3 ms·
The real problem is that these courses often teach a specific operating system or a specific office suite in an extremely facile manner. They're glorified typin
by stcredzero 17y ago
The real problem is that these courses often teach a specific operating system or a specific office suite in an extremely facile manner. They're glorified typing courses. That means when Microsoft changes the locations of buttons in Word, students' knowledge is obsolete. Even programming courses in high school (and many colleges) are tied to specific programming languages, not general concepts. A good course teaches a mix of theory and application, but most computer courses can't even handle application right.
This bothers me a lot. Not only are lots of "computer literacy" courses teaching stuff that will one day be trivia, but lots of supposed Computer Science education is over involved with particular programming language trivia. Heck, a lot of hiring nowadays is over-involved with such trivia.
Contrast this with stuff that kids do with eToys in Squeak. Kids using an "Object-paint" program to simultaneously explore vector algebra, programming, and robotics, without the words "vector" and "robots" even needing to be mentioned.
Get the mechanics out of the way so our minds can get on with the essentials.
- lurkinggrue 17y agoIn the 80s I learned more from pirating software on a Commodore 64 than I did in computer classes in school. I got the skill of figuring out a piece of software with no help or documentation. The computer equivalent of "teaching a man to fish" I suppose. Shame schools don't teach exploration and play with computers.
- stcredzero 17y agoYah, mon! Leaving a curious 11 year old alone with an Apple II and some manuals is worth a hundred "facile" computer courses. Shame schools don't teach exploration and play with computers. Squeak eToys were all about that!
- C3MDigital 17y agoThat's what happened to me when I was 11. My dad brought home an apple IIe and some manuals. I saved my allowance and bought a 300 baud zoom modem and 4 years later "The Authorities" came banging on the door at 3 a.m and confiscated my precious Apple and all my notes. Moral of the story: I'm now a professional member of the I.T. Industry