3 ms·
Megan McArdle: Did the Stimulus Save Us?
- ivankirigin 17y agoThe discussion also usually doesn't focus on the fact that the costs of the stimulus haven't been felt yet. It could just be higher taxes and higher interest rates. But it could also be that treasury bills are no longer purchased by foreign governments, and the shell game where the government essentially buys its own bonds will be harder to hide. That is much more serious problem than a crippled mortgage market. I'm looking forward to politicians justifying debasing the currency for "national security".
- forinti 17y agoI just hope that the devaluation of the dollar doesn't coincide with the election of the first latino president. It would be funny as hell, but utterly unfair.
- ivankirigin 17y agohuh? Is that a joke about the predisposition for strong men in latin america, who often have devalued currencies? Many, many countries have experienced extreme inflation. Even the US in the 70s and early 80s was pretty extreme. http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-inflation-rates/ http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-in...
- btilly 17y agoThe joke had nothing to do with strong men. Everything to do with how devalued currencies in Latin America tend to be, and how many people in the USA are afraid that the growing Mexican presence will bring us poverty.
- chubbard 17y agoSo if she's in favor of the stimulus, but then points out that it didn't do anything. Why did she say she was in favor of it? If the only thing it causes is higher inflation or taxes?
- sophacles 17y agoThere is something not discussed here, that I rarely see come up anywhere. Many of the places where stimulus money is available kept workers, started new projects, and even hired workers on the assumption that they would get stimulus money, or on the promise of that money. The power industry is spending lots of money, and keeping lots of workers on, based on money that is not actually spent by the government yet. The power of the stimulus goes far beyond the number of dollars currently spent. For example see the large outlays lots of companies have put down on "Smart Grid" stuff.
- anamax 17y agoHow about quantifying this? How much did each of these jobs cost? Do you really think that the borrowed money wouldn't have created any jobs? For example, we have stimulus-paid weatherization projects costing over $50k/house. That's economically stupid. We'd have been better off just throwing money out the window of passing cars.
- sophacles 17y agoI am not an economist, nor am I an exec or anything so it is all observations but: 1. When we talk about joint academic/industry projects we talk about numbers of dollars on the order of 1M and 10M not 10K and 100K. 2. Lots of conversation from various people along the lines of "we just hired some guys to get ready for FOA-xx" or "we picked up some guys to integrate with the new NERC requirements" where FOA-xx describes one of the many stimulus grants -- at the time many had not been awarded. Now that they have been "awarded" many companies are hiring people to do the jobs. The contracts w/ the gov't still arent signed, so this money is not actually listed as spent yet. I am personally involved w/ a couple of these, this is how it works. 3. Industry meetings/conferences have gotten bigger in terms of # of attendees. Many of the people selling software are new entries to the market. As for: * Do you really think that the borrowed money wouldn't have created any jobs? * I have no idea what you are talking about. I never said anything about borrowed money. Which borrowed money? Sure more money may have created more jobs, but at least in the power sector, even when credit was good and easy there wasn't this level of interest and job creation. About your last statement I totally agree: money spent on something I don't like doesnt enter the economy, therefore cannot possibly be helping things. (actually thats unfair, you seem like the type susceptible to poe's law so heres a bit of help: that last sentence was sarcasm).
- MaysonL 17y agoFor a contrary view, see the facts: http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2010/02/assessing-the-stimulus.html http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2010/02/assessing-the-stimulus... and: http://www.econbrowser.com/archives/2010/02/assessing_the_s.html http://www.econbrowser.com/archives/2010/02/assessing_the_s....