5 ms·
Right...and the insane part is they aren't even censoring the primary documents - just the index! It's like not allowing a library to have index card saying "Me
by oh_sigh 11y ago
Right...and the insane part is they aren't even censoring the primary documents - just the index! It's like not allowing a library to have index card saying "Mein Kampf is located in section 23, row 8 under 'misguided ideologies'", but you do allow them to stock the book itself.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoBecause this isn't about censorship! Google results are the default answer to 'what something is' online. It's improper for someone's first result online to be fraudulent or irrelevant. So Google is the problem. Not the actual article. Furthermore, actually removing content from original websites is incredibly hard, incredibly costly, and involves a lot of legal work. Tracing down web hosts all over the planet. Controlling this at the search engine level, on the other hand, only needs to talk to a handful of companies, and a simple, common framework can ensure individuals are able to expediently request redress for these wrongs against them.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cromwellian 11y agoWhat if one day everyone runs their own indexer, or there's a distributed search engine where people index parts of the web and share it with others like FreeNet/Kazaa? What of sites like archive.org whose job it is to preserve the history of the web, in effect, a history of our culture? You're talking about in effect, erecting a Great Firewall around Europe so that EU citizens can't surface information that the rest of the world can. But anyone in Europe could use Tor, a foreign proxy, or a VPN to get around this. Ultimately, if government censorship extends too far, it may push decentralized information indexing and sharing to be more mainstream than the darknets it currently exists on.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIf you'd like to help replace Google with a decentralized, publicly-controlled alternative, I think that'd be a great thing! But that's a very large amount of mystical speculation, Ray. And by and large, if people had their own indexers, we wouldn't have a single search engine determining what people's public reputation is, so this problem would largely cease to exist. But the reality is, this has nothing to do with 'government censorship'. Google itself admits things like revenge porn should be blocked. (And in fact, it's Google itself that decides whether or not to censor RTBF sites!) Private citizens should have the right to remove personal information with no public bearing from the Internet. If you disagree, feel free to post your social security number and credit card information.
- cromwellian 11y agoYou can't remove anything from the internet, that's the point, and that's why you should be very careful about what information you put in the internet. At best you can temporarily hide it. Anyone who truly wants to dig up dirt on you, or wants to do a background check, won't rely only on Google. You say it's not about a company in particular, but the principle, but notice how you are totally ok with a non-Google index. The reality is, any distributed system would converge eventually, and end up with the same issues you have with Google today, only just like with controlling nukes in a multipolar, vs superpower world, governments would lose power to regulate speech and publishing. Thinks would get harder and more dangerous for those wishing to remove information about themselves from being found. Notice how quickly people are to go hyperbolic on the precedent of Apple unlocking a single cell phone, because hey, if the FBI can ask Apple to do it, then the Chinese government can too. But I don't see any similar concern about the possible bad precedents European censorship will set for China, Russia, et al. How can tech companies put up a fight against Chinese requests for censorship, when the European Union is given that option? Given your history Jake, of nearly daily anti-Google articles on your social feeds, should I not be skeptical that this has less to do with principle, and more to do with your desire to see Google lose a battle or two? And before you chalk this up to my employment at Google, maybe you should look at my history in trying to prevent censorship of this form, going all the way back to the 90s as one of the authors of the early anonymizing internet proxies in 1996 (https://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~daw/papers/privacy-compcon97-www/privacy-html.html https://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~daw/papers/privacy-compcon97-ww..., search for 'Decense', or https://web.archive.org/web/20011129060515/http://www.clark.net/pub/rjc/decense.html https://web.archive.org/web/20011129060515/http://www.clark....) I have always absolutely opposed censorship, of any kind, by any entity.
- gohrt 11y agoSearch engine doesn't host the articles it links to, so the analogy doesn't quite match.
- gefh 11y agoBut the spanish newspaper hosting the article in the case that lead to this law _is_ under EU regulation, so I think in this case the library is 'all websites hosted in the EU' and google is just the card index.
- effie 11y agoThe objected results are being removed from search results page only for specified queries (name of the individual...). The documents themselves stay in search index and can be found via other queries not specified in the removal request.