3 ms·
Let's consider another market. Gag gifts. Suppose a streamer made their living by producing funny videos of entertaining or awkward situations where the gag gif
by Spivak 11y ago
Let's consider another market. Gag gifts. Suppose a streamer made their living by producing funny videos of entertaining or awkward situations where the gag gift is used. People on YT watch the stream, have a laugh, and then don't buy the actual product because it's only shocking/funny a few times before it gets old. Arguably you're paying for the experience of a gag gift rather than the actual product. Should the manufacturer be able to demand the videos be taken down?
You could do this all day with products which sell themselves on an experience. You could have a streamer buy expensive clothes, wear them with a secret camera and record the (or produce) reactions they get from a first person perspective. After you watch the video, why buy the clothes since you've lived vicariously through them?
How about food shows, guy goes to diners, drive-ins, or maybe some dives, interviews the chef, orders their specialty and then films their reaction. Is he not literally making money on someone else's work by this reasoning? Without the restaurants he's got no show.
Sure you could argue he needs permission to film on private property and the show is better with their consent but there's nothing really stopping him from ordering take-out and then eating it somewhere else.
Edit: Since I predict responses might be something like, "in these specific instances here's why a person would still pay for the product" you've got to do better than that -- doing something legally that costs someone sales doesn't suddenly make it illegal, and I could make the same point back at you about games.
- sp332 11y agoThe owners on that show still get paid though. And every one of them gets the location printed in big letters on the screen, which is more than some of these streamers are doing.