3 ms·
I don't think this kind of reductive thinking, if taken into more political and behavioral extreme areas works. Lets try this mental exercise, what is the phys
by mc32 11y ago
I don't think this kind of reductive thinking, if taken into more political and behavioral extreme areas works.
Lets try this mental exercise, what is the physical damage to me if I get raped? In extreme cases one could get infected with a potentially deadly STD, or if a woman, onr may become pregnant, but in many cases at the physical level, it's not all that different from regular sex between people. The main difference is granting permission to sex, or not granting permission to sex.
That makes all the difference, or most.
So, you see, it's easy to break things down into oblivion, the thing is, this is what, in part, makes is human, why we don't follow the same kind of courtship other animals accept as part of nature. Or why otherwise rationalized behavior is not normally accepted.
Restorative justice won't cut it here.
I of course understand my example is extreme, but I simply want to point out that there is a point where these ideas break down as a solution to unjust sentencing.
- aninhumer 11y ago>what is the physical damage to you if you get raped? I don't think the parent was suggesting only physical damage be considered. They discussed several examples of emotional damage. EDIT: And I'm not really sure why you're calling their post reductive either, it seemed fairly nuanced, and ended with "It's a very deep question. Not something that HN will answer in a thread."
- eanzenberg 11y agoThe OP kind of was when they brushed away the burglary they experienced as, not much monetary loss and the lost feeling of security was back went away after a few weeks. To feel secure in one's home is f*&(ing important. I'm not equating it to rape, but it's that intangible feeling of lost of trust you cannot quickly brush away.
- whitegrape 11y agoEmotional damage is interesting. In many senses it's entirely one's own fault, if one feels emotionally damaged / offended / distraught. But it's an uncommon mental discipline to get yourself to feel differently. That intangible feeling of lost trust can be quickly brushed away, the OP is an example of that since they did it in weeks, similarly rape actually doesn't end up being a huge deal for some victims. But it's pretty weird to start drafting up policies (like "let's punish less 'cause come on, he just threatened you with a knife and took your wallet, he didn't actually hurt you and your material losses were only the cost to get a new wallet and the small time it took to cancel any credit cards") that would only work on a small portion of the population with a certain level of mental discipline. The fact that some have it to various degrees and some don't is enough to make any suggestion requiring it to be pointless unless that suggestion includes "and kill / severely culturally shame anyone who does not have the discipline".
- philipov 11y agoThe error in thinking here is your equivocation of the emotional trauma of having your groceries stolen with being raped. Your conclusion is extreme, but it is not a logical conclusion.
- mc32 11y agoThe mental trauma of the crimes is stronger in some crimes than others but it still exists so to say, we'll restore to is a bit naive.