3 ms·
This is a free speech issue, plain and simple. Google is being entirely truthful in saying "this is a page that exists", and no one has a moral right to tell th
by andrewflnr 11y ago
This is a free speech issue, plain and simple. Google is being entirely truthful in saying "this is a page that exists", and no one has a moral right to tell them they can't. This whole idea of a "right to be forgotten" is purest excrement of bull, and can only be enforced by violating the rights of free speech and, if you took the phrasing seriously, rights to our own thoughts. But of course they don't take the phrasing seriously, because that would reveal what a runny load of crap it is.
- philipov 11y agoDoes France have a protection for free speech?
- andrewflnr 11y agoI sure as hell hope so. Censorship is widely regarded as a bad thing.
- orf 11y agoMaybe it's the European in me but I think the right to be forgotten is a good idea. Maybe not implemented the best, but the idea is sound. Say someone published a book of peoples names and photos, complete with a description of the worst thing they have done during their lifetime. Sure, if your a doctor and you had some malpractice problems then it's a good thing that people can see that, but that time you got drunk and did something stupid that ended up in the news? Should that be the first thing that pops up when searching for you? Wouldn't that effect your employment prospects, your future? Is there any actual value to anyone in that being only a search away, other than it matches a particular query for your name? Google is being truthful in saying "this is a page that exists", but does it have to if the person the page is about has a legitimate reason for wanting it removed? The actual page still exists and can still be accessed so nobodies freedom of speech is being curtailed, this just gives citizens a right to say "maybe I don't want the fact I was wrongly convicted of something to follow me around forever". If anything this is giving citizens the freedom of speech to say "I want this to be forgotten, it's not me and shouldn't haunt me forever".
- CamperBob2 11y agoThere are a lot of things that are good ideas, but that cannot be implemented without side effects that far outweigh any conceivable benefits to society. The "right to be forgotten" is one of them.
- grahamburger 11y agoThe implementation really is the problem here. There just isn't a way that this can be implemented fairly. Or maybe there is, but trying to force it before we've found the right way to implement it just isn't working. Obviously it would be great if the Internet really could forget about the stupid things I've done. It would be even better (for me) if I could get everyone to literally forget about those things. Of course there's not an ethical way for me to get other people to literally forget things, and I think what GP is saying (and I agree) is that there's also not an ethical way to get the Internet to forget things.
- orf 11y ago> there's also not an ethical way to get the Internet to forget things. Sure there is, be lucky enough to have a common name (or one shared with a celebrity) and wait until enough news piles ontop of your bad news that nobody will ever find it.
- grahamburger 11y agoLol I guess that's true. Or start to use a nickname / middle name. Or even just do enough neutral / good things that get reported online that you bury your own bad stories.
- jim-greer 11y agoDo you think a customer service representative at Google should be the one making this decision? Seems like it should be a French official. There are hundreds of thousands to deal with though.
- jim-greer 11y agoDo you think a customer service representative at Google should be the one making this decision? Seems like it should be a French official. There are hundreds of thousands to deal with though.