial and social distress, and it's not ameliorated by a reasonable change in environment. In the past, it's comprehensible how homosexuality was (1) statistically abnormal, (2) distressful to a degree, and (3) not ameliorated by a reasonable change in environment.
People want a concept of mental disorder that is "objective". That's not possible. Disorder is absolutely context-bound.
- maratd 11y ago> People want a concept of mental disorder that is "objective". That's not possible. With a bit of effort, I think it is. I disagree with your definition of a disorder. A disorder is anything that negatively impacts an individual when compared to the mean. With a bit of effort, you can statistically measure that based on fecundity.
- alanwatts 11y agoMental classifications are purely subjective by default.
- maratd 11y agoNot true. We're starting to identify the mutations responsible. There's nothing subjective about that.
- jlg23 11y ago"A disorder is anything that negatively impacts an individual when compared to the mean." Not every deviation from the mean has only negative impacts (e.g. A person with OCD probably makes a better air traffic controller.) and the definition of what is "negative" can actually change over time. Last but not least we should look at why they are negatively impacted. The impact often comes from society and maybe society should be more tolerant instead of medicating everyone who is deviating from the mean.
- emodendroket 11y ago> (e.g. A person with OCD probably makes a better air traffic controller. I very much doubt that is the case
- DanBC 11y agoYour point - that mental illnesses aren't always seen as entirely negative by the people who have them is a good point. And this point is excellent: >The impact often comes from society and maybe society should be more tolerant However > A person with OCD probably makes a better air traffic controller. Obsessive Compulsive Disorder is often a severely debilitating[1] illness. It's marked by intrusive thoughts, and rituals to cope with those intrusive thoughts. I can't see how those could help someone be a better air-traffic controller. Here's some information from a UK charity: http://www.mind.org.uk/information-support/types-of-mental-health-problems/obsessive-compulsive-disorder-ocd/ http://www.mind.org.uk/information-support/types-of-mental-h... The most important part from that link is probably this, which talks about the difference between the normal anxieties that everyone has, and what happens in OCD. > Although many people experience minor obsessions (e.g. worrying about leaving the gas on, or if the door is locked) and compulsions (e.g. rituals, like avoiding the cracks in the pavement), these don’t significantly interfere with their daily lives, or are short-lived. > If you experience OCD, your obsessions and compulsions will cause you considerable fear and distress. They will also take up a significant amount of time, and disrupt your ability to carry on with your day-to-day to life, including doing daily chores, going to work, or maintaining relationships with friends and family. OCD is probably not going to help someone be a better air traffic controller. OCD is a much misunderstood illness, and there's some stigma around it, so I hope you don't mind me dumping some information here. [1] WHO list OCD in their top 20 debilitating illnesses. http://www.who.int/bulletin/volumes/82/11/en/858.pdf http://www.who.int/bulletin/volumes/82/11/en/858.pdf > Of the 10 leading causes of YLD in the world among individuals of all ages, four are psychiatric conditions, with unipolar depression being the leading cause (2). Among individuals between the ages of 15 and 44, panic disorder, drug use disorders, and obsessive–compulsive disorder (OCD) were included in the top 20 disorders. (YLD == Years lost to disability)
- Almaviva 11y agoLife is distressful to a degree. That's a meaningless criterion devoid of all content which invites arbitrary judgement.
- specialist 11y agothreatofrain is explaining, not defending.
- Almaviva 11y agoI'm not attacking the parent, I'm attacking the definition being explained.
- mcguire 11y agoThe colors of visible light form a continuous spectrum. "Red" vs. "blue" is a meaningless criterion devoid of all content which invites arbitrary judgement.
- Almaviva 11y agoThat's not a good comparison. Red and blue have very objective definitions given that we have three types of light receptors in our eyes, and a given kind of light can be measured to activate the "blue" or "red" kind without any subjective input.
- emodendroket 11y agoIt is sometimes speculated that Homer wrote about "wine-red seas" because the ancient Greeks considered blue and red "the same" color. Or, to take a more modern example, the Japanese consider blue and green the same color (there are words that can distinguish, of course, but we have words that can distinguish various shades of the same color too). Clearly the division into different colors involves some degree of subjectivity and yet it doesn't make sense to claim that, therefore, words for colors are meaningless.
- vanderZwan 11y ago> Deafness is also an interesting discussion because there are deaf communities now, so a reasonable change in environment is possible. Not only that, but the "traditional" way of "treating" the Deaf was to force them to learn to vocalise, and to forbid them from learning sign language. The reasoning being that they should integrate with regular society as much as possible, and this was the best way to ensure that. Of course, in reality it is like forcing blind people to communicate exclusively via pictionary. Luckily this has been changing for a while now.
- StanislavPetrov 11y agoScience is objective. Psychiatry is not objective. Psychiatry is not science.
- jmcmichael 11y agoDo you believe that psychiatry provides us valid knowledge that allows us to identify, study, and treat individuals who have mental influences that cause them to be a danger to themselves or society? If not, by what means to propose that we do so?
- Karunamon 11y agoHomosexuality was once considered a psychiatric disorder. That alone tells you that it is a reflection of social norms, not objective truth, and therefore, inherently unscientific. This is different from medicine (which also had an interesting past as it evolved) in that there's broad, objective consensus as to what's harmful and what's not, and its work is detailed and reproducible and there's few questions how the mechanisms of action work - infectious particles harm the body and cause disease, and there's no debate on that matter. Whether or not psychiatry can help those who are a danger to themselves or others (answer: of course it can.. one way or another) is orthogonal to whether it's scientific or not.
- DasIch 11y agoThe idea of evidence-based medicine and using the scientific method in medicine came up in the 1960s. It took longer still for it to become widely used and there are still massive problems in that area today, take a look at drug testing as an example. You can't reasonably claim psychiatry to be significantly more or less scientific than medicine. You're idea that there is an objective consensus on what's harmful and what's not is simply ridiculously wrong. Just look at discussions about making insecticides or pesticides illegal that come up quite regularly.
- Karunamon 11y agoYou're idea that there is an objective consensus on what's harmful and what's not is simply ridiculously wrong. I didn't say for all things, but I did say broad. And most importantly, the results of the studies have nothing to do with what people think is harmful or wrong, only what actually can be measured and reproduced. People argue over climate science too (and for the same reason as your counterexample). There's still broad consensus at the end of the day. Meanwhile, the psych "science" is inherently anchored to whatever the social norms of the day are. Medical science and biology can define a healthy body with much more certainty and detail than psychiatry can define a healthy set of thoughts.
- pessimizer 11y ago> A mental disorder means a stable cluster of symptoms in a population such that it is (1) statistically abnormal, (2) distressful to a degree (clinical significance), and (3) not ameliorated by a reasonable change in environment. 1) Every individual is statistically abnormal. That's how they're identifiable. It's debated amongst professionals because there are absolutely no consistent criteria for behavioural normality that wouldn't include wide swaths of undistressed people. 2) is incoherent in practice. Mental disease is diagnosed in people because they are not distressed by things that "should" distress people. Mental disease is also diagnosed if people are distressed by the reaction of others to their symptoms, not by the symptoms themselves. 3) "reasonable change" is a hint that 3) is completely arbitrary. The context that the concept of non-physical mental disorder is bound in is a historical accident, non-physical mental disease doesn't translate between cultures (entirely culturally-bound and fashion-following), and most of our current concepts of mental disease have origins dependent on things like the order in which we happened to discover certain neurotransmitters and superstitions about epileptic seizures making people sane. Mental illness is defined as when you don't get your work done, or you make it difficult for other people to get their work done. All of the handwaving around it, and the fabricated physical theories applied to a wide range of "disorders" that largely amount to disobedience and differing opinions and values, corrupt our society and undermine democracy. You take the drugs and you do what you're told, or you will be medicated for your own protection. It's also class/race-based - the range of behaviors a suburban white girl would be medicated for are largely different than the ones an inner city black boy would be medicated for, even though they would get the same diagnosis (since diagnoses are based on "distress.") This is not new. Every third rebellious kid I knew in high school 25 years ago was diagnosed with Oppositional Defiant Disorder or Bipolar Disorder, and had month-long stints in mental hospitals that began when they stayed out all night that one time, or flunked a semester, or got caught drinking or smoking pot. ADD wasn't quite as trendy then, and the range of products being sold to parents for it was narrower.
- jmcmichael 11y agoDo you believe that mental disorders exist? If so, how would you go about identifying and treating them? If not, what empirically verifiable means do you know of to identify people who are a danger to themselves or society, and treat them?