7 ms·
>No matter what degree of variability is chosen, alien planets are very unlikely to be much larger than the Earth. To be specific, we can say with 95% confidenc
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
>No matter what degree of variability is chosen, alien planets are very unlikely to be much larger than the Earth. To be specific, we can say with 95% confidence that another planet with intelligent life, such as our nearest neighbour, will have a circumference no more than 20% greater than that of the Earth.
Huh? I see no justification for this.
I'm firmly in the "We know nothing about aliens and won't until we get some hard data" camp.
Alien life will, by definition, be alien. We have no basis for assuming it's even going to be recognisable as life.
Life essentially seems to be a persistent self-reproducing dissipative structure that responds to evolutionary pressure. There is nothing in the manual that requires liquid water, gravity, a planetary surface, carbon, or any of the other ingredients that define life on Earth.
- fergussimpson 11y agoIf we are talking about alien life in general, I completely agree. But this calculation relates specifically to intelligent life. And from that collection we can deduce something, as explained in the website. The calculation assumes nothing about the presence of water or carbon.
- erik_landerholm 11y agoI see no justification for anything in this article. His assumption that beings like us (ability to reason about our place in the universe and even leave our own planet's gravity well) are common is dubious. There is no evidence of that at all.
- dsmithatx 11y ago> His assumption that beings like us (ability to reason about our place in the universe and even leave our own planet's gravity well) are common is dubious. There is no evidence of that at all. Yes I want to believe this but, I'm afraid there is no science behind it. Based on # of galaxies and stars it does seem logical however, what unknown variables also equate into determining this? Needless to say I stopped reading after this assumption in the first paragraph.
- aidenn0 11y agoI think the argument is this: given N beings in the universe that want to search for other such beings, if each being assumes they are the median it maximizes the chance that one being finds another. So maybe we are actually the 99th percentile in size, then it's okay that we are looking for larger beings, because the vast majority of beings that really are around the 50th percentile will be looking for larger beings.
- JoeCoder_ 11y ago> There is nothing in the manual that requires liquid water, gravity, a planetary surface, carbon, or any of the other ingredients that define life on Earth. On carbon, this is from [a recent Astrobiology textbook](http://books.google.com/books?id=x83omgI5pGQC&q=%22there%20may%20very%20well%20be%20only%20a%20single%20element%22 http://books.google.com/books?id=x83omgI5pGQC&q=%22there%20m...) which probably does count as a manual : ) "There are, after all, only a finite number of elements in the periodic table, and many of these are very poorly suited to support life for any of a fair list of reasons. Consequently, many of the 90-odd naturally occurring elements can be ruled out. So many, in fact, that in the end there may very well be only a single element--carbon, the basis of all life on earth--that is able to support the complex chemistry presumably required to create any self-replicating chemical system. The easiest way to appreciate the special, perhaps even unique, qualities of carbon is to compare it with silicon, its closest cousin. Many of the properties that suit carbon so well to its central role in Terrestrial life are shared or even exceeded by silicon. For example, silicon, like carbon, is tetravalent--that is each atom forms four bonds, allowing for the formation of a rich array of complex molecular structures. And, while silicon-silicon bond is weaker than a carbon bond, the discrepancy is only about 25%. Consistent with this, both silicon and carbon can form long molecular chains, For example, compounds of silicon and hydrogen, called silanes, with up to 28 consecutive silicon-silicon bonds have been reported in the scientific literature. Likewise, while carbon is the fourth most common element in the Solar System as a while, silicon is many orders of magnitude more common on the surface of Earth. Indeed, silicon is second only to Oxygen in terms of its abundance in the Earth's crust. Nevertheless, silicon simply cannot support the same rich chemistry as its "upstairs" neighbor in the periodic table. The problem lies in both the thermodynamics (equilibrium stabilities) of silicon's interactions with other atoms and the kinetics (rates) of these reactions... So carbon wins over silicon. But what of the 90 or so other naturally occurring elements? They fare even worse than silicon."
- aagha 11y ago> "There are, after all, only a finite number of elements in the periodic table..." That's because we've only discovered or figured out how to make a finite number of them. Is there a reason that other (alien) elements can't exist that we've never been exposed to?
- wrsh07 11y agoYou're missing the point, then. Have you heard of the German Tank Problem? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_tank_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_tank_problem You can make estimates from a sample size of one. That's literally the point of the entire article. If you want their justification, it's here: ============ A similar connection between area and population is seen among countries on Earth. Those with a larger population also tend to have a larger area. This effect is not quite as strong as you might think, due to the way countries are formed. A tiny region of land is less likely to declare its independence if only a handful of people were living in that region to begin with. The smallest countries therefore tend to have slightly higher population densities. Overall though the trend is clear, larger countries do hold significantly larger populations. Most countries are smaller than sixty thousand square kilometres, yet most individuals live in a country of over one million square kilometres. If we are to estimate the size of an ordinary alien planet - one that hosts intelligent organisms - we first need to make two decisions. The first is the connection between population size and planet size. The simplest approach is to suppose that, on average, the population density will not change with planet size. For small changes in planetary radius this ought to be a good approximation. For planets much larger than Earth one could imagine that a larger proportion of the planet’s surface - for example near the poles and the equator - tend to become uninhabitable. A more detailed study of planetary atmospheres, and the prevalence of water, is needed to give a better answer here. For now we shall stick with the simple model where the average population of a civilisation increases with the planet’s surface area.
- duaneb 11y agoThis is a fun thought-experiment, but they need to do a lot more footwork in applying our unique population characteristics to theoretically ancient civilizations in highly different contexts. For instance, who knows what the behavior of a self-regulating population is on hitting the carrying capacity of a region—we already have and use birth control, and we regulate our worldwide economy (albeit poorly, look at our use of oil). > For now we shall stick with the simple model where the average population of a civilisation increases with the planet’s surface area. This is exactly what keeps it as an amusing thought experiment a la the doomsday argument—it's an unintuitive result from treating our population growth as simple as possible and extrapolating it to a general law.
- Benjammer 11y agoAgreed that size thing doesn't really have justification anywhere, but w/r/t the second part of your comment: What about the fact that Hydrogen, Oxygen and Carbon are the basic building blocks for all types of life that we have observed so far on Earth, and they are also 3 of the 4 most prevalent elements (H, He, O, C) in the observable universe in general? Sure, people have theorized that there could be Silicon- or Germanium-based biochemistries out there that work similar to Carbon-based life, but it's probably more likely we're going to find something closer to a Carbon-based biochemistry than not, just given the distribution of elements out there, right? I think we can still talk about statistical probabilities without having actual observable data on a non-Earth life form, can't we?
- tgb 11y agoI think the author messed up a classic "Doomsday argument" [1] style estimate which wouldn't depend upon the distribution. I see no way to recover the attempt, though. (I assume that's what the author was going for, given the precision of the estimate along with the use of 95% and 20% which are almost the standard doomsday argument values: that we're 95% certain that the total number of humans ever is at most 20 times (not 20%) the number that have existed before us.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_argument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_argument
- pklausler 11y agoHere's the one piece of hard data that we have on alien life: We haven't observed any.
- Grishnakh 11y agoYes, but that doesn't prove anything. You're not going to see alien life on other planets when your technology is so primitive that you've never even send manned missions beyond your nearest moon, and you've only recently even begun to detect other planets (outside your own star system), and even there you don't have the capability of detecting planets as small as your own. If you don't bother to actually observe planets similar to your own, then of course you're not going to observe any alien life similar to your own.
- pklausler 11y agoWe do have the ability to detect signals: none found. We have also not detected any von Neumann - Bracewell probes. These are significant negative results, since any civilization slightly more advanced than ours could quickly (a few M years) seed the galaxy with vN-B probes -- and would eventually do so with probability approaching unity.
- zahmahkibo 11y agoAssuming they actually want to talk to us.
- pklausler 11y agoAssuming at least one of them might want to talk to us, yes.
- Grishnakh 11y agoThe other responder is correct. The signal detection thing is just dumb. Signals quickly fall in strength to background noise levels, so you need to broadcast a huge amount of power in a tight beam to overcome that over any significant distance. So basically, you're arguing that just because no ETs have bothered to pour a lot of resources into 1) finding us and learning of our existence, and 2) building a gigantic, power-consuming radio transmitter and directing it at us, that they must not exist. The probes thing assumes that the ETs actually want to talk to us. That's a pretty huge assumption. We've had civilizations here on Earth which had no desire for outside contact (namely the Chinese during some of their dynasties). What makes you think the ETs are so intent on pouring resources into making artificially-intelligent probes to establish communications? By that logic, WE don't exist, because we haven't bothered to do these things either.
- te0x 11y agoDid you read the article?