2 ms·
Oh, now I understand! You meant to say that if we ignore everything about the plaintiff, the actions the plaintiff has taken in and out of court, what we know a
by jessaustin 11y ago
Oh, now I understand! You meant to say that if we ignore everything about the plaintiff, the actions the plaintiff has taken in and out of court, what we know about the patent, and what we know about the products that were actually being sold, we should be able to consider the case in tabula rasa fashion, and give the patent the benefit of the doubt. I guess I was confused because this was in response to something about odious franchising...
Except, any particular patent won't get the benefit of the doubt from a jury of software people. We've seen the harm patents have done in our industry, and we're sensitive to the harms they've done in other industries and in society as a whole. There probably are some plaintiffs that would inspire some sympathy from us despite that, but this certainly isn't such a plaintiff.