4 ms·
Unlike Red Hat, Canonical are a bad company (ethics wise), mostly sponging off Open Source projects. :( Very few in the Open Source Community would cry if they
by justinclift 11y ago
Unlike Red Hat, Canonical are a bad company (ethics wise), mostly sponging off Open Source projects. :(
Very few in the Open Source Community would cry if they were to disappear.
- jcastro 11y agoPlease. Canonical has written millions of lines of Free Software code.
- justinclift 11y agoAnd they've being unethical many times as well. I have personal experience of this. :(
- EGreg 11y agoSo what is the code of ethics for this industry? And which large organization upholds it the best?
- xemoka 11y agoCare to share your experiences?
- justinclift 11y agoI'd rather not get sued. :( Can discuss privately though, if it's relevant to you and you're not employed/contracted/related to Canonical.
- ausjke 11y agoI don't know how bad it is, however I use Ubuntu on my desktop daily for free and I appreciate that, I don't see Redhat provides that though(ever since Redhat dumped Desktop users after Redhat 8/9 release many years back).
- lmz 11y agoFedora? Any of the RHEL recompiles?
- derekp7 11y agoFedora would be great if they did periodic LTS releases -- and it wouldn't really take much effort, as they sort of do this now by basing a given version of RHEL off a given Fedora release. So the work that goes into keeping RHEL 7 up to date could be applied to Fedora 19 without too much hassle.
- justinclift 11y agoderekp7: Sounds like the CentOS desktop/workstation builds would be more your kind of thing?
- justinclift 11y agoHmmmm, there is Fedora, which is Red Hat's kind of equivalent, and also CentOS. Guessing you're already aware of those and they don't work as well for you?
- slgeorge 11y agoIt's really a matter of priorities. When RH started 'server' was the focus and became the revenue generator. Workstation was the area they expanded into, in my opinion. When Ubuntu started the focus was on the 'desktop' (meaning general users). And Cloud became the big server-side change that drove growth - meaning developer-centric technologies and cloud delivery. For those reasons, both companies / communities tend to have a different DNA.
- bemused 11y agoagreed, but not sure if Red Hats embrace&extend is any better - all corporate entities seeking too much influence/power in the oss ecosystem should be carefully watched
- ausjke 11y agoAt least the systemd initiated by a Redhat employee was a bit too intrusive to the OSS ecosystem in my opinion.
- digi_owl 11y agoCanonical is more ham fisted, but RH seem more and more insidious. If you look at some of the more controversial maintainers of various Linux related projects, they are on RH payroll (but you have to dig a big to learn that, as quite often they are presented as individuals). This means that communication and coordination between them can happen across corporate channels rather than public ones, and only reach public channels after they have started applying the patches. Look at cgroups for example. Initial development was done by two guys out of Google. But now its maintainer is on RH payroll. And he has upped and decided that it needs to be reworked to have one user space manager. And who else but another RH employee has such a manager ready and waiting? While a third party project has to scramble to catch up with the changes.
- groovy2shoes 11y agoUlrich Drepper, Lennart Poettering, Kay Sievers, ... Back in high school, I used to look up to RedHat. Having attended NC State (RedHat HQ was on campus when I attended), it was my dream job to work on open source software at RedHat. But now, I hate RedHat. They have too much control and influence over the Linux ecosystem, and aren't exactly acting in everyone's best interests. I strongly dislike the direction Linux has been heading in for the last few years, and RedHat is largely (though not single-handedly) responsible for that.