5 ms·
"Apple has long suspected that servers it ordered from the traditional supply chain were intercepted during shipping, with additional chips and firmware added t
by samstave 11y ago
"Apple has long suspected that servers it ordered from the traditional supply chain were intercepted during shipping, with additional chips and firmware added to them by unknown third parties in order to make them vulnerable to infiltration"
Wow, so this is very interesting given, pretty much, everything that has been going on.
Will apple actually be the bastion of freedom (both in market and privacy) that the US supposedly stands for??
Google makes its own machines, as does facebook (actually more interested in FB's fiber switches/routers, but thats beside the point)....
But Apple has made "servers" for years... I guess they didnt consume them in their own DCs?? So I basically take it that they are effectively joining their take on Open Compute (mobos that can be mounted in controlled environments, where controlled now also means they can ID if anything was modded/changed in shipping?)
EDIT: I would really like to know how long "long" is from "apple long suspected"....
I was informed of NSA back-doors in Cisco gear in 1997 - WTF is Cisco's stance on any of this -- I haven't heard anything from them at all (or I missed anything they said)
- seanp2k2 11y agoXserves were replaced a few years ago. The current "replacement" is the Mac Pro. I highly doubt that all of iCloud runs on racks filled with the little cylinders. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xserve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xserve http://readwrite.com/2014/08/26/apple-icloud-amazon-web-services-hosting/ http://readwrite.com/2014/08/26/apple-icloud-amazon-web-serv...
- protomyth 11y agoIf they were really paranoid they could build a new Xserve powered by an offshoot of their A series ARM chips. To help defray costs, they could actually sell the thing.
- npunt 11y agoThat'd be an awesome extension of the resources they invested, but it runs the risk of designs serving too many masters (like the F35 Joint Strike Fighter trying to add VTOL, making the non-VTOL thing way too heavy), and the A-series probably doesn't have enough cores for the unit price to work well for these services. What Intel is doing with Xeon Phi and the 18-core Xeons is the way things are going I think.
- protomyth 11y agoI think they could handle a separate line of chips. Plus, a lot of folks are going the ARM route in server-land.
- ryao 11y agoIf their A-series chips have protected internal data paths and ECC, they could build microservers around them. The A9 already has PCI-E lanes that could be used for networking and storage.
- rdancer 11y agoIf for every F35 they made three of each, with different capabilities, and ceremonially dumped the two without the desired capabilities out in the ocean, it would still be cheaper overall. Which is hopefully what Apple would do. It's not like they lack talent or organizational ability to employ a few more chip designers. Or a few dozen.
- acdha 11y agoThe A9 does have respectable performance and great thermal characteristics. Rather than compete head to head with Intel, who are very very good a general purpose CPUs, it'd be interesting to see a cloud-optimized “server” which is actually a 1U cluster of storage processors – tweaked A9, as much flash as they can fit, etc. – so you'd have capacity to do things like encrypt everything at rest and in transit and apply distributed database techniques to everything because you'd have a relatively huge amount of processing capacity very close to each block of storage and they control the entire software stack. Basically like what Oracle does with Exadata without fitting a yacht into the purchase price.
- ipsum2 11y agoMaybe not Apple data centers, but it is possible to have a data center of Mac pros: http://photos.imgix.com/racking-mac-pros http://photos.imgix.com/racking-mac-pros
- jonathankoren 11y agoSounds like NSA's Tailored Access Operations[0], and other equivalent agencies. When you're a big enough target, state actors bring the full force of the state's espionage tools to bear. [0] http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/how-the-nsas-secret-elite-hacking-unit-works/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/how-the-nsas-secre...
- samstave 11y agoExactly! How many machines have you purchased in your career? I've purchased THOUSANDS - which of these have been intercepted and compromised? I have no clue.
- Spooky23 11y agoI don't know about spy agency compromise, but I have definately caught suppliers "accidentally" sticking counterfeit memory into devices.
- avn2109 11y ago>> "...which of these have been...compromised...? ~All of them, though likely without bothering to intercept your specific hardware, since you were relatively unimportant. Instead, the breaches were built into commodity hardware far upstream of you, for fully general attacks.
- iam-TJ 11y agoIt occurs to me if the company is that big, or that big of a target, it can manage to collect its servers directly from the manufacturer/supplier rather than rely on a third unrelated party for transportation.
- joering2 11y agoSo what? How do you know Dell/HP/Whoever has not been forced by NSL letters to implement backdoors.
- 11y ago
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoIntercepted during shipping? How long would an operation like that take? And can't a company with Apple's clout ask the supplier for a spec sheet that lists all the chips and a diagram showing the location of said chips?
- samstave 11y agoOf course they can, which is why perhaps apple "long suspected"... maybe shipping times were fucked and apple noticed - but my question is WHEN did apple notice???
- jkestner 11y agoYou sound incredulous. It's a thing. http://www.pcworld.com/article/2083300/report-nsa-intercepts-computer-deliveries-to-plant-spyware.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/2083300/report-nsa-intercepts...
- ryao 11y agoThe Intel chipsets even have an embedded device with complete access to everything, its own firmware and its own integrated flash where malware can be flashed by anyone with Intel's internal documentation and the private RSA key corresponding to the public key that is etched into the hardware: https://libreboot.org/faq/#intelme https://libreboot.org/faq/#intelme
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoA bit. So are they going to run these in another country? Because Congress is pretty idiotic when it comes to technology and they can pass laws to force Apple (and others) to allow snooping.
- mc32 11y agoThis doesn't make much sense. Even if apple made their own, unless they will be shipping with their own fleet of delivery trucks with armed guards not on the take, how would this differ from shipping dell machines, or if they do go this route, why not use their own guarded shipping for Dells and netapp stuff? Not only that, but they can confirm the firmware after receiving the equipment, unless they suspect the CPUs machine code, but then who will they get their CPUs from? And besides, it's not like they'll be tearing out all the netapp, dells and Cisco --everyone even amazon have them all, from what I hear.
- randall 11y agoIt's a lot easier to diff if you invented the originals.
- mtgx 11y agoThey could do stuff like this for their own servers: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/designshift/orwl-the-first-open-source-hardened-computer https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/designshift/orwl-the-fi... But they may want to build their own chips, too, because they probably shouldn't trust Intel (they do some of that already, but they may need more powerful chips for their datacenters).
- sna1l 11y agoI have a buddy who was super high up in a telecom back in the late 90s/early 00s and he mentioned that all the big telecoms basically voluntarily were creating traffic backdoors for the government. When he mentioned it, he didn't even blink. It was eerie.
- samstave 11y agoEchelon. It is real. It has been around forever.