3 ms·
"Things like roads and trains ... are a public good." No, they're not. From Wikipedia (which matches what I learnt in economics class): "... a public good is
by rahimnathwani 11y ago
"Things like roads and trains ... are a public good."
No, they're not.
From Wikipedia (which matches what I learnt in economics class):
"... a public good is a good that is both non-excludable and non-rivalrous in that individuals cannot be effectively excluded from use and where use by one individual does not reduce availability to others."
Trains are definitely excludable (can't get on without a ticket) and rivalrous (the train can get full, meaning no space for additional passengers).
Roads are obviously rivalrous (gridlock!) but you could argue the extent to which they are excludable. Sure, there are toll roads, but it would be hard for you to exclude me from using the road in front of my house. With technology, though, you could make me pay for usage according to some arbitrarily-designed tariff, though, which would force me to self-exclude if I weren't willing to pay the price.
- kennywinker 11y agoThose a mucky definitions. Roads are excludable in just the same way as trains... you don't have a car, you can't get on roads. That's economic exclusion, and a bigger excluder than transit fares in most urban settings (not to mention requiring a license, no DUIs, etc). A good transit system has very low fares, as they try to include everyone even the poorest people. A good transit system also has very rarely full trains, and more coming along in 5min if that one's full. If you're arguing that roads are a public good, then you absolutely must accept that transit is one... and any rational person would agree that they are a far greater good than roads and highways (at least, within the urban centers).
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"Those a mucky definitions." There was exactly one definition in my comment: that of a public good. The remainder was my reasoning for why roads and trains do not fit that definition of a public good. With which part(s) do you disagree? "If you're arguing that roads are a public good..." I'm not arguing that. That's why I started my comment with "No, they're not". I'm not sure how to respond to the rest of your comment, as your main point (that public transit is good) is orthogonal to mine.
- kennywinker 11y agoMucky definitions: excludable and rivalrous. > Roads are obviously rivalrous (gridlock!) but you could argue the extent to which they are excludable That sounds like you're arguing that roads are in some way a public good, or more of a public good than trains, to me...