16 ms·
What Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with Its Robots
- ikeboy 11y agoTitle is borked. Should have a what in the beginning.
- basicallydan 11y agoProbably yes, but consider this interpretation: > Seventeen prominent roboticists think: "Google should do with its robots." Doesn't matter what. They should just do.
- progressive_dad 11y agomake do do something do great things do nothing do experiments do a dance fondue Can you make fondue with gravy? Yeah, I bet that would be tasty.
- kaybe 11y agoThat would mean that Google is able to fulfill a task with the robots, no? As a figure of speech, 'this should do' means that something is sufficient. Any first-language speakers?
- basicallydan 11y agoMakes sense to me! Q: "Which company is sufficient with its robots?" A: "Google should do. [with its robots]"
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoTitle is killing me.
- jkjjjjj 11y agomy left nut
- csours 11y agoI also love the reddit tracker in the URL: http://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/robotics-hardware/.VvMLpmu3Gb4.reddit
- ikeboy 11y agoIt's not a reddit tracker, it doesn't get sent anywhere. It's added when you have the reddit companion extension installed, to tell it to show a toolbar. mrfusion must have the extension and clicked on it from https://www.reddit.com/r/robotics/comments/4bolus/what_17_prominent_roboticists_think_google_should/ https://www.reddit.com/r/robotics/comments/4bolus/what_17_pr..., the only submission at the time of the submission here.
- dang 11y agoIt seemed fine by the time I saw it, but we took out the magic 17. The weirdest and most surprising of the tricks PG came up with for improving titles: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- resoluteteeth 11y ago> 17 Prominent Roboticists Think Google Should Do with Its Robots Apparently this includes having robots write titles for HN posts?
- monk_e_boy 11y ago> For autonomous deliveries, it's the last 10 meters that is the hard part. Couldn't someone build a delivery box (like an american mail box) that could be mounted on your property, close to the curb, within reachable distance from a delivery truck. The truck could stop, tell the 'amazon delivery box' to unlock and open. Then place items in it. There could be various different sized boxes, from small to large chest freezer type things. The box would have some electronics in it, a solar panel on top, it doesn't matter how expensive they are - you can rent them from Amazon or whoever. This would then reduce all the complex variables of how to drop packages off at the destination.
- saulrh 11y agoThis would be ridiculously useful for apartments, if you can find the space for it curbside. Large packages right now are delivered in one of two ways: 1) They leave it at the door. Risk of theft. 2) They leave it with the rent office, which is only open 9-5. Regular job? You have to either wait until Saturday, or you're screwed if your rent office isn't open Saturday. I've thought in the past about trying to design a door door with a mail flap equivalent that works for really large packages, or something you could build into the wall next to a door to replace a coat closet that'd serve the same purpose. Moving it out to the curb and making it automation-capable sounds like an excellent proposal for this purpose.
- allannienhuis 11y agoYou wouldn't even need one container per apartment/resident - just a reasonable number of various sized compartments. A keypad/pinpad or touch screen login would open the appropriate container for the customer. This is how Canada post handles parcel deliveries with their 'super mailboxes' (without the keypad part as they do have a small box for each unit where a key is dropped). [edit] Authentication could be handled in a lot of different ways: QR code, RFID or other card/dongle/phone/internet based ways.
- kaybe 11y agoLike this you mean? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Packstation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Packstation We have those in Germany, it's quite common. Opening is done with a card and code or barcode. The article mentions countries with similar systems: Austria, Finnland, Estonia, Latvia, Poland, Canada, Australia and United Arab Emirates. edit: And not mentioned in the text but there is an image from Denmark.
- bliti 11y agoI think Google should continue with its self-driving effort. They have their maps and fiber technology that provide some hard-to-get pieces of the puzzle. This is the robot that will impact humanity the most. An automated box on wheels (seats optional). Just think of the things a self driving car could do for you: - Pick up anything from mostly anywhere. - Schedule pickup around the clock. - Move things/people securely and be able to track the contents through a camera. - Act as a mobile living space. Not requiring a dashboard frees up a lot of space.
- reacweb 11y agoGoogle is doing research in AI to reach the singularity. I think robotic is very important for Google, but reassuring people is more important. Google does not want to be associated with something frightening like "terminator".
- Isamu 11y agoWhat, nobody wants tap-dancing? Vaudeville anyone? Geez, that was the FIRST thing Walt Disney went for. Look up "Project Little Man" with Buddy Ebsen as the model. http://www.waltdisney.org/blog/early-days-audio-animatronics%C2%A9 http://www.waltdisney.org/blog/early-days-audio-animatronics...
- sounds 11y agoI think Robin Murphy, Texas A&M Professor, has the right suggestion for Google. No idea if Google will actually do it. > If I were a large company with deep pockets, I would accept that robotics is what is called a ‘formative’ market and just like shopping on the web, it will take a decade or so to ramp up. Robots are innovations that do not directly replace people and thus it is hard for people to imagine how to use them—thus the market is formative. The theory of diffusion of innovation indicates that potential end-users, not developers, need to experiment with applications to see what works (and not just physically but human-robot interaction as well). > However, robots have to be extremely reliable and the software customizable enough to allow the end-users to tinker and adapt the robots, so that the end-user can find the ‘killer app.’ Essentially, you can crowdsource the task of finding the best, most profitable uses of robots, but only if you have good enough robots that can be reconfigure easily and the software is open enough. I would concentrate on creating generic ground, aerial, and marine robots with customizable software and user interfaces in order to enable their regular employees (and customers) to figure out the best uses. > In order to make sure the development was pushing towards the most reliable, reconfigurable, and open robots possible, I suggest the developers focus on the emergency response domain. Disasters are the most demanding application and come in so many variations that it is a constant test of technology and users. Imagine the wealth of ideas and feedback from fire rescue teams, the Coast Guard, and the American Red Cross, just to name a few! Focusing on emergency management would also have a positive societal benefit.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIsn't this an example of a Scientist speaking outside their area of expertise? Not substantially different from a Physicist speaking on Literature or History. Personally, I don't see a mission-critical application for robotics any time in the immediate future. Low-risk deployments will yield data, not rescue teams. Firemen have no time to fool with experimental gadgets.
- robotresearcher 11y agoRobin Murphy has been doing reacue robots her whole career. Her team had robots at the WTC site. Very few people know more about this area than her. It's appropriate to be skeptical of course, but don't dismiss the expertise of someone before looking them up.
- simonh 11y agoHardly any of the problems they suggest robots can solve are problems Google faces though. Last 10 metres delivery, supply chain control and management, disaster relief work, oil and gas, home assistants - particularly for seniors. There are too many comments in there to address all of them but here's a few: "If anyone could crack the indoor social robot market that is seeing such high interest right now in both the consumer and commercial spaces, it would be them" Why on earth would Google care about the indoor social robot market? "If I were a large company with deep pockets, ... it will take a decade or so to ramp up" It's always easy to say how other people should spend their money, and just because a company is one of the few that can do a thing, it doesn't follow that they should do it. A lot of the speculation seems to be of the "if I had a billion dollars, I would..." wish fulfilment sort. I can see the point of self driving cars. They were doing street view anyway and that's a pretty obvious application for autonomous vehicles. But they're not actually a manufacturing or supply chain company. Their foray into that with Motorola was an expensive mistake. I just don't see that a lot of the other robotics stuff they're doing is relevant to their business. That doesn't mean nobody should be investing in this. Sure there are applications down the line, but are they relevant to Google? The only one I can think of is data centre build out and maintenance. But Google aren't near the scale to support an entire industrial robot development and manufacturing industry just for a handful of data centres.
- IanCal 11y agoHaving said that, are they profitable problems to solve? It doesn't really matter if they're things vital for google now, but if they're profitable and google are well placed to profit from them then it makes sense to do surely. > Why on earth would Google care about the indoor social robot market? Why on earth would google care about the home heating market?
- linkregister 11y agoI don't think the acquisition of Motorola was for anything other than the patent portfolio. In https://www.google.com/press/motorola/ https://www.google.com/press/motorola/ , Google mentions Motorola Mobility (the mobile phone arm of Motorola), but I believe this is overshadowed by the overt statement about patents immediately afterward.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Animats 11y agoFrom the article: "What are those guys up to?" The answer seems to be "not very much". Google bought all those robotics companies but didn't get them to work together. All the companies are still in their original locations. Nobody has a product. Even Bot and Dolly, which had a product, no longer seems to be selling it. Boston Dynamics is being sold because they don't play well with others. The whole robotics exercise seems to have been a hobby of Andy Rubin, and when he left, nobody had a clue what to do. Google/Alphabet, through mismanagement, may have added negative value to the robotics industry. Google's secrecy here seems to be more about hiding management failure than protecting intellectual property. Martin Buehler, the brains behind BigDog, is now at Disney, and I expect we'll see more mobile robots there. Disney has wanted this for years; around 2000, they hired Danny Hillis to work on theme park robots. They got some improvements to their anamatronics, and a dino robot that pulls a cart but gets its balance from the cart wheels. The next killer app in robotics is probably really good bin-picking. Kiva's mobile platforms can bring the shelf to the picker, but a human still takes the thing out of one bin and puts it into another. Amazon is working on solutions to that.
- Animats 11y agoAfter reading "Google parent Alphabet ushers in 'fiscal discipline era'"[1], it's likely that Google/Alphabet will effectively be out of robotics shortly, after trashing most of the R&D startups in the field. Nobody they acquired is 2 years from making big bucks. Workers will be, as previously threatened, reallocated to other parts of the business. Probably related to ads; that's still 94% of revenue. This is discouraging. It's the acquire-trash-dump thing Paul Allen was notorious for. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11357131 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11357131