5 ms·
Clicking around [0], one finds that Global's business isn't even really based on selling foam arrows. No, they sell franchises to "Archery Tag® Licensees", to w
by jessaustin 11y ago
Clicking around [0], one finds that Global's business isn't even really based on selling foam arrows. No, they sell franchises to "Archery Tag® Licensees", to whom they then sell foam arrows. Then we learn:
"We do not guarantee regions, cities, or areas for our Licensees. We believe that having more Licensees in one area brings a larger brand awareness for Archery Tag®."
What a fucking scam. No wonder they're patent trolls. They already make a living screwing over their franchisees, why not try to screw over everyone else too?
[0] http://archerytag.com/faqs http://archerytag.com/faqs
- wyattpeak 11y agoI never thought I'd find myself defending a plaintiff in a patent lawsuit, but some of HN has really gone off the deep end with this anti-patent nonsense. This is a company who are defending their legally granted competitive advantage in a field in which they actually compete. I don't know that I consider a foam arrow sufficiently non-obvious to patent, but that's neither here nor there. Not only is this not troll-like, this is precisely the sort of situation for which patents were designed. Someone comes up with an idea; thinks, "huh, this idea would be easy to steal"; and applies for protection against it being stolen. A patent does not have to be on a final good or service, and owning a patent does not oblige you to sell a product to anyone who asks. If you have a patent on industrial machinery to protect your own production chain, you're not required to build one for anyone who is willing to put up the cash for it. It is nevertheless reasonable for you to sue someone who copies it - "they won't sell it to me" is not a defence against patent infringement. To draw a rather apt analogy - there is a laser tag company in my parts (basically you run around in a darkened room shooting each other with guns that fire a little IR laser) - they don't sell their equipment to anyone who asks - it's a competitive advantage for their venues. I don't know whether or not they have patents, but I don't see how you could reasonably argue that they shouldn't have them if they designed the equipment, or that they should be required to provide that equipment to others. If they were required to do that, what would be the point of the patent? And just to save accusations of cherry-picking, I agree with you about the non-guaranteed region rah rah, but it's rather beside the point.
- jessaustin 11y agoThis entire post is beside the point. I was talking about a franchising scam. These are not the business practices of a successful manufacturer successfully selling its valuable products. Apple and Samsung don't pull this kind of shit. This sort of thing preys on unsophisticated people who have a bit of money saved, by separating them from that money before they've seen enough to know how valuable (or not) the foam arrow product is. Read the first sentence of the FAQ: "Pricing details are available when an application to be a Licensee is approved..." I'm all for caveat emptor, but once they've crossed that line they've lost the moral status to demand society's assistance in punishing competitors. Besides, what are we talking about here? Any 9yo could figure out how to attach a foam tip to an arrow. They've spent far more time obtaining patents and setting up complicated commercial schemes than they have developing a product. The entire patent system is seen by many as harmful and unnecessary. This isn't the example that's going to prove it's not.
- wyattpeak 11y agoHow is it a franchising scam? I'm agreeing that not guaranteeing an operating area is a bit shit, but reports (from within this very thread, no less), suggest that it is very much a real and, more, worthwhile, outfit. Then again, I don't really care if it's good or a pile of shit, there's no law against having a crappy product. Withholding pricing details is pretty standard for franchises. I would probably agree (somewhat) with a point that franchising as a system often tries to take advantage of unsophisticated people, but I don't see much evidence that this is anything more than par for the course. > Any 9yo could figure out how to attach a foam tip to an arrow. As I said, I didn't disagree with the obviousness, though it's become murkier, read more discussion below. > They've spent far more time obtaining patents and setting up complicated commercial schemes than they have developing a product. Feel free to back this up any time you like.
- Natanael_L 11y agoYou seem to be entirely skipping over the novelty requirement as well as non-obviousness.