2 ms·
One of the decisions I made about downvotes on HN is to treat them as editorial feedback. Maybe I was unclear, maybe my facts were wrong, or maybe my comment ju
by brudgers 11y ago
One of the decisions I made about downvotes on HN is to treat them as editorial feedback. Maybe I was unclear, maybe my facts were wrong, or maybe my comment just wasn't very good. In response, I often delete or edit or rewrite my comments. The critical thing for me understanding why a comment was downvoted.
It looks to me like the comment in question was flagged. Lacking elements such as examples, rationales, analyses or an interesting story may have caused people to find it uninteresting. By being only tenuously related to the issues around laptop privacy, others may have found it low quality. It is plausible that one or more people felt that a likely result would be sparking two sides to talk past each other. The ;) does little to argue against such an interpretation.