5 ms·
I find it interesting that the article points out that neither mass transit riders nor automobile drivers pay the full cost of their trips. Yet it never asks th
by pdonis 11y ago
I find it interesting that the article points out that neither mass transit riders nor automobile drivers pay the full cost of their trips. Yet it never asks the obvious question: couldn't that be the main reason why both forms of transportation are inefficient?
- twoodfin 11y agoThere's a difference though: If it were politically feasible, a marginally higher gas tax could fund all road construction & maintenance. People might drive a little less, but the system wouldn't go into a death spiral. If mass transit riders had to fund the system purely through user fees, the result for most systems would be a collapse, as fewer riders would require higher prices leading to fewer riders...
- CalRobert 11y agoAt least in the US, the gas tax would need to be substantially higher. If we accounted for the externalities (dead people hit by cars, mostly, and perhaps the potential collapse of human civilization as we render much of the planet uninhabitable) the gas tax would rise even more. If anyone asks I'll dig up the math because citation is important (and I'm not sure I did it right years ago), but I remember doing some calculation a while back that we could pay to remove the carbon emitted by gasoline with a tax that made it around $15 a gallon. That doesn't seem bad, really. Perfectly happy societies function with $8-$11 a gallon gas, and not destroying civilization seems worth it. Edit - though I realize that by the latter argument, reducing the population is, in a horribly macabre way, a positive externality. It's not one I support, though.
- pdonis 11y ago> perhaps the potential collapse of human civilization as we render much of the planet uninhabitable The problem with trying to base taxes on something like this is that you would have to be really, really sure this consequence was unavoidable. I certainly am not convinced that climate science is accurate enough to support such a claim (or economics, for that matter, since part of the claim is really about the economics of adaptation to climate change vs. mitigation of climate change).
- CalRobert 11y ago"you would have to be really, really sure this consequence was unavoidable" Why? Wouldn't we actually need to be really, really sure this consequence was extremely unlikely? If an asteroid had only a 50/50 chance of hitting Earth would we be wise to disregard it?
- pdonis 11y ago> Wouldn't we actually need to be really, really sure this consequence was extremely unlikely? No, because that would imply a level of predictive power that we do not have in climate science and economics. Basically, with the accuracy of prediction we currently have in those fields, it is impossible to be sure that the impact of climate change will be extremely unlikely to cause severe disruption of our civilization. And the key point is that that is true regardless of whether or not we spend trillions of dollars on trying to mitigate climate change. So the only real choice we have is adaptation; any resources we spend on getting better at adapting to climate change will at least move us in a positive direction, whereas we can't be sure of that with regard to resources spent on attempts at mitigation. In order for adaptation to not be a rational response, we would have to be so sure that climate change was going to cause severe disruption that it was worth trying to mitigate the change even though we can't predict what specific actions would do that. In other words, we would have to be so desperate that it was worth trying whatever mitigations we could think of without even trying to predict their effects. Climate change alarmists would like us all to believe that we are that desperate, but the case for that does not stand up to scrutiny. > If an asteroid had only a 50/50 chance of hitting Earth would we be wise to disregard it? If an asteroid had a 50/50 chance of hitting the Earth, we would be able to predict that specific actions we could take could reduce that probability to something negligible, because we have very accurate predictive power with regard to the orbits of astronomical bodies, at least on the relevant timescales (years to decades). Given that, of course we would not be wise to disregard the prediction. But, as above, that argument does not apply to the climate, because we can't predict the effects of any specific actions well enough to know how, or even if, they will reduce the probability of a severe disruption to our civilization.
- pdonis 11y ago> If mass transit riders had to fund the system purely through user fees, the result for most systems would be a collapse If this is true, doesn't it imply that mass transit is not economically viable?
- CalRobert 11y agoWeirdly we focus on subsidizing big machines to move people even in situations where making it possible to walk would be a better solution for all parties.
- pdonis 11y agoWhat sorts of situations do you have in mind? I have a commute to work that is about 20 miles each way. How could it possibly be made feasible for me to walk?
- CalRobert 11y agoPlaces could be designed where it's uncommon to need to go 20 miles. I refer to dense, mixed use areas where housing and jobs are close together. This isn't ALWAYS feasible, of course (a coal power plant is ideally nowhere near housing), but it can be done an awful lot more than we do now. If I may ask, where do you live? How much of that 20 mile commute is through parking lots? Agriculture? Suburban sprawl? Undeveloped land?
- pdonis 11y ago> Places could be designed where it's uncommon to need to go 20 miles... Sure, but that's not the same as saying people will want to live there. This is really the underlying problem with the whole mass transit discussion: mass transit proponents start with the premise that mass transit is preferable to driving, and then deduce what kinds of living and working arrangements will make mass transit work well. Then they assume that everyone can be forced to adopt those living and working arrangements, whether they want to or not. Btw, this is also true of proponents of driving: they start with the premise that driving is preferable, and then assume everyone can be forced to adopt living and working arrangements that make driving work well, whether they want to or not. But of course an even better answer would be to let people's preferences for living and working arrangements determine what sort of transportation to build, not the other way around. > How much of that 20 mile commute is through parking lots? Agriculture? Suburban sprawl? Undeveloped land? My commute is through fairly densely populated suburbs of a large metropolitan area. Most of the suburbs date from before sprawl became a thing, so they are more compact than most suburbs; but they are also poorly designed compared to more recent suburbs--they are highly suboptimal for driving and walking and public transportation. For that reason, many people (including me) do not want to live in those older, denser suburbs, and are willing to trade a longer commute for more living space and better designed communities. (Other people are starting to move back into the even more densely populated city areas, where walking and mass transit work at least tolerably well. But that requires accepting much less living space for the same money.) I should also point out another solution to the transportation problem, at least for commuting: telework. I expect that to become more popular as an alternative to large investments in transportation infrastructure. Many jobs do not require physical presence, at least not all day, every day, and the cost of building out high speed internet, while not negligible, is a lot less than the cost of building and maintaining highways, railways, etc.