3 ms·
As a shill for libertarian socialism, i am obviously glad to see controlled experiments that validate my prejudices about human nature. I switched jobs a few mo
by danharaj 11y ago
As a shill for libertarian socialism, i am obviously glad to see controlled experiments that validate my prejudices about human nature. I switched jobs a few months ago from a steady job with good benefits to a less steady job with no benefits because it gave me far more autonomy and independence. I know many people who are very ambitious and want to be their own bosses: few of them want to rule others. In fact, of the bosses i know, all of them are frustrated by having to order and direct people.
There is one pattern of thought that i think is missed by this experiment, but another one could just as well measure it too and i hope someone decides to: it's easier to order people to do what you think is right than it is to convince them that you are right. I think under circumstances where a person feels frustrated that their point of view isn't being validated by others they will have a greater tendency towards authoritarian power as opposed to autonomous power.
Certainly, how many of us have gone through the phase of growing up where we think that if everyone just listened to us and did what we said, everyone would be better off? I think well intentioned paternalism is a greater cause for authoritarian desires than narcissism and ego validation.
- mercurialshark 11y ago"I think well intentioned paternalism is a greater cause for authoritarian desires than narcissism and ego validation." This, absolutely.
- smartscience 11y agoLest we forget, that well-intentioned paternalism is sometimes entirely on target: on Reddit at the moment there's a link 'Engineer Who Blamed Himself For Not Stopping Challenger Launch Dies' http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/challenger-engineer-bob-ebeling-dies_us_56f09f3be4b09bf44a9e41f2 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/challenger-engineer-bob-...
- gph 11y agoYou're really stretching the definition of paternalism with that one.
- jessaustin 11y agoHow on earth could one consider that case to exemplify paternalism in any fashion? "Detail-oriented engineers overruled by schedule-obsessed management." Film at eleven.
- smartscience 11y agoHe talked about bringing a shotgun to work to stop the launch. Perhaps it would be better to say it exemplifies what the paternalists imagine they are doing.
- Natsu 11y agoOne could more easily see the managers as the 'parents' who thought they knew better than the engineers below them, though, making it say quite the opposite of what you are trying to say.