4 ms·
Are there any open source companies that make even 1B a year? The reason I ask is because anyone with a model of "open source our core product" makes me concer
by jedberg 11y ago
Are there any open source companies that make even 1B a year? The reason I ask is because anyone with a model of "open source our core product" makes me concerned for their survival. It seems like a tough business model and Redhat is the only (moderate) success I can think of.
When your biggest competitor is yourself at a $0 price point, how do you compete?
- vacri 11y agoYou sell services rather than products. Businesses outsource all the time, and why not outsource custom work to the same people who make the product you're using? You're not going to be in the $1B space selling services, but neither are you at risk of extinction.
- davidw 11y agoThe problem with this is: billable hours are what make you money, not working in the product. Juggling those becomes very difficult. I've been following this space for years, and there are no easy answers. I think the model where the 'secret sauce' is proprietary, and you give away the infrastructure, like, say, Ruby on Rails, seems to work ok. Produces some good open source software and is still an 'easy'/straightforward business model, because you're selling a product.
- icebraining 11y agoThe problem with this is: billable hours are what make you money, not working in the product. The two are not incompatible. Most of our new features are paid for by our clients, some of which we then include into our main product. Maintenance comes from other sources of revenue, though - hosting, for example, since many companies would rather not deal with that, even if they could.
- oostevo 11y ago> You're not going to be in the $1B space selling services There are lots and lots of companies in the government and huge enterprise services space that have more than a billion in revenue. A few off the top of my head: * https://newsroom.accenture.com/fact-sheet/ https://newsroom.accenture.com/fact-sheet/ * http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/ctsh/revenue-eps http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/ctsh/revenue-eps * http://www.csc.com/about_us/ds/29505-company_profile http://www.csc.com/about_us/ds/29505-company_profile
- vacri 11y ago"selling [open source] services [for your own product]", in the context of the thread.
- gozur88 11y agoThe last time I worked at a software company they were trying to plump up the license $/services $ metric, because while it's easier to book services contracts they also increase your costs. Software companies only make runaway profits when they sell the same thing to a bunch of different customers. That said, it's not like you can't make money selling services.
- coldtea 11y ago>You sell services rather than products. Well, IBM and Oracle sell services on Open Source products and even Microsoft does nowadays... And they could sell services for my open source product too, if they fancied it. So how that makes me much safe?
- mikekchar 11y agoI've linked this so often it hurts: http://www.oreilly.com/openbook/opensources/book/tiemans.html http://www.oreilly.com/openbook/opensources/book/tiemans.htm... I'll try to keep it short this time :-). Michael Tiemmann was one of the founders of Cygnus software, which was started on $6K and was sold to Red Hat for $600M. Tiemmann went on to become CTO of Red Hat and is currently (I think) VP of Open Source Affairs. The key quotes from this link. When looking at the GNU Manifesto, "Suffice it to say that on the surface, it read like a socialist polemic, but I saw something different. I saw a business plan in disguise." Later he goes on to say: "I would explain how freedom to share would lead to greater innovation at lower cost, greater economies of scale through more open standards, etc., and people would universally respond 'It's a great idea, but it will never work, because nobody is going to pay money for free software.' After two years of polishing my rhetoric, refining my arguments, and delivering my messages to people who paid for me to fly all over the world, I never got farther than 'It's a great idea, but . . .,' when I had my second insight: if everybody thinks it's a great idea, it probably is, and if nobody thinks it will work, I'll have no competition!" IMHO opinion, Red Hat's best idea was acquiring Cygnus and buying into Tiemmann's ideas. The result is what you see now. The thing that fascinates me is that Tiemmann still has no competition because nobody thinks it will work.
- jedberg 11y agoHaving worked for a company that followed his model (Sendmail) I still say it doesn't work. I think Cygnus was a fluke. Also, assuming it was sold for 10x revenue, which is pretty standard, that means the revenue was only $60M a year. That's tiny for an enterprise software company.
- mikekchar 11y agoActually, IIRC revenue was $130M per quarter. In fact, after Cygnus was acquired the division it became drove revenue in Red Hat for a long time. It's been a very long time since I looked at it, but the records are public so if you are interested you could find out. I'm curious about Sendmail. What was the business model? Cygnus's business model was essentially custom development. They did have a proprietary product for a short time, but as one of the terms of sale of the company they ditched it. Just looking at sendmail now, it appears they were trying to make money dual licensing. I agree that this will never work.
- slgeorge 11y agoThe OSS trade-off is market penetration vs revenue from a business perspective. It's successful if the free marketing and adoption is worth the loss of revenue. Both RedHat and SUSE's competition in the 90's were proprietary Unix (e.g. SunOS etc) options. Linux commodified "low-end Unix-like OS" in conjunction with Intel processors. As a thought experiment, imagine them trying to compete against the big UNIX hardware vendors as a pure OS vendor: it would have been impossible, and there are some parallels in the outcomes for BeOS and NeXT. Both RH/SUSE were able to widely penetrate through "cheap distribution", getting their product into the hands of users who then preferred to use Linux - plus it was cheaper. Strictly speaking Open Source is not failed business model because it simply isn't a business model at all. It's a model for licensing software, not how to make money. But, I know what you mean, it does add another level of complexity. However, there are ways to run a model that has many of the advantages while also keeping value in the commercial aspects. For RH/SUSE they have two versions - the free stuff, and their certified distribution. The basic version of that is that their paying customers are primarily slow-moving corporates and the military. While people say they sell "support", a key part of the package is hardware and software certification - they're selling compatibility and stability and certainty. If you're in IT in a Fortune 100 and you want to run SAP, even if your tech team could run Fedora, SAP isn't certified on it, and if things do go wrong do you want to be in that conversation?