3 ms·
Which was actually the thing that employees cut even before I entered the workforce. I distinctly remember that my dad was on the declining wave of such benefi
by mjevans 11y ago
Which was actually the thing that employees cut even before I entered the workforce. I distinctly remember that my dad was on the declining wave of such benefits being cut from the company he was working for.
It seems like for the programs that were pre-funded over the years those retirement funds either got lost in stock market declines or were otherwise raided for various non-retirement reasons (usually by the company or through cutting benefits and freeing that stored resource); in other cases I can easily see it having been 'funded' the same way 'Social Security' was 'funded' (assume eternal expansion, pay for today's retired with today's income).
I think the appeal of Basic Income Guarantee ideas is not just how effective experiments show them to be, but that it replaces 'retirement' and all sorts of other social safety nets with one solution that's a lot more streamlined. It turns all of the other fraud problems in to tax enforcement and tracking, which thanks to credit cards, the average consumer already gladly agrees to.
- Spooky23 11y agoBasic income is like the Ron Paul of HN. Pensions are too unsustainable, but we're gong to magically pay a wage to everyone. Good luck with that.
- maxxxxx 11y ago10 bonus points for "Ron Paul of HN"!!! That's funny.
- mjevans 11y agoThe problem of the pension is that it has proven unreliable to allow private institutions which can go defunct, dissolve, or otherwise discharge that liability to have it. The next fad was (is) forcing employees to 'invest' in their own retirement; except that it turns out even experts aren't that great at investing, let alone the average worker who's job REALLY isn't investing. The obvious thing is actual socialism in limited areas of society. BIG is a way of making the resources provided by taxation compete instead of being lost to bureaucracy. In this case the 'limit' is set at having more than what a normal person is expected to have. It presumes that we have reached a level of technology where energy and machines are able to provide more than the standard of living desired by the population using a given set of resources. Obviously if that assumption is invalid then nothing could 'solve' that problem aside from modifying the population or the resources. Unfortunately there are only two 'tools' that we've yet invented for resolving that problem; birth control and war.
- Spooky23 11y agoPensions are clearly superior to self-investment. You need to address the employer stealing the funds or not making contributions as required. That's where a government solution would add value -- have a state-administered pension fund with strong controls. States like New York with string funding requirements have sustainable public employee pension systems. No reason that something similar could be done for the rest of society.