4 ms·
> I don't understand why this community has to have a weekly cycle of bashing different programming communities. It's funny if done in good taste. You should b
by naasking 11y ago
> I don't understand why this community has to have a weekly cycle of bashing different programming communities.
It's funny if done in good taste. You should be able to take a joke with good humour, even if it's at your own expense, and this is a pretty good joke.
- faizshah 11y agoMy comment wasn't directed at the OP it was directed at the community and these weekly community bashing cycles.
- coryfklein 11y agoIf you want to actually know the "why", I don't think any one person can answer for certain but I have noticed similar trends on HN and attribute it to the culture necessary among start-ups: brutally challenging assumptions and discovering failure points. I think that kind a culture is necessary in quickly shutting down projects that have a high likelihood of failure before too much time is invested in them. Unfortunately, that culture also tends to leak into many other aspects of the community.
- BenoitP 11y ago> brutally challenging assumptions and discovering failure points Nicely phrased. I'd apply this to engineers in the general too. People can often speak of them (and me) as difficult; when this is really what is needed of people that make things happen. Especially on critical infrastructure. You can't really wing details on the integrity of the bridge you are building.
- pklausler 11y ago"Don't implement critical systems with tools that any idiot can use, because they'll show up."
- erikpukinskis 11y agoI don't think the general commentary is in good taste. To me the difference between a good faith joke and a bad faith joke is whether you actually like the people you are making fun of. I don't think that's the case here. My sense is that the people laughing actually think NPM and JavaScript suck. The tone I am getting is "haha, you are bad and I am a better programmer than your whole community". Is that not how you perceive it? Am I just imagining contempt where there is none? It's like, I can joke about you being an alcoholic if I think you're actually just a fun heavy drinker. If I think you're actually a violent alcoholic, it's not funny for me to joke about that.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- piokuc 11y agoI don't think people are making fun of other people here, we are lauhging at a particular software engineering pathology, that's all. There are important lessons in the story of left-pad library to be learned not only by JavaScript programmers, it's pretty universal, I remember someone asking about API for min and max for Java (not JavaScript) on StackOverflow.