4 ms·
I don't think the distinction between autonomy and influence/power is so clear-cut in practice. The article defines autonomy as the absence of unwanted influen
by kijin 11y ago
I don't think the distinction between autonomy and influence/power is so clear-cut in practice.
The article defines autonomy as the absence of unwanted influence. But in a human society, unwanted influence is not something you can simply opt out of. Having autonomy without isolating yourself from the rest of the society means having at least some degree of influence over those who would like to influence you in unwanted ways.
As long as there are people out there (politicians, marketers, burglars, terrorists, etc.) who are trying their damnedest to influence you, the only way you can achieve autonomy is to be able to tell them to get the fuck off your lawn. Sometimes you need to push people physically off your lawn. Sometimes you need to kill them, because they would kill you if you don't. An autonomous person without effective power will quickly cease to be autonomous.
So autonomy is just another form of power. Some might even say that everything is power, and it's not just empty rhetoric.
- digi_owl 11y agoMakes me think of something i ran into about the freedom concept that was bouncing around at the time of the American revolution (and thus inspiring and influencing the founding fathers). I think it boiled down to freedom being the absence of coercion in any form.