3 ms·
In my opinion, this article fails to draw a crucial line: the limit between what a user has to know and what he can ignore. Speaking of cars, users have extens
by loup-vaillant 17y ago
In my opinion, this article fails to draw a crucial line: the limit between what a user has to know and what he can ignore.
Speaking of cars, users have extensive knowledge of it. To the point that no one can legally drive a car without a driving licence. This represents dozens of hours of specialized learning and training.
And I was talking about a single purpose device. Computers have many purposes. No amount of user friendliness is going to hide this essential complexity. No matter what we do, users will have to know basic things like the difference between a computer and a program, between a browser and a the Internet, or between the address bar and the search box. If they don't, they could lose their privacy or their money. Just like driving left without looking can be lethal.
Many computer users lack this kind of knowledge. The only way we can give them a "great experience" is by teaching first. Until we do, they will stay dependent, helpless, and happy. (At least as far as computers are concerned, which is further and further, these days.)
- GHFigs 17y agoThe only way we can give them a "great experience" is by teaching first. Who do you mean by "we" and what exactly do you think should be taught?
- loup-vaillant 17y ago"We" are developers, teachers, and even just any people who know some very basic stuff well. And we should teach: First the very basics. What is a computer? A program? An OS? A network? The internet? A web browser? A web site? A URL? A search engine? A file? A text editor? Email? Web based mail? Then, a bit about privacy and security. What is a virus? An anti-virus? A firewall? Spam? Fishing? Spam filters? Cryptography? TLS? How to spy on your husband? Can you trust strangers and companies on line (compared to IRL)? What is a weak password? And finally, a crash programming course in a super-easy programming language so they can write a hello world, do some calculations, and a basic interactive program (like a dichotomy game). It shouldn't take more than a few hours (maybe even just one). But it definitely should teach that computer errors are often programmer errors. That it is possible to do personalized automation of tedious tasks. Ideally, all these things should be taught with the help of GNU/linux machines. Not only to push the philosophy, but also to put everyone in an unfamiliar environment, then get them familiar with it. Just to teach them that they can actually learn.