4 ms·
A university is a safe space from physical violence. And why would I be ok with someone advocating that I or my family be deported? Because that's what just hap
by sp332 11y ago
A university is a safe space from physical violence. And why would I be ok with someone advocating that I or my family be deported? Because that's what just happened to these students.
- bsaul 11y agoi don't want to diminish the anxiety that those kind of situations can produce, but talking about voting for physically violent measures still is different from actually doing them.
- sp332 11y agoI disagree. Promoting violence is violent. Especially if you write it all over a college campus where the targets of the violence are living. Edit: that's why "aiding and abetting" or "conspiracy to" commit crimes is also a crime.
- xupybd 11y agoAt this point it's only speculation that this is promoting violence. While people may be feeling a lot of fear, that response might not be entirely rational.
- sp332 11y agoHow many violent people have to loudly proclaim their support for Trump before the fear becomes "rational"?
- imron 11y agoSince when is guilt by association a concept worth supporting?
- sp332 11y ago[Edit: removed paragraph] Whoever did this is personally threatening students on campus. If they were just supporting Trump I would have a lot less problem with this.
- imron 11y ago> and that's why Trump is wrong to say that Mexican immigrants are criminals who should all be deported Which is not what Trump said by the way. As I mentioned in another post I don't support Trump (and neither am I even able to vote in US elections) and I have no horse in this race, but if you're going to criticise him, at least do it for things he said, not for exaggerations of what you think he said. > Whoever did this is personally threatening students on campus No, what happened was entirely impersonal, and not threatening in any way unless you perform a large amount of mental and linguistic gymnastics.
- sp332 11y agoOk, I removed that part. But I have no idea what you mean by "impersonal" when the action is clearly aimed at the Latino students.
- imron 11y agoIt is impersonal because it wasn't someone coming and speaking to you personally, nor was it a message that specifically mentioned you. It was just a generic message chalked by some unknown 3rd party, and not specifically directed at anyone. I fail to see how chalking 'trump 2016' is 'clearly aimed at Latino students'? Latinos are not the only group he has marginalised, but even then maybe it was written by someone who supports some other policies of his or by someone who wants to see some fresh names in politics beyond just Clinton/Bush. From what I can tell many of Trump's supporters don't like all his policies either. What they like is that he is unlike any other politician running for office and that he has enough of his own money that his words aren't bought and paid for by others. In debating you learn you cannot make a convincing argument without thoroughly understanding your opponents arguments and lines of reasoning. If you think the only reason people want to vote for Trump is because they are rascist and intend for violence to be committed against certain groups in society, then you will fail to convince most of them not to vote for Trump, because that is not what they want or believe.
- pigpaws 11y ago@imron - you mean like this guy? the infamous black panther at the voting polls? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Black_Panther_Party_voter_intimidation_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Black_Panther_Party_voter_... but, like you probably said (in your head), he wasn't convicted, so he must have been innocent... not quite the way others saw it though...
- imron 11y ago> Promoting violence is violent Chalking 'Trump 2016' is a decidedly non-violent action. You might find it offensive, distasteful, disrespectful, or any number of other adjectives, but it is not in any way violent. I say this as someone who does not support Donald Trump or his policies.
- elthran 11y agoUnder the law, /everywhere/ is a safe space from physical violence - universities are not special in this regard. And the law only stays that way as long as the people in power decide to maintain it as such. I'm also not saying you have to be OK with the message - just that rather than trying to shut down the people making statements, they should be engaged and challenged.
- sp332 11y ago"Engaged and challenged" doesn't mean letting them cover the campus in graffiti.
- tclmeelmo 11y agoChalk markings are not uncommon on the Emory campus, and I think it's a little severe to call them graffiti. For example, https://mobile.twitter.com/michaelgraves91/status/541046363161890816 https://mobile.twitter.com/michaelgraves91/status/5410463631...
- merpnderp 11y agoFirst off, the first amendment is clear on this issue and FIRE has a 100% success rate (donate today if you can) in overturning school bans on speech. And perhaps you should allow that speech the same way I wouldn't be okay with Hillaray 2016 who spearheaded the effort to create the situation in Syria (along with Lybia Egypt and Iraq) which has caused the deaths of over 500k people and tens of millions of homeless. If one of the presidential contenders doesn't make you safe, I would think Hillary would be first to mind with bloody deadly wars in the wake of her only tenure in real power.
- sp332 11y agoHarassment and threats aren't covered. I think you're right about Hillary, but what does that have to do with this conversation?
- merpnderp 11y agoWriting "Trump 2016" on the ground during an election year is only a threat or harassment in the case of a few people's (poorly thought out) opinion. It isn't a threat in the eyes of the law or the first amendment, even if it weren't an election year. And people who push for this type of patriarchal protection from ideas that scare them should be careful that this doesn't become the norm, for their own opinions are surely as "threatening" to others.
- greenyoda 11y ago"the first amendment is clear on this issue" Since the First Amendment only restricts the actions of the federal (and by extension the state and local) government, it only applies to universities run by the government (e.g., state universities). Private universities like Emory are not bound by the First Amendment any more than a shopping mall is. However, there are other ways to pressure universities to allow freedom of speech: exposing their actions in the press, alumni cutting off financial support, etc.
- mkohlmyr 11y agoYou don't have to like it. You do have to accept that some people have an opinion you don't like and that they have a right to express it. And where on earth did you get "physical violence" from?
- sp332 11y agoPartly Trump http://mashable.com/2016/03/12/trump-rally-incite-violence/ http://mashable.com/2016/03/12/trump-rally-incite-violence/ But his supporters are the ones beating and kicking people. Most recently https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/03/14/trump-trump-trump-yells-attacker-as-he-beats-hispanic-man-muslim-student/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/03/1... Edit: forgot his campaign manager http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/breitbart-s-michelle-fields-ben-shapiro-resign-over-trump-incident-n537711 http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/breitbart-s-michelle-fie...
- mkohlmyr 11y agoAnd Al Sharpton gatherings have resulted in killings.. Just because someone agrees with you or associates themselves with you does not mean you have to be held accountable for their actions. It is my understanding the breitbart woman was proven to be lying about what actually happened by multiple videos showing the "incident". I hadn't even heard about it before today but even a cursory google gave me this (admittedly poorly done) video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6NoMPxomjiw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6NoMPxomjiw so maybe you shouldn't spread that.
- sp332 11y agoThis isn't about blaming Trump for the graffiti. This is about other people using Trump's campaign to harass and threaten Latino students. She said she almost fell but kept her balance. http://www.breitbart.com/big-journalism/2016/03/10/3276486/ http://www.breitbart.com/big-journalism/2016/03/10/3276486/
- dbattaglia 11y agoIf young people can't handle seeing "Vote {other party or candidate}" during election season, regardless of their beliefs, they are in for a lifetime of suffering.
- sp332 11y agoThis wasn't part of a campaign. And the vote was over already so it wasn't trying to get out the vote for Trump either.
- dbattaglia 11y agoSomeone advocating to vote for a candidate doesn't have to be part of a specific campaign. It's a common thing seen and heard everywhere during elections.
- xlm1717 11y agoThere's another vote in November.
- Omniusaspirer 11y agoI don't think graffiti qualifies as "physical violence". If you or your family is here illegally then you do so with the understanding that you might be deported. There's certainly good arguments to be made that our immigration policies need to be changed, but "beef up border security and deport current illegals" is absolutely a valid proposal and one that's supported by a large number of both American and Mexican nationals (who are hardly fond of Nicaraguan immigrants). It may not be the view I personally hold but adding ridiculous hyperbole and unbridled emotion into your stance makes it hard to take seriously.
- sp332 11y agoYou're not going to have a productive conversation about immigration if you pretend emotion doesn't exist.
- Omniusaspirer 11y agoEmotions are high on both sides, and are quantifiable for neither. Policy should be driven by metrics, not exaggerated emotional appeals.
- sp332 11y agoDeciding whether policy should encourage or discourage immigration is 98% value judgement. "Metrics" might be able to measure what you care about, but you have to decide what to care about first.
- ap3 11y agoIt's the federal government that deports people, following the immigration laws of the US. Are you saying you don't feel safe walking around the US knowing that ICE or CBP deport people?