9 ms·
On Let's Plays – That Dragon, Cancer
- TillE 11y agoI think it's extremely unlikely that this has a significant impact on sales. But I understand why some developers get upset about it, in the same way Jonathan Blow was upset about piracy despite massive sales. It's a loss of control. You made a thing and you don't want people just taking it. Emotionally, that makes perfect sense. But empirically, these factors have never been make-or-break for any game. Heavily pirated games are also huge sellers. Firewatch is doing very well right now despite being a similarly YouTube-able game.
- jamie_ca 11y agoI don't disagree on the sales impact - if you're spending a sufficient portion of your day watching videos of people playing a game, and that game isn't streamed, you're FAR more likely to watch a different game than actually go and buy a copy and play it. That said, the irony is strong here when streamers are complaining about not being able to monetize their stream of someone else's work without restriction.
- Nadya 11y ago>That said, the irony is strong here when streamers are complaining about not being able to monetize their stream of someone else's work without restriction. They are monetizing their time spent/interaction with viewers which is a very different thing and something people do monetize (see: speaker's fees, counseling fees, adviser fees) That's the idea behind monetizing streams/streamers accepting donations. It's a way the viewers can support the person to stream for X hours a day and have it be something they can routinely do because they are being paid for their time. It just so happens that time is being spent playing a game that is the result of someone else's work. I think it is stupid to deny free publicity - but maybe there's a reason why I'm not in marketing/advertising. Not sure if necessary, but possible bias: I don't monetize through ads and prefer to accept donations, but I have streamed on occasion and have received donations for doing so.
- stcredzero 11y agoThat's the idea behind monetizing streams/streamers accepting donations. It's a way the viewers can support the person to stream for X hours a day and have it be something they can routinely do because they are being paid for their time. It just so happens that time is being spent playing a game that is the result of someone else's work. To me, the position of enlightened self interest would have the Let's Play creators offering their support by urging their viewers to give Patreon donations or buy the game. Given that is happening, then it's time for the game creators to start rethinking their business model.
- greggman 11y agoShare the revenue? Don't know what the correct split is. As a game creator who spends 2+ years per game on a team of 20 (so 40 man years) and then some one spends 4 to 80 hours recording themselves playing and then editing I'd tend to think the game creators deserve the lion's share of the revenue but maybe I could be convinced otherwise. Youtube already does this for music (not sure they actually share revenue) but they do at least provide a way for the music creator (or the creator's representatives) to get revenue when someone else uses the music. A better sharing arrangement sounds like mostly a win/win --- Let me add, while the Let's Player can certainly be entertaining if people are really watching for their entertainment value then they shouldn't need the game to get viewers. In other words, it seems arguable viewers view for the games more than the Let's Player. If people would tune in without the games then there's no reason for the Let's Player to have the games at all. Just be an entertaining person like a some of the more popular youtubers.
- thedufer 11y agoYou're significantly devaluing the streamer's contribution. The streamers who make money have spent years cultivating a following. That network effect is hard to value, but I'm pretty sure 0 isn't quite right.
- Nadya 11y ago>Share the revenue? Don't know what the correct split is. As a game creator who spends 2+ years per game on a team of 20 (so 40 man years) and then some one spends 4 to 80 hours recording themselves playing and then editing I'd tend to think the game creators deserve the lion's share of the revenue but maybe I could be convinced otherwise. A game nobody has heard of and never will hear of vs any popular streamer who has spent 3+ years streaming and has 1,000's if not 10,000's of followers. Some of those followers will buy the game. That's the dev's split. Even a no-name streamer (like myself) who pulls in 10-20 people tops during a good hour can still manage to sell some copies of the game merely by playing it (assuming they're enjoying it/it's a decent game worth buying). The dev still get's their split: free advertisement. Dev's are, of course, free to not let streamers stream their game. I think it's stupid and wouldn't buy their game on principle: largely I assume the worst. Is the game so bad they want people purchasing it without seeing any gameplay? Well, I'll pass. Myself and 100,000's of others who have changed their purchasing decisions from "game reviews" to "someone who's gaming taste is similar to mine enjoys it and it looks fun". Game development is a business. Fail to keep up with the times and find yourself using an outdated business model and you will go out of business. It's just a matter of how long it takes. For better or worse, many people make their game purchasing decisions based on streamers and seeing live gameplay so judge if a game looks fun or not before purchasing. I think a dev is free to not allow people to stream their game or to profit from streaming their game. But I will point out to them that they're shooting themselves in the foot and that I think they should reconsider. The only games that I've ever seen hurt by free advertisement are games which are awfully bad. Which I consider a win for the consumer, even if the dev loses out on. Just like any other business: it doesn't matter how hard you worked on something if the end product was bad. It's sucks for the creator/people who spent so much time on it, but that's how business works and I'll side with the consumers every time.
- Spivak 11y agoLet's consider another market. Gag gifts. Suppose a streamer made their living by producing funny videos of entertaining or awkward situations where the gag gift is used. People on YT watch the stream, have a laugh, and then don't buy the actual product because it's only shocking/funny a few times before it gets old. Arguably you're paying for the experience of a gag gift rather than the actual product. Should the manufacturer be able to demand the videos be taken down? You could do this all day with products which sell themselves on an experience. You could have a streamer buy expensive clothes, wear them with a secret camera and record the (or produce) reactions they get from a first person perspective. After you watch the video, why buy the clothes since you've lived vicariously through them? How about food shows, guy goes to diners, drive-ins, or maybe some dives, interviews the chef, orders their specialty and then films their reaction. Is he not literally making money on someone else's work by this reasoning? Without the restaurants he's got no show. Sure you could argue he needs permission to film on private property and the show is better with their consent but there's nothing really stopping him from ordering take-out and then eating it somewhere else. Edit: Since I predict responses might be something like, "in these specific instances here's why a person would still pay for the product" you've got to do better than that -- doing something legally that costs someone sales doesn't suddenly make it illegal, and I could make the same point back at you about games.
- sp332 11y agoThe owners on that show still get paid though. And every one of them gets the location printed in big letters on the screen, which is more than some of these streamers are doing.
- fenomas 11y ago> if ... that game isn't streamed, you're FAR more likely to watch a different game than actually go and buy a copy and play it Surely the relevant question is whether people would be more likely to buy if the game is streamed, but a few more streamers posted a link and refrained from spoiling the ending? That's what the article is asking for, not for everyone to stop streaming.
- TheCowboy 11y agoI'd be interested in seeing more variations. I don't think it's as simple as exposure increasing sales by a constant factor. I imagine there are diminishing returns for some types of games, particularly narrative style games with lower replay value. There's also an argument that only showing a portion of a game would get people to buy the game to finish it themselves. Unless there's an option for revenue sharing between streamers and game makers, which creates more of a win/win situation. I can imagine arrangements in the future where popular streamers are contracted by game companies, and only those streamers have permission to stream a game. Or they hire a streamer to produce the video for them, then upload it and collect the ad revenue in perpetuity. Sometimes the arguments against small companies being rightly worried about not generating enough revenue start sounding like the offers of "exposure" that designers often receive in exchange for unpaid work.
- bluesilver07 11y agoI think the impact on the sales would depend on the type of game. Like he explains in the blog - "it can especially benefit those who make competitive or sandbox games. However, for a short, relatively linear experience like ours, for millions of viewers, Let’s Play recordings of our content satisfy their interest and they never go on to interact with the game in the personal way that we intended for it to be experienced. "
- Joof 11y agoHow do you combat this? Realistically speaking. Here's how: Ask major let's-play channels to explain how it's meant to be experienced firsthand and they should come watch after they've played. Not for money, but for the experience. Toby fox did this with Undertale on game grumps and it was noted that there is a significant lag time in number of viewers that picked up later which indicates that people actually followed this advice. They trust the let's players' opinion. In reality it probably still helps sales. I routinely buy games that are high up on twitch that I hadn't heard of before.
- wmf 11y agoDon't market it as a game? AFAIK people don't post "let's watch" videos of movies.
- derefr 11y agoSure they do; • MST3K-izations of movies are plentiful. But there's a higher bar to them; viewers expect the commentator to be enhancing a movie that might otherwise be unwatchable, not just adding their thoughts. • "Directors' commentary" (and "actors' commentary", etc.) audio streams are also plentiful. If someone's opinion on the movie as it progresses would be specifically interesting, then people will want to combine the two.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> AFAIK people don't post "let's watch" videos of movies. Many people do post "blind reaction" videos for various series. They're quite popular; many "reaction" channels have tens of thousands of subscribers. In those, the reaction is the valuable contribution; it can be fun to watch something you've previously enjoyed and see how others react to it.
- Joof 11y agoYou may be on to something; although I think having an actual let's player may be necessary. Now I'm going to get a bit artsy. Games are typically about the interaction between the player and the game and how that player reacts is a significant part of the experience. Let's plays sort of mediate this experience by allowing the audience to see the reactions of the let's player. This is much less powerful, but sometimes the audience actually prefers the less powerful experience. Horrer games are popular to watch because people don't always like being scared (but watching other people getting scared is pretty entertaining). That Dragon, Cancer likely suffers because it's not a game that makes you feel good, it's an intense experience; it's easy to prefer the less-intense, mediated experience. As a result, the sales overall may suffer (and the artists might be frustrated that people aren't playing it 'properly'). It almost needs a new business model. I think we can agree that more games like this is a good thing.
- slavik81 11y agoFor many games, a recording of someone playing it is so different from the actual game itself that I strongly support giving rights to streamers. However, their point is well-made. This game is more similar to a movie than it is to, say, Minecraft. It's reasonable to reflect that in how recordings are treated. Their game is not particularly interesting to me, but it seems they made something unique. I hope it eventually pays off for them.
- tomc1985 11y agoHasn't anyone seen how kids obsess over Let's Play? I've talked to several kids who almost prefer watching Lets Play over playing any given game. That South Park episode was spot on. Developers should be alarmed!
- 2bitencryption 11y agoI don't think 'kids' obsess so much over Let's Plays as they do over the characters doing the playthrough (piewdiepie, whoever else is big, etc). You're ten. You don't have a debit/credit card. You can't buy games on Steam. Even if you could, your parents might not even let you play them (GTA, Fallout 4, etc). But you have a smartphone with a 4k display, and probably access to an iPad, and certainly a laptop at your disposal, and all you need is a browser to access Youtube. So you watch games instead. You don't care much about immersing yourself in the game's world, you care about the guy screaming "oh my godddddd!! what the shiiiiiiiit!" and making comments that ten year olds find funny. I don't think this equates to "kids will never play games when they grow up since they are so used to watching them instead." Eventually they grow out of this phase and play games like mature people do. Of course, that only covers the "Youtube Personality" clique of Let's Plays. I myself watch narrative and immersive Let's Plays for games I certainly don't have the time or money to play anyway (Firewatch, a bunch of indie horror games I'm too scared to play, etc).
- mattmanser 11y agoI, a 37 year old man, had heard of infamous 2nd son but don't have a playstation. So I googled a let's play just to check out the gameplay, intending to watch 5 minutes, and ended up watching pewdiepie play the whole game. Be as disdainful and insulting all you want, but I found him funny, charming and thoroughly enjoyable, it let me watch the story like a film, but with a touch of the camaraderie of playing a game with friends like I used to when I was younger.
- vacri 11y agoIt's worth noting that the Let's Play folks actually add something to the experience. I'm not much of a watcher, but I started watching vegeta311 play Dark Souls on youtube, and before I knew it, 6 hours had passed. I was amazed at the guy's seemingly-casual skill - I'd sunk many hours into Dark Souls, but it was the skill I was watching for, not the game.
- vacri 11y agoWell, when you make a product that's more like a movie than a game (two-hour linear story where you experience everything by watching a video), then the public will treat it more like a movie than a game. It's even priced like a movie - $15 for 2 hours of content. The problem isn't the Let's Play world, the problem is that the product is an edge case. The article sort of skims right by this issue while recognising it: And for games with more expansive or replayable gameplay, it can directly benefit developers. There's your problem right there - you 'made a movie, not a game', and released it through gaming channels. Another point is that there are literally tens of thousands of games out there, and people use Let's Play not just for entertainment, but to see if a game is any good before purchasing. Essentially they use it for demo-ing the product, and if your game and your 'demo' are essentially the same thing, then that's a bad business decision, regardless of how much soul you poured into the product. Harsh, but if you're complaining from a business point of view, then you have to deal with harsh realities. For my own experience, I saw it crop up, and thought "Why would I want to spend $15 for a short game about cancer?". I was curious about it, but not so curious as to drop $15... or even search out a Let's Play myself. I imagine most of the Let's Play audience were similar - suggesting that $1/viewer is somewhat realistic recovery for lost sales... that's nonsense, in my opinion. Finally, a bonus problem: When your game is two hours long and you distribute through Steam, which has a no-questions-asked refund policy for 2 hours or less of gameplay, then a lot of those casual viewers you're after will just take that money back.
- adnzzzzZ 11y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted when this is exactly right. If you don't want this problem then don't make something with low amount of content that people can be done with in just a few hours.
- sp332 11y agoSometimes it's not about how long a movie or game is. It can still be really powerful to experience it even if it's short. Anyways $15 seems like a reasonably small amount for a game that took years to develop.
- striking 11y agoChances are that the people who are just watching the LP version of your game won't buy it. Sorry, but it's true.
- sp332 11y agoBut it could, at least in theory, expose the game to a few more people who will buy it. Whether that's a net gain depends on a lot of factors, but in this case, it seems clear they're losing sales.
- striking 11y agoIt looks to me that they made a huge investment into a game that wouldn't necessarily pay them back. Profits on games aren't always that great, especially for indie titles. It's not that they're losing sales, it's that they don't have many sales. And you need to pay 8 people somehow.
- sp332 11y agoIt is a little disconcerting that a game with such wide and generally positive coverage would not be able to make any money.
- striking 11y agoIt wasn't published by a massive publisher. It didn't get "hype". And it had a massive production budget. Realize that most game programmers at AAA studios are far underpaid and overworked.
- verroq 11y ago>have an unprofitable business model >become unprofitable >beg for donations If their game is a "relative linear experience" then why would anyone "go on to interact with the game in the personal way that we intended for it to be experienced".
- ball_of_lint 11y agoYou are assuming let's plays. On the flip side, consider if they aggressively challenged every let's play made of their game. Then their game is again profitable. They are showing courtesy and and doing people a favor by allowing let's plays to exist, but are now kindly asking for a favor back.
- MollyR 11y agofwiw I watch the occasional let's play video to confirm if a game is worth my time or money.
- Akkuma 11y agoInterest doesn't equate to profit if they have no other avenue to experience the "game". There are so many ways to entertain oneself that people could simply move onto something else readily available without paying for That Dragon, Cancer.
- hodwik 11y agoIt would not help them. The kids would be up in arms if they threatened litigation.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoNone of your bullet points are actually in the article.
- verroq 11y agoThose are merely my observations
- turaw 11y agoIf anyone read this line: "And that is this: our studio has not yet seen a single dollar from sales." and also wondered what they're talking about, this excerpt from the Wikipedia article on their game [1] might help: "Razer Inc., who acquired the Ouya platform and property in 2015, stated that all revenue from sales of That Dragon, Cancer on Ouya would be donated to the Morgan Adams Foundation and Family House SF, two charities that had assisted the Greens' during Joel's treatment in San Francisco." [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/That_Dragon,_Cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/That_Dragon,_Cancer
- Splines 11y agoFYI, there might be spoilers on the wikipedia page. I haven't played the game so I don't know how much they tell you but if you're planning on playing the game I would avoid the wikipedia page for now. (I was expecting a "Plot" section that I could avoid reading.)
- millettjon 11y agoRadiolab did a story about this. http://www.radiolab.org/story/cathedral/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/cathedral/
- stephenitis 11y agoThis was amazing thanks for sharing.
- pmiller2 11y agoI think this pretty much says it all: > a short, relatively linear experience like ours If you want to make money, don't do that.
- AimHere 11y agoWhy not? It worked for the Gone Home and Firewatch people.
- Trisell 11y agoI think we are also seeing an increase in lets plays due to the aging of the gaming population. I'm 31 grew up gaming, spending hundreds of hours each month gaming. Now I have a job 2 kids and a life. I barely have time to watch a movie once a week, let alone sit down and play a game that requires 20-40 hours of game play. Yet I spend most of my work days sitting at a desk writing code with my headphones on. It is much easier to turn on Quill 18 playing xcom, and enjoy the game and his commentary, while working, then it is to try and fit playing xcom into my daily life. Where I play for a week, the put the game down, and having to start over in a month when I have time again, yet don't remember any part of what I was doing. Also the demographics of games are changing. When I was young, I played C&C, games that took more thought, maybe doom. Now kids are waiting for the next call of duty to feed their ADD. While this kind of game is a more mature game aimed at a more mature player, who may not have the time to play it. Blaming the lets play culture seems like an easy thing to blame, but if your targeted demographic is an age group that has increasing less time to game, then seeing that demographic move to a format that you can't monetize, should be a warning to you before you attempt to target that demographic.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoYou've got it backwards. They're not blaming the Let's Play culture for existing, and they can see the value these videos add to gaming culture, what they're pointing out is the issues with revenue it currently creates. If the monetisation issue is fixed (they suggested leaving tips) then they can continue making storytelling games, and that appears to be in the interest of Let's Play video creators as well.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYeah. Half-way through reading the post I expected the authors to start passive-aggressive legal threats, or something. Instead, they announced they removed ContentID from the music ( :o ) and only kindly ask the video uploaders to encourage people to tip them a dollar or two... This reaction makes me want to buy the game and tip them just because of their approach to the issue. EDIT: just bought. I don't have time to play it now, but I firmly believe in supporting people doing commendable things just because they do those things.
- GhotiFish 11y agoOn the one hand: I do believe that if a game is basically a movie (a cinematic game), then a let's play of it can kill interest in playing (basically just seeing) it. On the other, I have this feeling that let's plays are starting to assert themselves as a strong market force. I've already seen games specifically made to target let's players as a way to reach their fans. Let's plays may just simply be a new reality of the market. Even if you assume policy ends up entirely in favor of cinematic games, without the ability to take advantage of the "let's play pulpit" then cinematic games are going to find themselves very disadvantaged. I think we're starting to see the effects of this, games that try to sell themselves on their narrative, which simply end up taking the player through a series of corridors and cutscenes, are losing. Games that sell themselves on their gameplay and build narratives around the player are winning. Not very nice to That Dragon, Cancer. I know. Sorry guys!
- izacus 11y ago>I think we're starting to see the effects of this, games that try to sell themselves on their narrative, which simply end up taking the player through a series of corridors and cutscenes, are losing. Games that sell themselves on their gameplay and build narratives around the player are winning. And that's exactly the problem - it creates a monoculture of genres even though those "losing" genres are still popular enough to be at least watched.
- GhotiFish 11y agoI disagree, I think this space you called a monoculture is incredibly diverse, and will continue to be incredibly diverse. Cinematic games are relatively recent territory, not established aspects of the gaming market. If the only limiting factor for games is that they'd have to look entertaining to people after someone has seen them play it, then I think you could look forward to some extreme diversity.
- imron 11y agoAw man, my son loves pancakes too. Now I want to both buy this game and not buy this game... :'(
- 59nadir 11y agoI find it interesting that everyone's default mode is somehow that a developer/studio should be able to dictate what people show from their game and whether or not they can make money from it. Even though I find the idea of making money off of Let's Plays a bit silly as well, I honestly think it should be none of your business as a developer. This is all part of a bigger picture where I think the consumer of media needs to have more rights, not less. People already mostly don't own what they buy, can't do what they want with it, etc., and further limiting that is doing no one any favors, except the people in the business that don't even play games themselves.
- sp332 11y agoIf the developer can't keep people from sharing the content, they're going to have to recover their costs from the relatively few people who actually buy the game, which means stratospheric prices. The only people who would by are the streamers who can commercialize their copy of the game, and rich people who just want to play. The rest of us would be stuck.
- jamstruth 11y agoDefinitely think there should be some way of sharing the revenue with devs, especially indie devs. Take "Life Is Strange" for instance. I watched a Let's Play on it and it killed any interest I had in actually playing the game. It was a story based game without much in terms of gameplay and I realised after I'd finished watching someone play episode 1 that the story was all that would keep me interested and I'd already seen that. Narrative games don't translate well into Let's Plays format of helping game sales.
- HemanHeartYou 11y agoah, game makers and musicians mad because they realized they went into the wrong industry when they could have just made potential thousands by playing video games and stuttering poor commentary over top of it how long before they target female twitch streamers?
- timwaagh 11y agothey should just file the DMCA take down requests. instead they say 'we're too nice for that' and complain in a blog post... meh.
- roosterjm2k2 11y agoEveryone, including the author, is missing the point of lets plays... They aren't monetizing the game... the game is largely secondary... i find myself (and others i've asked today about this) tend to follow youtubers or streamers, not games. Its the personalities that earn the revenue, the game is just a talking piece...
- Rudism 11y agoHe did specifically call out Let's Plays that just run through the game with little to no commentary. Though I suspect those might have less views than ones from the more popular streamers.