3 ms·
Few people would describe RSA as a patent troll. Few people would describe Intellectual Ventures as anything but. In between, there's a wide spectrum of entit
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Few people would describe RSA as a patent troll. Few people would describe Intellectual Ventures as anything but. In between, there's a wide spectrum of entities with varying degrees of contribution, sympathy, and abuse. Whether any particular litigant qualifies as a patent troll depends heavily on who is speaking.
As far as definitions of "abuse", for one definition, see http://patentlyo.com/patent/2011/09/rader-patent-litigation.html http://patentlyo.com/patent/2011/09/rader-patent-litigation.... : 'someone simply seeking litigation-cost settlements, or, in other words, "any party that attempts to enforce a patent far beyond its actual value or contribution to the prior art."' Newegg provided another clear and concise definition; both seem quite reasonable.
The phrase "foam-arrow lawsuit" suggests rather strongly that those definitions probably apply here.
The phrase as used by Newegg had the desired effect with their target audiences. And if using the phrase "patent troll" contributes to increased vilification of offensive patent use in general, I don't have any problem with that, either.
- monochromatic 11y ago> The phrase as used by Newegg had the desired effect with their target audiences. Exactly my point. It's using a dirty word in an unusual way to cast aspersions. > And if using the phrase "patent troll" contributes to increased vilification of offensive patent use in general, I don't have any problem with that, either. One man's "offensive" is another man's ordinary.