4 ms·
I think the difference is choice. White flight is white folks choosing to move out of an area. Gentrification is white folks choosing to move in to an area.
by marcus_holmes 11y ago
I think the difference is choice.
White flight is white folks choosing to move out of an area.
Gentrification is white folks choosing to move in to an area.
No-one else gets a choice. Only the white folks.
- mafribe 11y ago> No-one else gets a choice. Everybody gets the same choices, or can you point me towards a mechanism that prevents e.g. Chinese or Indians form moving? The difference is narrative: It's currently acceptable to blame whitey. Criticising non-whites is not socially acceptable in left-wing circles. Your comment is an instance of this behaviour.
- bruceb 11y agoWealthy white folks that is. Whites are more than half the population. Not surprising of wealthy pop many would be white. Plenty of poor ones. And this is SF the gentrfiers are white and Asian
- SerLava 11y agoIs there a word for people refusing to move? Because then every possible housing decision by a white person could be framed as a terrible thing.
- marcus_holmes 11y agohehe fair point :)
- zeveb 11y ago> No-one else gets a choice. Only the white folks. That's not really fair. White flight was a result of mandatory school integration policies, which forced middle-class (i.e., by-and-large white) and lower-class (i.e., by-and-large black) children into the same schools; white folks didn't have a choice about that, nor did those who stayed a bit longer have a choice about the continued decline of their cities. Poor city folks have the same choice now that white city folks had in the 70s: stay & deal, or flee elsewhere. The sticky point is that it's a lot easier for someone middle-class to afford to move to the suburbs & commute to work than it is for a poor person.
- thaw13579 11y agoTo be clear, Brown v Board of Education school integration ended racial segregation, not economic segregation. Things are arguably different now, but back then race was a major component of the perceived "decline."
- marcus_holmes 11y agoReally? White folks were forced to move away because their kids might go to school with black kids? Only in America...
- zeveb 11y ago> White folks were forced to move away because their kids might go to school with black kids? It's really, really unfortunate that race is a proxy for class in America. It's a natural and IMHO good human tendency for folks to want to be around others of their own class; the problem is that in America race and class are so conflated that one gets this horrible self-reinforcing racist spiral, which is unfair to blacks and poisonous to whites. And race isn't even all that good of a proxy for class, but due to the aforementioned self-reinforcing racist hate spiral it has been extraordinarily difficult to eliminate.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago> It's a natural and IMHO good human tendency for folks to want to be around others of their own class; Natural, but not good. Good is when we eliminate class, not enjoy its stratification.
- mc32 11y agoIt's always a choice. We have freedom of movement, we don't have hukous, we don't assign neighborhoods to people, racist housing policies haven't been a thing for a while. People need more housing choices, cities need to build more housing at different price points, bug also without strong-arming developers. People move due to economics. Looking for better, or looking for affordability. Middle and upper class will also move away from poor whites. See what happens when school districts are consolidated and blue collar kids and middle class upper middle get sent to the same schools, the ones who can move will move. Also, it's not as if gentrification does not occur in Tokyo or Lagos or Berlin. Housing stock goes through phases of attractiveness. What we need is more housing and less useless blaming, blaming will not address any of the issues of housing shortage.