2 ms·
> Global is asserting questionable IP rights aggressively and counting on the high cost of defensive litigation to win, so we consider it a troll Glad to see t
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
> Global is asserting questionable IP rights aggressively and counting on the high cost of defensive litigation to win, so we consider it a troll
Glad to see this high-profile acknowledgement that "patent troll" doesn't exclusively mean "non-practicing entity".
- fleitz 11y agoOften NPEs are not considered trolls, such as universities.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoDepends on who's doing the describing. Some university offices of "technology licensing" do act like patent trolls.
- Natanael_L 11y agoARM is a good example, they don't really manufacture any hardware. They license out rights to develop and sell hardware using their base designs. But they're a rare species...
- monochromatic 11y ago> Glad to see this high-profile acknowledgement that "patent troll" doesn't exclusively mean "non-practicing entity". Except that's exactly what it means (unless it means less than that--excluding universities and the like).
- JoshTriplett 11y agoThat might be how you're choosing to use it, but I've seen widespread usage of "patent troll" to mean anyone abusing patents in a variety of ways, whether they make a product or not. So it depends on who's doing the describing. In this case, Newegg's attorney concisely described another type of patent troll.
- monochromatic 11y agoQuestion: if it means something other than NPE, then what vague definition of "abuse" should we be relying on? Because if a company is making a patented product, and someone infringes that patent, and the company sues them... and THAT'S patent trolling, then literally anything can count as patent trolling. No. Words have meaning. Stop trying to pervert their meanings for effect.
- x1798DE 11y agoI think the grandparent post pretty clearly demonstrated a pretty good definition: > Global is asserting questionable IP rights aggressively and counting on the high cost of defensive litigation to win, so we consider it a troll If they are deliberately using shady claims (e.g. clearly overly broad interpretations of their patent) and counting on the high cost of litigation to get their desired outcome, I don't see what it matters whether they are a practicing or non practicing entity.
- monochromatic 11y agoEvery patent claim is questionable. Validity and enforceability are at issue in essentially every single patent case.
- aidenn0 11y agoTo me a patent troll has always been the patent equivalent of a SLAPP. Where you file not based on an expectation of winning, but that it will be less expensive for the defendant to settle than to fight the suit and win.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoFew people would describe RSA as a patent troll. Few people would describe Intellectual Ventures as anything but. In between, there's a wide spectrum of entities with varying degrees of contribution, sympathy, and abuse. Whether any particular litigant qualifies as a patent troll depends heavily on who is speaking. As far as definitions of "abuse", for one definition, see http://patentlyo.com/patent/2011/09/rader-patent-litigation.html http://patentlyo.com/patent/2011/09/rader-patent-litigation.... : 'someone simply seeking litigation-cost settlements, or, in other words, "any party that attempts to enforce a patent far beyond its actual value or contribution to the prior art."' Newegg provided another clear and concise definition; both seem quite reasonable. The phrase "foam-arrow lawsuit" suggests rather strongly that those definitions probably apply here. The phrase as used by Newegg had the desired effect with their target audiences. And if using the phrase "patent troll" contributes to increased vilification of offensive patent use in general, I don't have any problem with that, either.