5 ms·
When middle class families move out it's called *-flight. When poor families move out, it's called gentrification. Both are due to economics, some precipitat
by mc32 11y ago
When middle class families move out it's called *-flight. When poor families move out, it's called gentrification. Both are due to economics, some precipitated, not so much by individual bigotry but rather by self interest (the former wanting to preserve value individually in anticipation of devaluation of property, the latter get pushed out due to economics whereby its not viable to remain in a valuating neighborhood while earnings remain flat for the individual.
- thaw13579 11y agoWhile I'm sure there's plenty of self interest at play, it's important to remember that there were explicitly racist legal practices as well. A specific example is the practice of racially restricted covenants, which literally prevents a home from being sold to a someone who isn't white: http://www.bostonfairhousing.org/timeline/1920s1948-Restrictive-Covenants.html http://www.bostonfairhousing.org/timeline/1920s1948-Restrict...
- fiatmoney 11y agoAnd which haven't been enforceable for ~70 years, where they existed in at all. Some stuff has happened since then.
- thaw13579 11y agoAnd after that there was the FHA: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/05/the-racist-housing-policy-that-made-your-neighborhood/371439/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/05/the-raci... Yes, "stuff" continues to happen, for better or worse, but it's hard to believe that the state of housing is independent of bigotry given the evidence.
- fiatmoney 11y agoAnd those policies ended 50 years ago! Liberals have been in charge of housing policy for literally decades.
- thaw13579 11y agoAnd yet, race is still today a factor that can be quantified wrt housing: https://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/HUD?src=/press/press_releases_media_advisories/2013/HUDNo.13-091 https://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/HUD?src=/press/press_releas...
- fiatmoney 11y agoGosh, it's almost like there are worse outcomes regardless of housing policy.
- danharaj 11y ago1. Economics is not morally neutral, it's not a force of nature that blows through a town like a snowstorm. Economics is deliberate human activity. Economic justice and injustice is a coherent concept. 2. White flight and the creation of urban slums was a deliberate policy on the part of the government and its various partner institutions. Redlining by banks, whites only suburbs, highways built through poor and black neighborhoods, tearing up businesses and uprooting families, policing policies that targeted undesirables, etc. I find it hard to believe anyone can examine the evidence and come up with such an apolitical explanation as "self-interest".
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>When middle class families move out it's called *-flight. When poor families move out, it's called gentrification. There's a vast economic difference between a family moving further upscale and further downscale.
- marcus_holmes 11y agoI think the difference is choice. White flight is white folks choosing to move out of an area. Gentrification is white folks choosing to move in to an area. No-one else gets a choice. Only the white folks.
- mafribe 11y ago> No-one else gets a choice. Everybody gets the same choices, or can you point me towards a mechanism that prevents e.g. Chinese or Indians form moving? The difference is narrative: It's currently acceptable to blame whitey. Criticising non-whites is not socially acceptable in left-wing circles. Your comment is an instance of this behaviour.
- bruceb 11y agoWealthy white folks that is. Whites are more than half the population. Not surprising of wealthy pop many would be white. Plenty of poor ones. And this is SF the gentrfiers are white and Asian
- SerLava 11y agoIs there a word for people refusing to move? Because then every possible housing decision by a white person could be framed as a terrible thing.
- marcus_holmes 11y agohehe fair point :)
- zeveb 11y ago> No-one else gets a choice. Only the white folks. That's not really fair. White flight was a result of mandatory school integration policies, which forced middle-class (i.e., by-and-large white) and lower-class (i.e., by-and-large black) children into the same schools; white folks didn't have a choice about that, nor did those who stayed a bit longer have a choice about the continued decline of their cities. Poor city folks have the same choice now that white city folks had in the 70s: stay & deal, or flee elsewhere. The sticky point is that it's a lot easier for someone middle-class to afford to move to the suburbs & commute to work than it is for a poor person.