8 ms·
I've spoken to people who were convicted of a crime, spent some time in prison, and were then transferred to a medium secure forensic unit for treatment for the
by DanBC 11y ago
I've spoken to people who were convicted of a crime, spent some time in prison, and were then transferred to a medium secure forensic unit for treatment for their severe mental illness.
Every single one of them said they preferred the prison to the hospital.
This is because prisoners have sentences that they serve, but patients don't - they're just treated until they're well enough to go back to the prison population.
In general "I have a severe mental illness" is not enough to help a defendant get off. The test is something like "I have a severe mental illness, and it was controlling me during my time, and I did not know what I was doing". If we just look at the population of people with a mental illness we see that most of them don't meet this strict requirement.
Of course, this in England. I guess things are different in the US.
- Avshalom 11y agoIt's that way in at least some cases in the US too. I mean no one has any sympathy for sex offenders but for instance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coalinga_State_Hospital https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coalinga_State_Hospital can/does hold people indefinitely.